Luke Hodge v Chris Judd

[Jugada]

Pike is better, Pavlich may have played more games but 0 premierships is a blight on his footy resume.

I rest my case

 

[Gone Critical]

Pike is better, Pavlich may have played more games but 0 premierships is a blight on his footy resume.

Not sure that sort of humour works on the net

 

[MinerBoy]

Not sure what the purpose of the poster's bump was. The issue isn't topical and the poster provided nothing to the discussion.

 

[Xtreme]

Not sure that sort of humour works on the net

I am serious

 

[Gone Critical]

I am serious

Sure you are

 

[Xtreme]

Sure you are

I trust someone that will look at me directly in the face while he whacks me opposed to Judd who resorts to chicken wings and poking unsuspecting players eyeballs out.

 

[Lethality]

If it were Judd at West Coast, then it would be no contest. Unfortunately Judd wasn't as good at Carlton, and in the last few years he really fell away.

 

[Elite Master]

Love how it's only the Hawthorn supporters that are claiming Hodge is better. It's clear who is wearing the rose tinted glasses.

 

[Lethality]

Love how it's only the Hawthorn supporters that are claiming Hodge is better. It's clear who is wearing the rose tinted glasses.

39% of the vote wouldn't just be Hawthorn supporters, who are only 6.5% of the league.

 

[Masqualero]

Hodge 2 Norm Smith's (better than a brownlow - the prestige of that award went down the gurgler when it became obvious it was an umpires pet medal and cruddy MVP awards) and 4 premierships. Premiership medals overrule mickey mouse awards like the brownlow and mvp award.

Judd has a normie as well... 1 norm from 2 GFs. So he actually has a better strikerate than hodge for normsmiths.

 

[Lethality]

Judd has a normie as well... 1 norm from 2 GFs. So he actually has a better strikerate than hodge for normsmiths.

Higher strike rate would be expected from less than half the Grand Finals.

 

[Masqualero]

Higher strike rate would be expected from less than half the Grand Finals.

I was more making the point that Judd has a norm smith as well, but fair point.

 

[JD Tomahawk]

Not even close

 

[Xtreme]

Not even close

That's correct Hodge is so far ahead of Judd in both football success, football skill and as a person it's amazing people think Judd is equal let alone ahead of Hodgey!

 

[freddy mercury]

Juddy by the length of a straight.

 

[JD Tomahawk]

That's correct Hodge is so far ahead of Judd in both football success, football skill and as a person it's amazing people think Judd is equal let alone ahead of Hodgey!

In favour of Judd.

 

[Xtreme]

In favour of Judd.

I'm sure Judd is French for Hodge

 

[Hawk Dork]

Judd has a normie as well... 1 norm from 2 GFs. So he actually has a better strikerate than hodge for normsmiths.

That Normie probably should have been LRTs

 

[Elite Master]

That's correct Hodge is so far ahead of Judd in both football success, football skill and as a person it's amazing people think Judd is equal let alone ahead of Hodgey!

The only thing Hodge has that Judd doesn't is the reputation of a good bloke.

 

[Xtreme]

The only thing Hodge has that Judd doesn't is the reputation of a good bloke.

Judd only has 1 premiership compared to Hodge's 4
Judd only has one Norm Smith compared to Hodge's 2

MVP awards and brownlows mean s**t as their value has plummeted over the last 20 years thanks to umpire meddling and AFL corruption

 

[Masqualero]

Judd only has 1 premiership compared to Hodge's 4
Judd only has one Norm Smith compared to Hodge's 2

MVP awards and brownlows mean s**t as their value has plummeted over the last 20 years thanks to umpire meddling and AFL corruption

The only thing Hodge is better than Judd at is drink driving and getting drafted to Hawthorne. I would have included sniping opposition players when they are not looking but Judds knowledge and execution of both pressure points and the chickenwing armbar puts him ahead IMO.

Judd>>>>Hodge

 

[Xtreme]

The only thing Hodge is better than Judd at is drink driving and getting drafted to Hawthorne. I would have included sniping opposition players when they are not looking but Judds knowledge and execution of both pressure points and the chickenwing armbar puts him ahead IMO.

Judd>>>>Hodge

Hodge is a better bloke like I said previously he will look at the person in the eye before he roughs them up. Judd resorts to poking someone in the eyeball before making his move.

 

[Seeds]

Hodge is a better bloke like I said previously he will look at the person in the eye before he roughs them up. Judd resorts to poking someone in the eyeball before making his move.

Did he look murphy in the eye when he broke his jaw? Interested to know because if he did it changes my whole perception of the incident.

 

[Xtreme]

Did he look murphy in the eye when he broke his jaw? Interested to know because if he did it changes my whole perception of the incident.

You'll have to ask him that one

 

[kid_a]

Judd = freak, once in a decade kind of player.
Hodge= great, reliable, 2-4 in every team kind of player.

I pick Judd