Marty Mattner for:

[T Rick]

Kennelly,Newman,Mcphee,Milburn,Waters

Such a wide range of players, and all are viable options...

I just can't decide, i feel they are all possible keepers, may i have some advice?

 

[DonMania#5]

1) Milburn
2) Newman
3) Waters
4) Kennely
5) Mcphee

That is how i would rank them.
With Lucas coming back soon, Mcphee could rise up quite easily to the top though.

 

[foley4brownlow]

Kennelly,Newman,Mcphee,Milburn,Waters

Such a wide range of players, and all are viable options...

I just can't decide, i feel they are all possible keepers, may i have some advice?

milburn i rekan mate thats who il be getting this week at the expense of pfeiffer. milburn is very reliable and consistent

 

[sdsdsdsd]

1) Milburn
2) Newman
3) Waters
4) Kennely
5) Mcphee

That is how i would rank them.
With Lucas coming back soon, Mcphee could rise up quite easily to the top though.

Milburn or Newman.

Just a side question mate, any reason for choosing Waters over Kennelly. I have 305k to choose a defender and choosing between waters/kennelly/gilbee so im interested in ur decision

 

[T Rick]

Kennelly is as injury proned as that tall skinny kid in under 14s...

 

[William C]

i have to keep him ...

purely to avoid any donuts otherwise it would have been milburn easily

 

[mitchell12345]

i have already got milburn and he is a very consistent palyer so i would definately get him.

i am in the same situation as you because i am going to trade symes out and i don't know who to put in but i am thinking newman

 

[Thorgils]

With how crap some of the backline players are this season I refuse to trade. To many sideways trades for my liking. I cant see any true advantage in trading out Mattner yet. might even keep him for the year.

 

[William C]

johncock? definately a keeper imo

 

[foley4brownlow]

johncock? definately a keeper imo

second that

 

[T Rick]

johncock? definately a keeper imo

Got him, he is a machine .

 

[jdwood]

I'll be doing the double trade, getting PBurg and using the spare cash next week.

 

[Athomas]

Mcdonald?

Although just noticed this...
BRISBANE LIONS
Josh Drummond (quad) available

Great....

 

[favourites]

Ill get Milburn, not sure whether to do it this week or not.

This week trade one is Morton --> Browne

Trade two --> Mattner --> Milburn/P burg
--> N Jones --> Sam Mitchell (leaning this way)
--> L Davis --> B Johnson

The other two will be done next week. What are peoples thoughts?

 

[TylerDurden]

I'll be doing the double trade, getting PBurg and using the spare cash next week.

Agreed.

I'll be using the coin to get Simmonds the next week...

 

[kangaroo19]

For me, I'm tossing up between Mattner to Burg/Birchall/Johncock... ideas?

Burgoyne - most expensive, likely to get higher scores but inconsistent?
Birchall - consistent, any big scores likely?
Johncock - as above for birchall, but cheaper?

Also could afford McLeod, but would like to keep some cash for future trades...

 

[kangaroo19]

For me, I'm tossing up between Mattner to Burg/Birchall/Johncock... ideas?

Burgoyne - most expensive, likely to get higher scores but inconsistent?
Birchall - consistent, any big scores likely?
Johncock - as above for birchall, but cheaper?

Also could afford McLeod, but would like to keep some cash for future trades...

Thoughts?

 

[foley4brownlow]

For me, I'm tossing up between Mattner to Burg/Birchall/Johncock... ideas?

Burgoyne - most expensive, likely to get higher scores but inconsistent?
Birchall - consistent, any big scores likely?
Johncock - as above for birchall, but cheaper?

Also could afford McLeod, but would like to keep some cash for future trades...

burgoyne is likely to get the bigger scores but is very inconsistent. if your looking for consistency get birchall. hes capable of 110 but probably not a lot more . also johncock is consistent and is a lot cheaper so that might be the best way to go as you would have a bit of money in the bank for future upgrades.

 

[jdwood]

What do people think of Bock?

I'm looking at him as an alternative to Burgoyne. He is cheaper and averaging around 8-9 more p/w. I'm still leaning to Burgoyne due to is capability to score high scores and I can see Bock having a few games where he is forced to play tight and hence score very little.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Re: Marty Mattner for: BOCK

What do people think of Bock?

I'm looking at him as an alternative to Burgoyne. He is cheaper and averaging around 8-9 more p/w. I'm still leaning to Burgoyne due to is capability to score high scores and I can see Bock having a few games where he is forced to play tight and hence score very little.

Bock YES
Im doing this trade
Ellis --->Bock this week

Everyone loves passing it to him in the backline.
He is so strong and can take a fantastic mark..hardly ever fumbles

Get Bock

 

[Thorgils]

Re: Marty Mattner for: BOCK

Bock YES
Im doing this trade
Ellis --->Bock this week

Everyone loved passing it to him in the backline.
He is so strong and can take a fantastic mark..hardly ever fumbles

Get Bock

I thought you had eyes only for Porps?? Alot of love for The Bock it seems.

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Re: Marty Mattner for: BOCK

I thought you had eyes only for Porps?? Alot of love for The Bock it seems.

NOOOO! Porps is my one eyed man. NO ONE ELSE

Bock is just a defender you gotta love

 

[favourites]

Re: Marty Mattner for: BOCK

I cant get Bock.. until i rid myself of either porps or burton because i also have S Thompson.. I cannot have more than 3 players from one team, unless they have blue and white hoops. lol

 

[banana_bus]

After what Bock did to me last year I dont think Ill ever be able to get him again.

 

[leungtl]

After what Bock did to me last year I dont think Ill ever be able to get him again.

Seconded.