Make or break years!

[St-KriS]

Which player, if they dont perform this year, do you think will be booted out the door?

I think this applies to Brett Moyle and possibly Daniel Wulf although I love the guy (Actually work with his girlfriend's mum)

Any others?

 

[roach44]

Jason Blake: Did shows some good signs towards the latter stages of 2003, but if he doesn't go on with it he's in trouble.

Craig Callaghan: Needs his best year to have any chance of staying on for 2005.

Josh Houlihan: Surely if he doesn't crack it for at least 5 games he'll be delisted.

Brett Moyle: Will find it really tough to break into our midfield. Can find the pill, but is pretty slow and not the best kick. Proabably his last year.

Allan Murray: Had a good year for a rookie. Similar to Blake, he must go on with it. He lacks the quick decision making ability of Clarke, but has obvious talent.

Justin Peckett: Has pretty much said it'll be his last year anyway.

Troy Schwarze: Probably not up to AFL standard. Will be his last year.

Andrew Thompson: Unless he can take Steven Baker's tagging role, he'll be joining Burkey in the coaches box in 2005.

Brett Voss: If he has a year like last he'll be above average. Should improve and become our best small backman, but if his confidence falls, he might be in a bit of trouble.

Daniel Wulf: Is a dangerous prospect for the opposition to match up on. Quick, athletic and a good mark, but he just doesn't do enough. Unless he dramatically improves his consistancey, he'll be on his way to a third club.

Maybe a bit harsh, but lets hope the Sainters can at least crack the top 8, and maybe even the 2nd week of september!!!

 

[Rough_Edges]

Troy Schwarze and Callaghan owuld be the most likelys but Idon't think i'd like to see anyone get dropped in our Premiership year!!

Cheers, Future Heavyweight Champion!

 

[Kildonan]

Each and every year we will have to delist at least three players.

I think the brains trust at St Kilda are seeking stability and depth.

To that end we have recruited for depth at the end of last year and I expect a similar approach to this year -
minimum changes and trading for depth (whilst maybe retaining one or two picks for prime quality youngsters).

So I feel that many players like the list roach44 has posted is unlikely to be delisted but some of them probably will be.

 

[Wally16]

BLAKE WILL STAY

I think GT has greated the nucleus of the group now. Blake isnt going anywhere as I rate him somewhere between #18-24 of the 37 player group. Theres no one on the stkilda list who I would get rid of: Barring of course Thompson and Peckett whom I think will retire. We will only know by the end of year BUT the most likely at this stage would be:

TROY SCWHARZE
MOYLE
NICK STONE OR
Sadly WULF

 

[panthers]

I think callahan and Peckett will definately go and maybe Thompson