Updated stats:
Luke Hodge
250 games
22.1 disposals per game
167 career goals
2 x HFC Best & Fairest Winner (2005, 2010)
1 x HFC Best & Fairest Runner Up
3 x All Australian (2005, 2008, 2010)
1 x All Australian Captain (2010)
2 x Norm Smith Medalist (2008, 2014)
3 x Premiership Player (2008, 2013, 2014)
2 x Premiership Captain (2013, 2014)
1 x Jim Stynes Medalist (2014)
1 x AFLPA Best Captain (2014)
Sam Mitchell
261 games
25.65 disposals per game
61 career goals
NAB AFL Rising Star 2003
4 x HFC Best & Fairest Winner (2006, 2009, 2011, 2012)
1 x HFC Best & Fairest Runner Up
2 x All Australian (2011, 2013)
3 x Premiership Player (2008, 2013, 2014)
1 x Premiership Captain (2008)
1 x Brownlow Medalist (2012*)
Hodge wins on stats, but only just. Both have been brilliant. Went for Hodge, though that might just be due to my man crush.