Thread starter
#1
Collingwood supporters:
If Pies win the flag this year, who would you rather be the coach in 2012 - Mick Malthouse or Nathan Buckley? (ignoring the contract).
Neutral supporters:
- Who do you think Collingwood would be better to keep Mick, or go with Bucks?
To me, it seems a very awkward and not an ideal situation for the Pies. I think they'll go back to back, meaning Bucks will take over at the peak of their powers. If I was Pies man, I'd be reluctant to say goodbye to Mick for a newby.
Thoughts?
If Pies win the flag this year, who would you rather be the coach in 2012 - Mick Malthouse or Nathan Buckley? (ignoring the contract).
Neutral supporters:
- Who do you think Collingwood would be better to keep Mick, or go with Bucks?
To me, it seems a very awkward and not an ideal situation for the Pies. I think they'll go back to back, meaning Bucks will take over at the peak of their powers. If I was Pies man, I'd be reluctant to say goodbye to Mick for a newby.
Thoughts?

