Lukey McGuane! [2012 Thread]

[fleabitten]

Loved Lukey tonight and that last play was great to watch. Wife has already requested a Luke McGuane fantasy for later tonight.

 

[Harmichael]

Just accept he was a very important player for us tonight.

Be happy ya sad sack

I have and I am.

Like I said - Richmond Win > Internet debates

Richmond win v Scum > everything

 

[TJTIGER]

Don't mind so much that he missed the goal. His effort put the ball back in Tiger hands, removing any chance/possibility they could win it.

 

[Jammo1111]

Luke was about 6/10 and the other one Jacko was 8/10!!

 

[THE_GUN]

LMAO to the GUN posters on here told ya lukey would stick it right up ya

Just got home from the game & Straight onto the net !

He was ok, not great & not shit , just ok done his job - Still had his mcgoof moments
But in a strong supply from the midfield and having the 3rd defender thats the least he could do



But Tyrone ------------------------- F****ng Awesome

 

[theflea]

Just got home from the game & Straight onto the net !

He was ok, not great & not shit , just ok done his job - Still had his mcgoof moments
But in a strong supply from the midfield and having the 3rd defender thats the least he could do



But Tyrone ------------------------- F****ng Awesome

come on mate give credit where its due. He did his job perfectly.

 

[THE_GUN]

come on mate give credit where its due. He did his job perfectly.

Mate i believe i did give him the credit he deserved - He wasnt fantastic but was ok
There were alot of times where he misjudged the flight of the ball & was out positioned, Trust me 'I WATCHED HIM VERY CLOSELY TONIGHT"

 

[Del65166]

Played his role extraordinary well. Fwd pressure and couple of scores

 

[HKTiger]

Mate i believe i did give him the credit he deserved - He wasnt fantastic but was ok
There were alot of times where he misjudged the flight of the ball & was out positioned, Trust me 'I WATCHED HIM VERY CLOSELY TONIGHT"

Buy a clue. I'll even give you the $5. Check out the last quarter and watch who took contested marks for us and gave us a way out of the defensive 50. If you'd watched him that closely you might have an idea.

 

[Calcium Man]

Just got home from the game & Straight onto the net !

He was ok, not great & not shit , just ok done his job - Still had his mcgoof moments
But in a strong supply from the midfield and having the 3rd defender thats the least he could do



But Tyrone ------------------------- F****ng Awesome

Pretty much what everyone in this thread has been saying. He will make mistakes but as long as he does his job I.e good defensive pressure and a couple of goals.

 

[nobulltiger]

All I can say is to the haters, told ya so.

Lukey Mcguane

 

[Tigerrific]

I love you Luke.

 

[Equus]

Forewarning you guys to keep it civil.

 

[THE_GUN]

Look he did his job, Nothing outstandin nothing shit - just did his job
but we were playing carlton with a average defence at best and he has the 3rd best tall defender
He kicked 2 goals & 1 was dues to a lucky 50mtr penalty but thems the breaks and he got it

But seriously he wasnt fantastic - He was just ok

 

[sante]

McGun has to stick now.

 

[tigerT]

Look he did his job, Nothing outstandin nothing shit - just did his job
but we were playing carlton with a average defence at best and he has the 3rd best tall defender
He kicked 2 goals & 1 was dues to a lucky 50mtr penalty but thems the breaks and he got it

But seriously he wasnt fantastic - He was just ok

Nah he was very good tonight. Suggest you watch the replay.

 

[Jammo1111]

Luke competed really well, contributed to a few other scores and was easily worth his spot. And no big clangers.

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Lukey missed that last easy kick for goal in the dying seconds of the match that would have iced the cake...but he was'nt On his own in that regard...
Plenty of others were missing shots and hitting the post as well...he certainly was'nt robinson crusoe in that regard...
But he did compete...well done Lukey......but gee how good would it have been if you had slotted that goal......

 

[Jammo1111]

The other player who is on the fringe is Robyn Nahas. Despite being the only fresh player he was underwhelming in that cardiac last quarter.

 

[_Wang_]

Love how he smashed the packs.. Good game Lukey!!

 

[purrrrrrrrrrfect]

He did well, just makes me think that Hartley & RFC would do well to target Gumbleton for next season to play that role now.

 

[Laffy2Chaffey2Daffy]

Lukey missed that last easy kick for goal in the dying seconds of the match that would have iced the cake...but he was'nt On his own in that regard...
Plenty of others were missing shots and hitting the post as well...he certainly was'nt robinson crusoe in that regard...
But he did compete...well done Lukey......but gee how good would it have been if you had slotted that goal......

He did his job and milked the clock. and he deliberately missed so the bleubaggers could suffer in their jocks about what might have been if they weren't suck losers.

 

[Bojangles17]

Love how he smashed the packs.. Good game Lukey!!

**** me he played well, if theres one thing McG can do its contest....not once was he outmarked...took some grabs kicked a couple and by gee that tackle in the end was textbook...well done Luke a great stage to play career best game

 

[THE_GUN]

He did well, just makes me think that Hartley & RFC would do well to target Gumbleton for next season to play that role now.

Todd Elton

Lukey missed that last easy kick for goal in the dying seconds of the match that would have iced the cake...but he was'nt On his own in that regard...
Plenty of others were missing shots and hitting the post as well...he certainly was'nt robinson crusoe in that regard...
But he did compete...well done Lukey......but gee how good would it have been if you had slotted that goal......

What did you think of Tyrone Vickery's game

Nah he was very good tonight. Suggest you watch the replay.

I was at the game mate & watching him all night - whats the replay going to show me that i havnt already seen

 

[ShaneDoan]

Defs has earned his spot in the pocket over Nahas in my mind. Has been quite consistent for awhile now, going back to last season.