Rumour Marc Murphy upset/targeted ?

[burningdwarf]

It's funny you mention the number 16, how old was that school girl?? Yep beats captaining a club that's biggest achievements in the last 16 years is during the months of October to march.

You need to calm down, friend.

You're letting a really minor incident get to you a bit too much.

 

[Impunity!]

My understanding is it involves the best player to ever grace the football field.

Bullshit. Matt Priddis is a happily married man

 

[P1ET1ME]

What was the sledge?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Feerits Elf]

You need to calm down, friend.

You're letting a really minor incident get to you a bit too much.

And at 16, she was really minor.

Really, really minor.

 

[BigCarl]

Ha ha. The cheats label

It's funny you mention the number 16, how old was that school girl?? Yep beats captaining a club that's biggest achievements in the last 16 years is during the months of October to march.[/QUO

Actually we have made the finals numerous times in the last 16 years and 3 Grand Finals.

Not sure how old you are Grandpa but I've only been watching footy for the last twenty years and in that time Carlton has been THE WORST side in the competition - as evidenced by four wooden spoons (more than any other club).

Now if you are running some sort of ancient history class on good sides of the last millennium then you might get some interest from Collingwood supporters. I believe they were outstanding in the 1920's.

 

[Beer n Skittles]

Honest all the way though, publicly declared he may have been administered AOD9604 which totally confused ASADA and forced them to manufacture a bogus TB4 charge which was corruptly prosecuted by a pig circus over at CAS. No positive tests, no admissions, no whistleblowers and no evidence of TB4 at Essendon.

In a shit thread full of idiots this post is king

 

[Tushay]

Of course Carlton and Murphy want to keep quiet. If the rumour is true then Murphy doesn't want any more people to know his personal shame. His football shame is captaining a club that has been the competitions whipping boy for the past 16 years. Ten years of early draft picks and they're still rebuilding...

Ah, ok, so if a footy player sledges another about a personal matter it must be true, is that right?

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

I'm guessing he doesn't tackle people walking down the street either.

What a ridiculous, hyperbolic reaction to something that happens in every football game ever played.

Clearly not an over reaction given your captain has called Murphy to apologise and admitted that his team went too far.

Or is your captain making a ridiculous, hyperbolic reaction to something that happens in every football game ever played as well?

 

[3MM Superstar]

You need to calm down, friend.

You're letting a really minor incident get to you a bit too much.

I think you have me wrong. i have no problem with the minor incident at all.
It's the Moronic comment by one saint supporter that got me riled

 

[good4footy]

So the rumour is true?

If an apology makes Marc feel better about that then I'm happy we gave him one.

So the rumour is true? If an apology makes Milne feel better about that then I'm glad Malthouse gave him one.

 

[Farm Boy]

What was the sledge?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Carlisle told Murphy that his missus had "nice eyes". Murphy taken offence and started tearing up. He is just emotional I guess.

 

[AndyLucimitis]

I'm looking forward to the return match, that is if Murphy plays.

Unfortunately that won't happen until next year.

So you're looking forward to seeing him get another 28 touches and 2 goals as well. That's nice.

 

[theprospect]

Murphy really just wasted his time on a two time drug cheat.
Why take his word seriously

Didn't realise taking cocaine makes you a drug cheat. If you think that then 90% of the league are drug cheats.

 

[JeffDunne]

Clearly not an over reaction given your captain has called Murphy to apologise and admitted that his team went too far.

Or is your captain making a ridiculous, hyperbolic reaction to something that happens in every football game ever played as well?

Ever heard of PR?

The usual over-reactionaries in the media force clubs into a response. That's all this is.

 

[BigCarl]

It's funny you mention the number 16, how old was that school girl?? Yep beats captaining a club that's biggest achievements in the last 16 years is during the months of October to march.

Actually we have made the finals many times in the last 16 years, including 3 Grand Finals.

I'm not sure how old you are Granpa, but I've only been watching footy for the past twenty years. In that time Carlton have been THE WORST side in the competition as evidenced by four wooden spoons (more than any other club in that period). So own it.

However, if you are running an on-line ancient history class in "good sides of the last millennium" you may get some interest from Collingwood supporters. I believe they were jolly good back in the 1920's.

 

[Look2Me4Guidance]

So you're looking forward to seeing him get another 28 touches and 2 goals as well. That's nice.

So a poor man's Jack Billings?

 

[3MM Superstar]

Didn't realise taking cocaine makes you a drug cheat. If you think that then 90% of the league are drug cheats.

He got a strike against him, he was busted, he is dumb. officially he is a drug cheat

 

[mcfly7]

This is currently the best thread on bigfooty

 

[Navara79]

This is currently the best thread on bigfooty

Don't know about that. The Autopsy thread on your board after yesterdays game is pretty good

 

[PeaTea]

This is currently the best thread on bigfooty

I'm just loving scandals not involving my club for once.

 

[Arr0w]

Ever heard of PR?

The usual over-reactionaries in the media force clubs into a response. That's all this is.

So you're saying your Captain is only a puppet and doesn't stand up for what he thinks is right or wrong? Can't have it both ways JeffDunne

 

[burningdwarf]

Saints players said something bad, have attempted to apologise since.

Murphy probably shouldn't have gone out of his way to say something while Carlisle was injured on the ground.

I don't see the point in slamming each other's clubs and fan base, it really isn't a major story.

 

[ashep]

I'm not happy we apologized. Sledging is part of any sport. The more competitive the sport (NBA, etc) the more the sledging. Sledging is an effective way to put an opponent off of his game - to get an edge. It may be the difference between winning and losing. The fact we apologized to me is pathetic. You look at all the successful dynasty teams of the past 25 years, and more often than not the best teams were also the best sledges. If Murphy doesn't like what was said, then IMO there is a fair chance it is true, and if it is true then other players are just speaking the truth. If Murphy doesn't like the truth then maybe he shouldn't of taken his missus back.

Would sledging Crows players about what happened to Phil Walsh be cool with you?

Peanut.

 

[burningdwarf]

Would sledging Crows players about what happened to Phil Walsh be cool with you?

Peanut.

wtf?

 

[3MM Superstar]

Y

Actually we have made the finals many times in the last 16 years, including 3 Grand Finals.

I'm not sure how old you are Granpa, but I've only been watching footy for the past twenty years. In that time Carlton have been THE WORST side in the competition as evidenced by four wooden spoons (more than any other club in that period). So own it.

However, if you are running an on-line ancient history class in "good sides of the last millennium" you may get some interest from Collingwood supporters. I believe they were jolly good back in the 1920's.

You raised up history of last 16 years. If you have an issue with people raising history then don't do it yourself then.

Ps we were in the finals more recent than saints. Just sayin.