Marsh Community Series Discussion Thread

[vast]

4 hours is a long time in SuperCoach .....everyone dumping & complaining about poor old Devon Smith

View attachment 836412

He and Steven are cooked mate.

 

[nameless]

Hurley looks good...

 

[JT_the_Man]

Possibly. He will play rnd 1 for sure now. If there are no other options I will need to find the cash to bring him in.

He was always playing round 1. We literally have no other options.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Is Zach Guthrie best 22? Only $190k

Nope. If ya can't grow facial hair ya not ready for the big boys just yet.

 

[Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite]

Yeah so if anyone was reading what I said about not starting BZT earlier you can disregard

What do you mean, who makes way for Hooker in Round 3 then?

 

[Ash1337]

Zerk-Thatcher looks like he was given the opportunity to show himself and play a floating role. Francis Usually does that loose role but this time he was a lock down defender. I wouldn't expect that for him come round 1 so beware. Devon Smith Full inside mid when the season starts? Doubt it. Probably be 50/50 rotating with parish n stringer. Dont look too into things for this game. Many of them played in different positions than usual. Also they were playing a lot of handball game with not much pressure. These guys are going to get crushed doing that against top teams this season.

 

[freddy mercury]

Of course Steven and Smith both ton up.

 

[Milkshaker]

Definitely not true. I didn’t have Grundy at all last year and finished top 300.

Cost you the $50k

 

[Andrew Birch]

Is Zach Guthrie best 22? Only $190k

This game withstanding, he's a terrible SC scorer.

 

[TheMcManusNose]

Depends if there is a decent substitute i guess.

No I mean I don't think he'll come back for any consistent period this year or ever. Been chronic good 2.5 years now.

 

[vast]

Zerk-Thatcher looks like he was given the opportunity to show himself and play a floating role. Francis Usually does that loose role but this time he was a lock down defender. I wouldn't expect that for him come round 1 so beware. Devon Smith Full inside mid when the season starts? Doubt it. Probably be 50/50 rotating with parish n stringer. Dont look too into things for this game. Many of them played in different positions than usual. Also they were playing a lot of handball game with not much pressure. These guys are going to get crushed doing that against top teams this season.

Smith played forward most of the first half and swapped with parish at half time. Francis has almost never played as the loose man and Bezerker was covering stanley or ratagulea all day.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Cost you the $50k

Haha no, Rocky cost me the $50k, the prick. (Amongst many others mistake, cough... Brayshaw... and I had the worst luck with captain choices. Like Captaining Gawn when he got injured...)

 

[rocker_oz33]

I missed the second half.
How did Margaret thatcher look?

Good score .

Was it because we are $hithouse?

 

[Phoenix_9]

I’m only going BZT if Green doesn’t get named. I’ll swing Houston into the mids and pick up BZT.

 

[Milkshaker]

Haha no, Rocky cost me the $50k, the prick. (Amongst many others mistake, cough... Brayshaw... and I had the worst luck with captain choices. Like Captaining Gawn when he got injured...)

Rocky has cost people furniture, marriages, window damage, stubbies against the wall etc the campainger.... and now you $50k.

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

No I mean I don't think he'll come back for any consistent period this year or ever. Been chronic good 2.5 years now.

Has it been that long? s**t!

 

[Silky23]

Love it how everyone automatically drops Gawn. He should be your R1.

Take his injury game against Brisbane out and he averaged 132.5 last year while Grundy averaged 130.

Then there's this:

I guess if we want to get bias involved I better defend the big man.
Grundy had a foot injury leading into Round 1 so I better take away his Round 1 score because he was under done. So taking that away he averaged 132.3.

2019
Grundy tons 19/22
Gawn tons 18/21

Grundy total points - 2860
Gawn total points - 2696

Grundy scores >120 - 16/22
Gawn scores >120 - 13/22

You'll hit back with 'but yeah Gawn scored a double ton' so I'll remove the highest and lowest outliers.

Grundy avg - 130.25
Gawn avg - 130.9 (yes I excluded his injury game)

And then in 2018

Grundy outscored him, out averaged him, hit more tons, and had a higher floor.

Oh and the best thing?

Grundy has missed 6 games in 5 years.
Gawn has missed 19 games in 5 years.

So who's more durable? The answer is, you name it.... Grundy. I'd hate to substitute in for lost trades, and emergency scores for Gawn being off the park. But I don't have time.

I guess you're right though, the better pick is Gawn!!! Ha ha

 

[vast]

I guess if we want to get bias involved I better defend the big man.
Grundy had a foot injury leading into Round 1 so I better take away his Round 1 score because he was under done. So taking that away he averaged 132.3.

2019
Grundy tons 19/22
Gawn tons 18/21

Grundy total points - 2860
Gawn total points - 2696

Grundy scores >120 - 16/22
Gawn scores >120 - 13/22

You'll hit back with 'but yeah Gawn scored a double ton' so I'll remove the highest and lowest outliers.

Grundy avg - 130.25
Gawn avg - 130.9 (yes I excluded his injury game)

And then in 2018

Grundy outscored him, out averaged him, hit more tons, and had a higher floor.

Oh and the best thing?

Grundy has missed 6 games in 5 years.
Gawn has missed 19 games in 5 years.

So who's more durable? The answer is, you name it.... Grundy. I'd hate to substitute in for lost trades, and emergency scores for Gawn being off the park. But I don't have time.

I guess you're right though, the better pick is Gawn!!! Ha ha

Jiska right now

 

[Silky23]

Jiska right now

And me right now hehe

 

[JT_the_Man]

What do you mean, who makes way for Hooker in Round 3 then?

If he plays like this I doubt it will be him.

 

[Phoenix_9]

If he plays like this I doubt it will be him.

Hooker could easily be needed in f50

 

[Goats]

Anyone considering both Steven AND Dev Smith ??? F3 and 4 respectively maybe

Currently F4 & F5.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Anyone else starting Naismith R3 just for Cash generation?

 

[freddy mercury]

Currently F4 & F5.

+1
Whitfield Martin Steven Smith. Pretty standard first 4 no doubt.

 

[Phoenix_9]

Anyone else starting Naismith R3 just for Cash generation?

I have to start him at R2, I just can’t structure up my team to make Gawn work.
Naismith (80) + Whitfield (110) is better than Gawn (130) + fwd rookie (50) (King/Davis/Mahony/Rankine). (C. Taylor not an option, he’s already locked in).