I would take him if Sloane leaves.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: St Kilda v Western Bulldogs - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Saints at 51% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Salt is realI heard he's going to Norf.
Only way he'd play finalsWould improve our vfl team significantly
Losing Murphy would set Carlton back 3 years.
???You think 3 years? Have hardly seen him in the previous two years, not sure it would make such of a difference.
Overrated.
I think just losing Gibbs & Murphy in two consecutive years will be detrimental for the club. Club leaders and senior bodies would take years to replace.You think 3 years? Have hardly seen him in the previous two years, not sure it would make such of a difference. Has stuck with the Blues through thick and thin and would like him to stay (but hand over the C to Cripps and / or Doc).
However if he decided to leave best wishes and no hard feelings, would be a great get for a team in the mix that has some midfield depth so he doesn't have to try and do the heavy lifting, his gut running is A1.
How could anyone credibly assert this in May?A recent article has him going to Geelong If he decides to leave.
Would improve our vfl team significantly
As a depth player or push Douglas out? Would pay overs as well
???
Played every game last year, won the B&F.
Can’t see him leaving, but would have him at the tiges in a heartbeat, IF he left for unders. A midfield of Dusty, Cotch, Prestia, Murphy, Grigg, Caddy is A+
I agree, Carlton would/should be trying to keep him! His experience alone is invaluable to your kids coming through the ranks. Just saying, if he was gettable and there was mutual agreement he was leaving, would love Richmond to throw their hat in the ringRichmond would be a side where he could get as close to his 2011 form as he could - would significantly hide his deficiencies while allowing his strengths to flourish. Sydney would also be one.
Would be happy with band 2 right now. Not near Gibbs value in terms of what would we receive due to contract. Would prefer he stays because he offers footskills and goalsense that we need and we have enough kids without adding in a late first rounder for the compo pick, but we definitely aren't getting band 1, although I guess there wouldn't be much difference for us in band 2 and 3 compo. Gibbs is the one that has set us back I think - although having Murphy injured is a double whammy in terms of losing 3 of our best from last year (Murphy 3.5 games, Gibbs left, Docherty 0 - add in Kreuzer missing almost a month, that's our top 4 in the B&F last year) - but I reckon Gibbs was a lot more damaging player than Murphy was last year. Still wouldn't be ideal to lose both 2 years in a row.
His old man finished his career with us....thats the reason he barracked for us as a kid.I heard he's going to Norf.