Marc Murphy

[prattsta]

Murphy is quite happy at Carlton ..he dislikes the wind and sand so i think he will remain in Melbourne ...however seeing as Pav is looking to be traded ..what say a straight swap for Cain Ackland and pick 54 ????

Thats a little one sided, how about we throw in Sandilands as well to even it up a bit

 

[bLuEbOy1984]

the reason he didnt go to lions is because he didnt want to go interstate.. i dont think his coming to the dockers

 

[The Night Shift]

the reason he didnt go to lions is because he didnt want to go interstate.. i dont think his coming to the dockers

That is most likely very true.

Whay do we have to trade draft picks away again. Why do some fans always want to piss them away. This year we stand a good chance of picking up some solid western australian pacey midfielders. This is what we need at the Purple Horde, apart if a true Full Back pops up. The decision makes itself really.

 

[Wizard]

No Trading Unless Pavlich Forces Our Hand!!!!!!

Keep The Picks And For Once Develop Our Own Kids.

 

[blues4flag]

Sorry he's going to us. Deal is already done.

Thread over.

So we're agreed on:

Mctinosh, Wells, Smith, Pratt + 1st round pick

FOR

Marc Murphy - and to even the deal, we'll throw in our third round pick and give back Teague

 

[Tundrawolf]

No Trading Unless Pavlich Forces Our Hand!!!!!!

Keep The Picks And For Once Develop Our Own Kids.

Exactly.

Only trades that should be considered are player for player trades ie: Murphy for ?????, Dunn for ?????

Or one of our players for draft picks ie: Campbell for pick no. ???, Schammer for pick no. ???? etc....

 

[Wizard]

Dunn for ?????

No no no!!!!!

 

[Tundrawolf]

No no no!!!!!

Examples only!!!

 

[rgauci]

Fremantle IN: Marc Murphy, Nathan Van Berlo, round 2 from Adelaide
Fremantle OUT: Pavlich

Adelaide IN: Pavlich
Adelaide OUT: Meeson, Van Berlo, round 1, round 2

Carlton IN: Meeson, Adelaide round 1
Carlton OUT: Murphy

or something like that. Its all crap though. MM aint moving West.

 

[BlueDevil]

how about murphy for pavlich straight swap.

stuff adelaide and port. but i doubt our little champ and captain in waiting is going anywhere anytime soon.

 

[raffrox]

Marc Murphy chose not to go FS with the Lions to stay in Melbourne. This thread is a waste of time.

 

[amer]

Fremantle IN: Marc Murphy, Nathan Van Berlo, round 2 from Adelaide
Fremantle OUT: Pavlich

Adelaide IN: Pavlich
Adelaide OUT: Meeson, Van Berlo, round 1, round 2

Carlton IN: Meeson, Adelaide round 1
Carlton OUT: Murphy

or something like that. Its all crap though. MM aint moving West.

Umm, yeah no thanks.

So we're giving away 2 first rounders (Meesen and pick) and 2 second rounders (VB and pick).

No.