Martin v Shuey v Hartlett v Ziebell (version 2.0)

[Demonated]

Anyone who watched WC V North today could see why people rate Zeibell higher then Shuey. Shuey just doesn't have that comokazi style that Ziebell has. Sure Shuey us clean in space but he would never sacrifice his own game for the betterment of the team.

I don't understand how someone who watched that game could possibly think Ziebell performed better than Shuey. Shuey will likely get the 3 Brownlow votes and top coaches votes for the game (wait for tomorrow night to see I guess). You then go on to quote dream team points, which also have Jack Grimes and Touk Miller as the best on in their games this week, both which will likely not receive a Brownlow vote and may get 1/2 coaches votes if they are lucky.

Ziebell didn't have much of an impact on the game, very little hurt factor today. Shuey on the other hand was very damaging today. There's something to be said about actually spotting up a target and hitting them rather than kicking in blind hope. Are you sure you were watching the same game as everyone else? Or does 'comokazi' style count for everything.

 

[lmach]

It's all realive. What makes one rating system more relative to the other?

Your ignorance actually blows my mind.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Your ignorance actually blows my mind.

I'm happy to broaden your way of thinking

 

[eaglespremiers]

Another amazing game from Martin.
Has really pushed to the top echelon of midfielders this season.

 

[Tiggytigers]

martin needs to be taken out of this thread, is easily the best of the 4 by a country mile

 

[Donkey Chop]

martin needs to be taken out of this thread, is easily the best of the 4 by a country mile

If the tigers won more games he'd be a monty for the Brownlow. He's still a good chance

 

[Bulldog1954]

Surely the order is pretty clear now?

Dusty by a mile over the rest. Then Shuey comfortably over Ziebell who is comfortably ahead of Hartlett.

 

[juss]

Surely the order is pretty clear now?

Dusty by a mile over the rest. Then Shuey comfortably over Ziebell who is comfortably ahead of Hartlett.

No you need to wait for gym4life to explain to you how Shuey is better than Martin

 

[EagleCanival]

Surely the order is pretty clear now?

Dusty by a mile over the rest. Then Shuey comfortably over Ziebell who is comfortably ahead of Hartlett.

Hartlett could give Ziebell a run for his money.

 

[Elite Master]

It's definitely closer between Martin and Shuey than it is between Shuey and JZ.

Not sure about that. Martin is on another planet compared to the rest.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Not sure about that. Martin is on another planet compared to the rest.

Agreed. He's easily the best player. Shuey, like the Eagles still stuggles away from home. 23 and a goal against the Blues isn't exactly anything to crow about. Ziebell had 22 & 2 when he played the blues

 

[EagleCanival]

Agreed. He's easily the best player. Shuey, like the Eagles still stuggles away from home. 23 and a goal against the Blues isn't exactly anything to crow about. Ziebell had 22 & 2 when he played the blues

Last time Shuey played away from home before today he was given a perfect 10 from the coaches

But I'm not sure why I bother with you anymore. Say whatever you want.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Last time Shuey played away from home before today he was given a perfect 10 from the coaches

But I'm not sure why I bother with you anymore. Say whatever you want.

I didn't engage you so I'm not sure why you did either

 

[EagleCanival]

I didn't engage you so I'm not sure why you did either

I see ignorance and I just get the urge to correct it. I'll try not to next time.

 

[Donkey Chop]

I see ignorance and I just get the urge to correct it. I'll try not to next time.

That would be wonderful

 

[daicosdemis]

It's definitely closer between Martin and Shuey than it is between Shuey and JZ.

Not really. Shuey an explosive mid, Ziebell tough as nails and their statistical output is very similar.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Anyone just hear Schwartz on SEN unload on Shuey? It was one of the biggest bashings I've heard from a journo on a player. Despite this thread I actually like Shuey, I know his school coach very well.

But gees Ox cooked him. Called him a disgrace of a footballer who only plays for frees & if he doesn't change his game he should leave the AFL. It was abit OTT TBH

 

[eaglespremiers]

Anyone just hear Schwartz on SEN unload on Shuey? It was one of the biggest bashings I've heard from a journo on a player. Despite this thread I actually like Shuey, I know his school coach very well.

But gees Ox cooked him. Called him a disgrace of a footballer who only plays for frees & if he doesn't change his game he should leave the AFL. It was abit OTT TBH

Did he single out Selwood as well? Because there's really no comparison, Selwood's a lot worse.

 

[Matera92]

Anyone just hear Schwartz on SEN unload on Shuey? It was one of the biggest bashings I've heard from a journo on a player. Despite this thread I actually like Shuey, I know his school coach very well.

But gees Ox cooked him. Called him a disgrace of a footballer who only plays for frees & if he doesn't change his game he should leave the AFL. It was abit OTT TBH

Yes because that idiot wouldn't be salty at all about yesterdays result.

Perhaps should get stuck into his former team for not being able to put us away despite nearly double the inside 50's.

 

[juss]

Yes because that idiot wouldn't be salty at all about yesterdays result.

Perhaps should get stuck into his former team for not being able to put us away despite nearly double the inside 50's.

Lol you know you can criticise players, sometimes the criticisms are valid. Not everything needs to be traced back to the team you support.

 

[Matera92]

Lol you know you can criticise players, sometimes the criticisms are valid. Not everything needs to be traced back to the team you support.

Going OTT on a player that that is regularly smashed by taggers week in and week out when he was just near BOG against your former club is pretty unprofessional.

Then again, not surprising considering who it came from.

 

[EagleCanival]

Anyone just hear Schwartz on SEN unload on Shuey? It was one of the biggest bashings I've heard from a journo on a player. Despite this thread I actually like Shuey, I know his school coach very well.

But gees Ox cooked him. Called him a disgrace of a footballer who only plays for frees & if he doesn't change his game he should leave the AFL. It was abit OTT TBH

Last week the boys on SEN spoke highly on Shuey and how he's very similar to Cyril in the way he's damaging with the ball.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Has he had a go at Lindsey yet?

Yes.

Last week the boys on SEN spoke highly on Shuey and how he's very similar to Cyril in the way he's damaging with the ball.

Well he is. Ox even said that today. Just doesn't rate the type of player he is

 

[Donkey Chop]

Dusty, Ziebell, Shuey then Hartlett this week.

In that order

 

[Judd2Sewell]

Lol you know you can criticise players, sometimes the criticisms are valid. Not everything needs to be traced back to the team you support.

Welcome to bigfooty.