Luke Shuey vs Nat Fyfe

[jakefooty23]

If you could choose 1 of these players to be on your team, who would you choose and why? I made this thread to hear opinions from other people that aren't Freo or West Coast supporters.
I think both players are having great seasons and are both jets but I think Fyfe is the better player and I would have him over Shuey, even though Fyfe has abit of injury history, I think when he is playing he has a much larger influence/impact then Shuey.
INB4 "voting Shuey because OP is a Freo supporter", this is an actual question, just please just give your honest opinion.

 

[Roadto2018]

Uhh what on earth?

And that's coming from someone who made a thread about Giovanni Mountain-Silbery

 

[jakefooty23]

Uhh what on earth?

And that's coming from someone who made a thread about Giovanni Mountain-Silbery

Yeah ummm, I posted It on the wrong board lol. Can a mod move or delete this?

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Unless you were posting this in the bay, there is no board this question belongs on. No one bar the most biased Eagles supporter would take Shuey over Fyfe

 

[bradburygold]

I assume you mean would you rather 1 fyfe or 2x shueys?

 

[adammania9]

I think you is in the wrong board.

To answer your question; Shuey is a really good midfielder who uses the ball well and moves it forward on the attack but he lacks that game-breaking style that Fyfe possesses. Throw Fyfe in the centre and he wins the majority of clearances when the game is in the balance and there are very players if any at all I would prefer to have in a team that Nat Fyfe. He is a star.

 

[La Dolce Vita]

freo fans are cute

still obsessed with West coast i see

 

[Moist Biscuit]

gym4life The floors yours bud.

 

[gym4life]

gym4life The floors yours bud.

I said he was the surer pick due to injuries and personally I would pick him, doesn't mean I expect others to agree.

 

[wraglesweb]

I think you is in the wrong board.

To answer your question; Shuey is a really good midfielder who uses the ball well and moves it forward on the attack but he lacks that game-breaking style that Fyfe possesses. Throw Fyfe in the centre and he wins the majority of clearances when the game is in the balance and there are very players if any at all I would prefer to have in a team that Nat Fyfe. He is a star.

Exactly two different players and in a midfield you need balance.

It would be more do I pick

Fyfe
Bontempelli
Cripps
Pendelbury
Dangerfield

etc etc


Then would look at players with a little bit more outside dash to complement them

Shuey
Hannebery
Neale
Trelour

etc etc you get the picture

Fremantle supporters are that hard up to get something over West Coast supporters they put this sort of thread up ......

Can't even put it in the right place .....

 

[jakefooty23]

Exactly two different players and in a midfield you need balance.

It would be more do I pick

Fyfe
Bontempelli
Cripps
Pendelbury
Dangerfield

etc etc


Then would look at players with a little bit more outside dash to complement them

Shuey
Hannebery
Neale
Trelour

etc etc you get the picture

Fremantle supporters are that hard up to get something over West Coast supporters they put this sort of thread up ......

Can't even put it in the right place .....

Don't Be salty. I've just started a thread, I haven't ripped on Shuey or anything. Yes I put it in the wrong board, but I have no clue how to move it so until a mod moves or deletes it, it's here I guess lol

 

[wraglesweb]

Don't Be salty. I've just started a thread, I haven't ripped on Shuey or anything. Yes I put it in the wrong board, but I have no clue how to move it so until a mod moves or deletes it, it's here I guess lol

I'm not Salty it's just a stupid thread and won't grow legs. So mod might aswell delete it now

 

[jakefooty23]

I'm not Salty it's just a stupid thread and won't grow legs. So mod might aswell delete it now

Lol, you seem quite salty to me

 

[wraglesweb]

Lol, you seem quite salty to me

And why would I be salty ?

Your the one who went on the Shuey thread and got your back up because one Eagle poster said he would take Shuey this year over Fyfe .....

And had to make a full thread about it because you couldn't handle that one poster thought that......

Gee whiz and you call me salty !!!

 

[La Dolce Vita]

I would take Shuey in a heartbeat

Full of heart and character..Plays for the club and his team mates love him..

Fyfe...not so much

 

[jakefooty23]

And why would I be salty ?

Your the one who went on the Shuey thread and got your back up because one Eagle poster said he would take Shuey this year over Fyfe .....

And had to make a full thread about it because you couldn't handle that one poster thought that......

Gee whiz and you call me salty !!!

Im not salty at all, all I've done is made a thread (put it in the wrong place though lol) and you've come on here and said nothing positive and brang absolutely nothing to this thread but a whole bunch of salt. There has been like 22 votes and 5 to Shuey, ive seen worse vs threads...Just leave if your not going to add anything good to the thread.

 

[jakefooty23]

I think you is in the wrong board.

To answer your question; Shuey is a really good midfielder who uses the ball well and moves it forward on the attack but he lacks that game-breaking style that Fyfe possesses. Throw Fyfe in the centre and he wins the majority of clearances when the game is in the balance and there are very players if any at all I would prefer to have in a team that Nat Fyfe. He is a star.

Yeah I put it in the wrong board aha, I want a mod to move it if that's possible

 

[wraglesweb]

Im not salty at all, all I've done is made a thread (put it in the wrong place though lol) and you've come on here and said nothing positive and brang absolutely nothing to this thread but a whole bunch of salt. There has been like 22 votes and 5 to Shuey, ive seen worse vs threads...Just leave if your not going to add anything good to the thread.

No your trying to prove a point too one poster on the Shuey thread.

Don't pretend your not

Anyway good luck with the s**t thread

 

[jakefooty23]

No your trying to prove a point too one poster on the Shuey thread.

Don't pretend your not

Anyway good luck with the s**t thread

Thanks, sorry for bringing you to tears by making a thread you don't like

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

the insecurity is strong with this one

 

[bird_man]

Considering he'll be a Saint in a few months time, I'm obviously going to say Fyfe....

 

[jakefooty23]

the insecurity is strong with this one

No

 

[jakefooty23]

Considering he'll be a Saint in a few months time, I'm obviously going to say Fyfe....

Good luck with that

 

[Wild Bill]

I hate threads that are started by posters from the team with the clearly better player.

 

[themidlandmaster]

Jack watts