Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Matthew Clarke Drafting Record at Richmond...

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Yeah...seemed to be a complete sh*t show from the Eagles on draft night - but maybe I'm being overly critical as I haven't dug too deep into any Eagles forums.

Can people confirm what is fact and what was fiction from the night:

1. If Eagles bid on Patterson at #3 or even #4, GC would not have been able to match Addinsall?

2. Eagles traded out a F2 to go up 1 x spot, to bid on Addinsall only to have the bid matched. So they then take Lindsay. Hawks were next....with Amon, Impey, Di Ambrosio amongst others, surely they weren't taking Lindsay..??

So did Eagles give the Saints F2 for literally nothing, thus spending a first and second on Lindsay?

3. They didn't match for Banfield or Evans. Was this because they had no list spots left? Did they expect them to get through to the rookie draft, or do they miscalculate points/picks?

So I honestly don't know what's fact or fiction. But if indeed they could've got Addinsall, Banfield and Evans by being a little smarter, and also kept their F2 in the process, then it's a balls-up of epic proportions on the 1 x night their list mgt team are expected to excel.

Know I’m late to the party, but to add to answers already given:

1. Possibly, but the difficulty is bids needed to matched on others players (e.g. Annable) to remove picks in the teens as well to bring the pick where the Murray and Addinsall bids landed where in.

2. Not so much Hawks taking Lindsay, but if West Coast had any shot at Murray or Addinsall it had to be as early as possible. Which didn’t work obviously. But Hawks were keen to trade back. So Eagles traded up to secure the pick and the player they wanted as opposed to waiting one pick and maybe seeing another team jump in and grab the player they wanted (Murray or Addinsall if bids weren’t matched, Lindsay if they were).

Additionally, that’s kind of the price it takes. Essendon gave up a second round pick to switch picks with Geelong to get Nate Caddy.

3. I’d say it’s similar to us with Kellaway. Simply valued higher players on the board than Banfield and Evans. Which to be fair, most would have Allen and Williams ahead of both.The eagles had already committed to Finn McCray, Devon Robertson and Harry Schoenberg before the draft so don’t think the expectation was that Banfield nor Evans would get through the rookie draft.
 
O would argue Reid , Shannahan , Duursma , Lindsay wont be playing in their next premiership either
They might sneak one if Lalor gets a nasty corky and Gibcus gets the runs and spreads it through the team.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Matthew Clarke Drafting Record at Richmond...

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top