Matt Crouch is just a plodder.

[port_adelaide_1870]

I know which one i want in my team.

 

[Maddogmetro]

16. Accept that DBJ is a superior player

Let's put this to bed once and for all:



What does this show?

Crouch's stats are superior in kicks, handballs and disposals per game (and by a considerable margin).

MC has 2 more tackles per game.

MC has more goal assists per game.

MC has more than DOUBLE (almost triple) contested possessions per game.

5 more effective disposals per game.

MC has almost 6 clearances per game to DBJ basically none.

All this, while have 11% LESS game time than DBJ.

There is not even an argument here. MC far superior in every way. There is no disputing these stats.

You are wrong you delusional flog.

 

[Maddogmetro]

I know which one i want in my team.

Haha the guy who gets taken out by his own player, then thinks he's tough because there is a little blood on his face?

If that is Port's criteria for a good player, no wonder you are so shit.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Let's put this to bed once and for all:

View attachment 263089

What does this show?

Crouch's stats are superior in kicks, handballs and disposals per game (and by a considerable margin).

MC has 2 more tackles per game.

MC has more goal assists per game.

MC has more than DOUBLE (almost triple) contested possessions per game.

5 more effective disposals per game.

MC has almost 6 clearances per game to DBJ basically none.

All this, while have 11% LESS game time than DBJ.

There is not even an argument here. MC far superior in every way. There is no disputing these stats.

You are wrong you delusional flog.

I am not gunna go through this AGAIN... go look through the thread, all this debate has already taken place.

In short stats are not relevant when comparing a fulltime midfielder to a fulltime defender.

 

[Maddogmetro]

I am not gunna go through this AGAIN... go look through the thread, all this debate has already taken place.

In short stats are not relevant when comparing a fulltime midfielder to a fulltime defender.

Perhaps you don't realise, but stats are really good because they are INDISPUTABLE. They are OBJECTIVE. Not your stupid, 'Ohh well I just think he has the flair that stats don't show!'

Or perhaps you are going with, 'Oh he plays a different position, so stats just don't matter at all'.

You are a flog.

...

Just saw your edit.

Going for the 'different positions' argument I see.

Well doesn't that make every single one of your comments completely ****ing useless?

You can't claim that the players are not comparable, and then compare them and come to the conclusion you reached. Do you not even see the complete idiocy in your comments?

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Perhaps you don't realise, but stats are really good because they are INDISPUTABLE. They are OBJECTIVE. Not your stupid, 'Ohh well I just think he has the flair that stats don't show!'

Or perhaps you are going with, 'Oh he plays a different position, so stats just don't matter at all'.

You are a flog.

You really are a flog arent you, DBJ is a DEFENDER, those stats do not prove his defensive work rate, does not show what he has done to prevent his opponent from getting touches and getting goals, does not show defensive acts. Like i have said before in the thread, from an early age (under 18 champs) the word was that Spud was a player that just knew how to find the ball, knew how to get into the right places etc. Stats like that are useless because he is a midfielder, his job is to get the ball, is around the ball nearly all the time, where darcys main role is to stop his opponent and after that find some ball of his own.

Youre an idiot if you think this comparison is as easy as "look Crouch gets more touches therefore he is better"

 

[Bernie L]

Let's put this to bed once and for all:

View attachment 263089

What does this show?

Crouch's stats are superior in kicks, handballs and disposals per game (and by a considerable margin).

MC has 2 more tackles per game.

MC has more goal assists per game.

MC has more than DOUBLE (almost triple) contested possessions per game.

5 more effective disposals per game.

MC has almost 6 clearances per game to DBJ basically none.

All this, while have 11% LESS game time than DBJ.

There is not even an argument here. MC far superior in every way. There is no disputing these stats.

You are wrong you delusional flog.

Ive tried that with Porf 1870. He just ignored it, either that or just didn't plain understand it

Keep at it Porf 1870, your entertainment is fun.

Oh, why are you the only Port flog on here pumping up double blow job????

