Recommitted Max Hall [Extended until 2027]

[The Nostradamus]

23 year old saints msd rookie from last year still out of contract and in serious form

27 touches 3 goals on the weekend, 21 and a goal the week before

will get a fair increase from the bare min rookie contract, whats he worth?

 

[Yoda_]

whats he worth?

Lots

 

[projectv]

Very quickly turning into one of our best players. No way he leaves yet.

 

[The Nostradamus]

ST KILDA is yet to offer breakout talent Max Hall a contract beyond this season, despite an impressive month-long stretch that has put the club's rookie recruit among the most in-form players in the competition.

 

[DT_35]

Rumours around the media he will sign a multi year contract. No stress

 

[Tasmanian saint]

A huge miss buy Hawthorn having this guy right under there noses

 

[Chip Scab1]

A huge miss buy Hawthorn having this guy right under there noses

Makes up for the 30 or so hits they've had since 1976, I guess.

 

[GinniAndTonic]

A huge miss buy Hawthorn having this guy right under there noses

I mean hardly a miss, we never had the chance of taking him you had the pick before us.

 

[HairyO]

A huge miss buy Hawthorn having this guy right under there noses

Saints 1st was ahead of ours and we couldnt trade up the MSD ladder. What are you saying we should have done?

If a Rookie doesnt sign a new contract with their club what happens in terms of how other clubs can recruit? Are they delisted or does a trade need to happen?

I.e. can we literally pick him up for nothing? Or will we see St Kilda demand a 1st round pick for a guy they got for chump change?

 

[Tasmanian saint]

Saints 1st was ahead of ours and we couldnt trade up the MSD ladder. What are you saying we should have done?

If a Rookie doesnt sign a new contract with their club what happens in terms of how other clubs can recruit? Are they delisted or does a trade need to happen?

I.e. can we literally pick him up for nothing? Or will we see St Kilda demand a 1st round pick for a guy they got for chump change?

I gather he would be like any other out of contract player you would have to trade for them. Seeing st kilda gave him his opportunity you would hope he stays loyal . How long was he involved at box hill for?

 

[Veer Right]

Honestly would rather keep Hall then NWM such is how i rate his outlook. As long as he develops into a 20+ disposal player he will end up a jet. Goal kicking mid with elite disposal who does hit targets with inside 50s.

Hall and Tauru courtesy of Simon Dalrymples arrival have both been unreal finds.

 

[Foxman98]

Honestly would rather keep Hall then NWM such is how i rate his outlook. As long as he develops into a 20+ disposal player he will end up a jet. Goal kicking mid with elite disposal who does hit targets with inside 50s.

Hall and Tauru courtesy of Simon Dalrymples arrival have both been unreal finds.

I know you guys may have had some awful 1st rounders over the last decade but Tauru at pick 10 in a super draft isnt a find,

Hall on the otherhand very good mid season draftee

 

[HairyO]

Honestly would rather keep Hall then NWM such is how i rate his outlook. As long as he develops into a 20+ disposal player he will end up a jet. Goal kicking mid with elite disposal who does hit targets with inside 50s.

Hall and Tauru courtesy of Simon Dalrymples arrival have both been unreal finds.

Not to mention Hall's next contract is unlikely to be more than $500k. NWM is a great player but the money being mentioned about him is simply insane.

 

[Broski]

Not to mention Hall's next contract is unlikely to be more than $500k. NWM is a great player but the money being mentioned about him is simply insane.

I reckon you are underselling NWN massively. Would have him in the same talent bracket as Nick Daicos and Sam Darcy. The money being thrown around is absolutely justifiable.

 

[Chip Scab1]

I reckon you are underselling NWN massively. Would have him in the same talent bracket as Nick Daicos and Sam Darcy. The money being thrown around is absolutely justifiable.

You are not delusional at all.

Darcy - 3x R1 + upgrades should he leave
Nick - 3x R1 + upgrades
Your player 1x R1 + R2

Yeah he's a gun, but Darcy is the best young forward in the game (behind Thilthorpe), and Nick is probably the best player.

Comparing your excellent HBFr to these two is delusional.

 

[CatToTheFuture]

Saints 1st was ahead of ours and we couldnt trade up the MSD ladder. What are you saying we should have done?

If a Rookie doesnt sign a new contract with their club what happens in terms of how other clubs can recruit? Are they delisted or does a trade need to happen?

I.e. can we literally pick him up for nothing? Or will we see St Kilda demand a 1st round pick for a guy they got for chump change?

Reckon Charlie Cameron might have still been rookie listed when traded to Brisbane. Didn't change anything

 

[Broski]

You are not delusional at all.

Darcy - 3x R1 + upgrades should he leave
Nick - 3x R1 + upgrades
Your player 1x R1 + R2

Yeah he's a gun, but Darcy is the best young forward in the game, and Nick is probably the best player.

Comparing your excellent HBFr to these two is delusional.

First time watching football I guess?

 

[Chip Scab1]

First time watching football I guess?

First time being called out for being the nonce you are being (on this topic, but likely more), I guess.

Tell me, which part specifically isn't (in your opinion) a statement of fact?

 

[HairyO]

First time watching football I guess?

He is literally dragging his team over the line every week and the key reason why the Saints are pushing for a finals win this year.

Or, no single player in the game is really that important and any team spending a huge % of its cap on a tiny number of players is going to fail.

Which of the 2 sentences above rings true do you think ?

 

[Chip Scab1]

He is literally dragging his team over the line every week and the key reason why the Saints are pushing for a finals win this year.

Or, no single player in the game is really that important and any team spending a huge % of its cap on a tiny number of players is going to fail.

Which of the 2 sentences above rings true do you think ?

Dragging them all the way to the 15th. I'd imagine you meant well when that came to mind as some sort of genius you had to share with the world.

 

[HairyO]

Dragging them all the way to the 15th. I'd imagine you meant well when that came to mind as some sort of genius you had to share with the world.

Yeah if not for NWM they would be languishing in 16th.

 

[aussierulesrules]

No.1 ranked player in the AFL for the month leading into this round, and the no.1 ranked “general forward” for the 6 weeks leading into this round.

Think he copped much closer attention this week, but still managed to kick 3 sausages (including a big launch from outside 50), from 15 possessions.

Will obviously cost us a whole lot more cap space than we would have expected, but hopefully we get it done ASAP.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Blues should chuck some of the TDK money at him. Actually kick goals, instant step up on 90% of our small forwards.

 

[Tasmanian saint]

Blues should chuck some of the TDK money at him. Actually kick goals, instant step up on 90% of our small forwards.

He doesn’t really play like a traditional small forward though

 

[aussierulesrules]

He doesn’t really play like a traditional small forward though

Yeah the reason his scoring (fantasy/ranking points) is so good is because he’s pushing up to the stoppages and spending most of the game playing in the midfield, and pushing hard forward when we have the ball.