Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

[EagleCanival]

Anyone who watched WC V North today could see why people rate Zeibell higher then Shuey. Shuey just doesn't have that comokazi style that Ziebell has. Sure Shuey us clean in space but he would never sacrifice his own game for the betterment of the team.

Shuey was bog...

 

[Woobla Stainz]

Anyone who watched WC V North today could see why people rate Zeibell higher then Shuey. Shuey just doesn't have that comokazi style that Ziebell has. Sure Shuey us clean in space but he would never sacrifice his own game for the betterment of the team.

Lol

 

[EagleCanival]

Lol

It was at that point I realised Donkey has been playing us all along.

This explains so much.

 

[copthat]

Anyone who watched WC V North today could see why people rate Zeibell higher then Shuey. Shuey just doesn't have that comokazi style that Ziebell has. Sure Shuey us clean in space but he would never sacrifice his own game for the betterment of the team.

Ah yes, the illusive "comokazi" trait.

Why does being cleaner with the ball = "would never sacrifice his own game for the betterment of the team"?

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Anyone who watched WC V North today could see why people rate Zeibell higher then Shuey. Shuey just doesn't have that comokazi style that Ziebell has. Sure Shuey us clean in space but he would never sacrifice his own game for the betterment of the team.

Is this real life?

Shuey had 5 more clearances, 5 more contested possessions and a lot better DE today. You think he's clean in space when he's actually being clean in the contest. Ziebell was our best player in the first half with the amount of time he kicked it to Eagles players.

 

[lmach]

To be fair, Ziebell had about three score involvements for us today. Shuey just doesn't have that ability to give away 50m penalties that Ziebell has. He would never sacrifice his own game for the betterment of the other team.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Ziebell 21 disposlas, 12 tackles. The No 1 ranked player on The ground according to the AFL rating system. Shuey 29 disposals the 12th ranked player. That's fact.

 

[Cadillac]

Dusty needs to be removed from this poll. He's a top 5 midfielder.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Dusty needs to be removed from this poll. He's a top 5 midfielder.

According to some WC supporters Shuey is as good

 

[Happy Mastenator]

Ziebell 21 disposlas, 12 tackles. The No 1 ranked player on The ground according to the AFL rating system. Shuey 29 disposals the 12th ranked player. That's fact.

I think you mean Shuey was second in player ratings and Ziebell was second worst, a net negative actually...

 

[Donkey Chop]

 

[Happy Mastenator]

View attachment 265011

Just when I thought you couldn't embarrass yourself any further you are using DT scores. Oh my.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Just when I thought you couldn't embarrass yourself any further you are using DT scores. Oh my.

It's all realive. What makes one rating system more relative to the other?

 

[Happy Mastenator]

It's all realive. What makes one rating system more relative to the other?

Are you being serious? You don't know the difference between the DT rating and the official play ratings.

If you don't know you should probably stop posting.

 

[EagleCanival]

It's all realive. What makes one rating system more relative to the other?

You're sighting a reference that uses a system in which a player ineffectively tackles a player (4 points) being more valuable that a player spotting up a forward laces out on the chest (3 points)

 

[Donkey Chop]

You're sighting a reference that uses a system in which a player ineffectively tackles a player (4 points) being more valuable that a player spotting up a forward laces out on the chest (3 points)

TBH I barely noticed Shuey tonight. He's like a modern day Anthony Rock

 

[EagleCanival]

TBH I barely noticed Shuey tonight. He's like a modern day Anthony Rock

If you fail to even notice a player that's pretty much a Shoe in (no pun intended) to get 3 votes and possibly 10 votes by the coaches, than that's more your failure to acknowledge him, than Shueys detriment as a player.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Shuey was a pretty clear BOG in the West Coast game IMO.
Didn't see the Richmond game last night but Martin put up big numbers.

 

[juss]

Shuey was a pretty clear BOG in the West Coast game IMO.
Didn't see the Richmond game last night but Martin put up big numbers.

Martin was the best player (acknowledged by the commentators and a lot of viewers), but we lost, so he is unlikely to get the 3 or the 10. The awards favour winners, I expect Bontempelli to take it.

 

[Tiggytigers]

I know I barrack for Richmond but surely dusty is easily the best player out of the 4? Martin is currently one of the best mids going around at the moment

 

[EagleCanival]

Martin was the best player (acknowledged by the commentators and a lot of viewers), but we lost, so he is unlikely to get the 3 or the 10. The awards favour winners, I expect Bontempelli to take it.

Not too sure BT and his hard on for "THE PACKAGE!" would agree with you, but Martin had one of the rare performances where he should manage to get three votes regardless of the result.

 

[juss]

Not too sure BT and his hard on for "THE PACKAGE!" would agree with you, but Martin had one of the rare performances where he should manage to get three votes regardless of the result.

BT loves them stiff arms

 

[Donkey Chop]

I know I barrack for Richmond but surely dusty is easily the best player out of the 4? Martin is currently one of the best mids going around at the moment

Comfortably

 

[Yippy Yi Yeo]

Almost 20 percent difference in disposal efficiency between shuey and ziebell today, just showcased the difference in class between the 2 players.

 

[EagleCanival]

I know I barrack for Richmond but surely dusty is easily the best player out of the 4? Martin is currently one of the best mids going around at the moment

It's definitely closer between Martin and Shuey than it is between Shuey and JZ.