 

[Maddogmetro]

You really are a flog arent you, DBJ is a DEFENDER, those stats do not prove his defensive work rate, does not show what he has done to prevent his opponent from getting touches and getting goals, does not show defensive acts. Like i have said before in the thread, from an early age (under 18 champs) the word was that Spud was a player that just knew how to find the ball, knew how to get into the right places etc. Stats like that are useless because he is a midfielder, his job is to get the ball, is around the ball nearly all the time, where darcys main role is to stop his opponent and after that find some ball of his own.

Youre an idiot if you think this comparison is as easy as "look Crouch gets more touches therefore he is better"

You are a genuine ****** aren't you?

Ignores objective stats, claims they are irrelevant, provides no other objective measure to compare players other than 'Coz I said so lol'

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

You are a genuine ****** aren't you?

Ignores objective stats, claims they are irrelevant, provides no other objective measure to compare players other than 'Coz I said so lol'

No shit Crouch is going to have better stats, he is a midfielder... was Kane Cornes a better player then Bob Murphy? Yes or no.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

There is very little objective measure to say Murphy was the better player but everyone who watches the game would know Bob is better than Kane.

 

[T2B_]

Where's the rest of the Poort goo patrol? Poor old p_power_1997 is getting his rectum pounded in here.

 

[Bernie L]

Hey Porf 1870,

can you change the thread title to Murphy>>>>Kornes

 

[Bernie L]

Where's the rest of the Poort goo patrol? Poor old p_power_1997 is getting his rectum pounded in here.

And he hasnt left yet

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Hey Porf 1870,

can you change the thread title to Murphy>>>>Kornes

Its the same argument, comparing a running half back to a midfielder who gets easy stats.

 

[Maddogmetro]

Hey Porf 1870,

can you change the thread title to Murphy>>>>Kornes

Or if you want a real comparison based on position, Laird >>>>>> DBJ

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Where's the rest of the Poort goo patrol? Poor old p_power_1997 is getting his rectum pounded in here.

And he hasnt left yet

Just because there are more flogs like you guys in this thread doesnt mean you're winning the argument. "LOOK GUYS, more anti port people agree with me, IM WINNING, YAY!" lol

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Or if you want a real comparison based on position, Laird >>>>>> DBJ

Answer the question, is kane cornes better then Bob murphy?

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

There is very little objective measure to say Murphy was the better player but everyone who watches the game would know Bob is better than Kane.

 

[Beats28772]

Let's put this to bed once and for all:

View attachment 263089

What does this show?

Crouch's stats are superior in kicks, handballs and disposals per game (and by a considerable margin).

MC has 2 more tackles per game.

MC has more goal assists per game.

MC has more than DOUBLE (almost triple) contested possessions per game.

5 more effective disposals per game.

MC has almost 6 clearances per game to DBJ basically none.

All this, while have 11% LESS game time than DBJ.

There is not even an argument here. MC far superior in every way. There is no disputing these stats.

You are wrong you delusional flog.

Thanks for confirming the DBJ first 12 games are significantly better than Plodder.

 

[Maddogmetro]

Answer the question, is kane cornes better then Bob murphy?

Neither are currently playing so couldn't tell you.

 

[T2B_]

Just because there are more flogs like you guys in this thread doesnt mean you're winning the argument. "LOOK GUYS, more anti port people agree with me, IM WINNING, YAY!" lol

Well see the problem is Poort fans around here usually flock to freds like this to huff and puff.

But they are mysteriously avoiding this one... one can only assume they don't want to get involved in such a failed argument.

 

[Maddogmetro]

Thanks for confirming the DBJ first 12 games are significantly better than Plodder.

Uhhh wut. Nice drugs you're taking there.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Neither are currently playing so couldn't tell you.

LOL!

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

AHAHAHAHAHA POINT PROVEN. You cant even admit when youre wrong.

DBJ >>>>> Crouch Confirmed

 

[Maddogmetro]

AHAHAHAHAHA POINT PROVEN. You cant even admit when youre wrong.

DBJ >>>>> Crouch Confirmed

Other than religious nutters, I've never seen someone so deluded in my life.