Werewolf MARVEL Werewolf

[Jhye Clark 13]

How exactly was I covering my arse?

And if I was evil why would I want to lynch a lowly villager? I'd be going for a big fish

You should have thought things through. It was as obvious as the balls between my legs that Reaps was the shapeshifter yet despite being told who was likely evil you stayed on Reaps.

 

[Blacky]

How will evil know if the doc is protecting me or I actually gave it back to him? I could give it to a flog for a night and then back to him. We won't be discussing it in here after tonight

Fair enough. It just made me uneasy having evil know where the amulet is at all times and revealing the doctor.

 

[Millky95]

Doctor only

So give it to me

 

[sante]

The amulet never works for evil because we just lynch or Vig them immediately after their saved

My concern is that your plan neutralises the doctor and the amulet - they're now being passed around two people in perpetuity and if that is broken the doc gets killed immediately more than likely

Will we know they were saved by the amulet? Look at the N1 write up. We don't know for sure if it was me attacked or someone the doc protected

 

[tigland]

Not sure I have ever had an amulet

 

[Sterge]

Does the shield protect from lynching?

 

[Sterge]

Will we know they were saved by the amulet? Look at the N1 write up. We don't know for sure if it was me attacked or someone the doc protected

Im pretty sure cap was attacked

 

[Blacky]

Will we know they were saved by the amulet? Look at the N1 write up. We don't know for sure if it was me attacked or someone the doc protected

Agreed.
Fair enough. Just wanted to kick the tyres

 

[Dennis Trumpet]

You should have thought things through. It was as obvious as the balls between my legs that Reaps was the shapeshifter yet despite being told who was likely evil you stayed on Reaps.

I oh knew he was the shapeshifter. But he could just as easily have picked harolad instead of colossus as he claimed.

 

[Golumless]

I said from the start that wosrst case scenario we lynch a villager. I still stand by it as I don't think it was worth leaving him on the possibility that the reaper was the godfather.

Actually. I reckon in Reeps case that he was a shapeshifter... it was probably more dangerous to leave him alive as he'd be prime candidate for vampire conversion. Reality is lynching a villager is the meh option day one as at least the good roles are untouched.

 

[sante]

So give it to me[/

Who did you protect N1?

 

[Kennedy Parker]

sante right now you need to be very careful. It is likely that evil would gladly sacrifice one member to get the amulet for the rest of the game. You might get quite a few doctor claims here. Try and delay when you pass the amulet as much as possible I reckon.

 

[sante]

sante right now you need to be very careful. It is likely that evil would gladly sacrifice one member to get the amulet for the rest of the game. You might get quite a few doctor claims here. Try and delay when you pass the amulet as much as possible I reckon.

At least I have 3 others to discuss with.

 

[Millky95]

Who did you protect N1?

Myself

 

[Sterge]

Myself

you're claiming doc?

 

[SM]

What have I missed?

 

[Sterge]

At least I have 3 others to discuss with.

I wouldn't believe anyone openly claiming doc it's stupid to come out this early and as CC said likely evil will throw a junior member under the bus to try and get it.

The real doc hopefully isn't inactive and is switched on enough to protect you anyway

 

[Sterge]

What have I missed?

Mellty is evil, trying to get the shield off sante

 

[Millky95]

you're claiming doc?

I'm claiming Doc-won't-reveal-so-give-it-to-me-so-I-can-give-it-back-so-flogs-can-pass-it-around-like-the-Dutchie

 

[sante]

I wouldn't believe anyone openly claiming doc it's stupid to come out this early and as CC said likely evil will throw a junior member under the bus to try and get it.

The real doc hopefully isn't inactive and is switched on enough to protect you anyway

Again, it's not about protecting me. I'm basically a villager who knows 3 other villagers.

It's about keeping the amulet with good.

 

[Dennis Trumpet]

you're claiming doc?

There's more than one protector In this game remember. If one of the lovers gained the amulet it could also be pretty useful.

 

[sante]

If the doctor doesn't claim it could potentially end the game for the village, especially if I give the amulet to evil

 

[Sterge]

Again, it's not about protecting me. I'm basically a villager who knows 3 other villagers.

It's about keeping the amulet with good.

yes and since they hit you last night, they need to try again so the shield is lost to the flogs

just hope the doc is paying attention

 

[sante]

There's more than one protector In this game remember. If one of the lovers gained the amulet it could also be pretty useful.

Yep. Blacky

 

[Kennedy Parker]

The flaw in this plan is that doctor claims are can't be confirmed and therefore aren't trustworthy. The only way I can see this working is if the lovers out themselves as they can affirm each other. They wax the amulet between each other and doctor stays hidden to protect the one who doesn't have it. That would require outing two roles though.