Maxwell gone.

[Footy_Fan2007]

Maxwell - 1
Roughead - reprimand

Won't really be fair if roughead doesn't go for that especially that stevie j did. Maxwell will get 2.

 

[Hodge is God]

Won't really be fair if roughead doesn't go for that especially that stevie j did. Maxwell will get 2.

Stevie J has a record though.

 

[.Shotties.]

Won't really be fair if roughead doesn't go for that especially that stevie j did. Maxwell will get 2.

Johnson could have accepted a reprimand for his but carry over and bad record took it to a one week suspension.

 

[King Elvis]

If that's the only footage available of the Maxwell incident, you couldn't suspend him on it. Surely they'd have to have something else available like they did for Johnson last week?

Didn't Hartlett and somebody else get done recently from even more inconclusive footage?

 

[Tedeski]

I,m waiting on Ross Lyons view before I make any judgements

Your club let Stevie J down...............................they should have appealed.
He would have got off!

No brains at Geelong.

 

[Tedeski]

Won't really be fair if roughead doesn't go for that especially that stevie j did. Maxwell will get 2.

Poor footage. Dawes wasn't too shaken up. He kept playing.

Reprimand only for both Roughy & Maxwell.

Geelong should have contested for Stevie J!

I repeat!!

 

[Coaster2012]

Maxwell was horrific last night, he was almost a liability, he should go for a week at least, if he doesn't, there's no freaking consistency in the game.

 

[Cuzz09]

Should shave his head again. Seemed better then.

 

[Truck25]

Nobody should be suspended for any of the 'incidents' in the game last night.

They were all pissweak, nobody was hurt, none were deliberate thuggery (just a show if strength or niggling) - but they've set the precedent for this crap, and I doubt they'll wise up now.

According to the doctors report (maybe from Richmond doctor) Maxwell broke Puopolo's nose, so I would say somebody was hurt, cause that hurts like a biatch

 

[CAS79]

footage isn't great. Amazing they only have one blurry shot of the incident... how with modern cameras do you get such a poor shot of it?

 

[Cuzz09]

footage isn't great. Amazing they only have one blurry shot of the incident... how with modern cameras do you get such a poor shot of it?

Channel 7 footage.... Maxwell works for channel 7.... convenient

 

[Black Diamond]

Hypothetically, if a Hawk's player gets two games, do they miss the GF? That would seem an unfair punishment given if they lost last night they would have an extra and therefore could make it back for the final.

 

[Cuzz09]

Hypothetically, if a Hawk's player gets two games, do they miss the GF? That would seem an unfair punishment given if they lost last night they would have an extra and therefore could make it back for the final.

Yes they would.

 

[Obeanie1]

Low impact. Nothing in it

Reported Popolo had his nose broken.

So low impact and nothing in it isn't going to cut it.

If Stevie J got 1 week for his bump Maxwell should get two.

Amazingly silly thing to do, in fact Maxwell had multiple brain fades last night.

 

[B4Bear]

Maxwell doesn't have either a good or bad record.

He either gets nothing or at best he'll get two weeks.

High Contact, Intentional (only due to the Ottens rule), Low Impact - 6 activation points, level 3 ROugh Conduct - which is 325

Down to 243 with a plea

My only issue, firstly I don't think he meant any malice whatsoever - he was clearly trying to block the space and keeping Puopolo away from the ball. To then get assigned 3 activation points (for the intentional aspect) on the back of something which has zero malice is just poor.

FOr mine (at most) that should be negligent, High, low - 4 activation points - level 1 rough conduct which becomes 93 points with a plea

So he smashes a guy in the face, draws blood and he gets zero weeks with an early plea. Holy shit Batman, if I ever go to court can you be my judge?

 

[CoastersFlag No.5]

So he smashes a guy in the face, draws blood and he gets zero weeks with an early plea. Holy shit Batman, if I ever go to court can you be my judge?

"Puopolo left the field under the blood rule, the Hawks revealing later he received a broken nose. " has to be high contact medium impact now. He ain't getting off.

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

"Puopolo left the field under the blood rule, the Hawks revealing later he received a broken nose. " has to be high contact medium impact now. He ain't getting off.

3 with a 2

 

[Footy_Fan2007]

Your club let Stevie J down...............................they should have appealed.
He would have got off!

No brains at Geelong.

Rubbish he would have got 2. Why risk getting another week?

 

[Stratton_Gun]

Maxwell I didn't see the incident but since Puopolo drew blood he could be in trouble

Roughead looked like nothing in in but after Johnsons last week he could be in trouble. When I saw the replay, it looked like a half bump half push and I was suprised when Dawes stayed down so long. Hopefully just a reprimand

Gibson has no case to answer to. Even the umpire at the time said it was a free kick and nothing else in it

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

Roughead looked like nothing in in but after Johnsons last week he could be in trouble. When I saw the replay, it looked like a half bump half push and I was suprised when Dawes stayed down so long. Hopefully just a reprimand

You can't bump a bloke 50 metres away from the ball and drop him.

You certainly can't bump a bloke 50 metres away from the ball and drop him with a round house right.

Gibson has no case to answer to. Even the umpire at the time said it was a free kick and nothing else in it

 

[fomoco04]

Gibson has no case to answer to. Even the umpire at the time said it was a free kick and nothing else in it

Lynch got rubbed out earlier in the season for less.

 

[Neese]

Puopolo was bleeding prettty heavily, unless his nose spontaneously bled Maxwell deserves a couple of weeks. I'm guessing that's the main reason for Buckley's little discussion with the umpires, even though he claimed not to have seen the incident in the post match interview

 

[Cerpin Taxt]

Lynch got rubbed out earlier in the season for less.

Completely different.

 

[fomoco04]

Completely different.

How so?

 

[Cerpin Taxt]

How so?

Not running through it. MRP findings on Monday will be sufficient.