Traded Mega deal - 4 clubs, 2 players, 14 picks (inc #1, #2, #3, #8, #12 and 5 future picks)

[XhazzafootyX]

Did north get stooged

 

[Peter Sidorkiewicz]

Just for fun, if Tom is right, how do you think it is structured.

GWS
In: Pick 1
Out: Pick 3, Pick 12

North
In: Pick 2, Pick 3, Future 1st (PA)
Out: Pick 1, Horne-Francis, Future 2nd

Port
In: Horne-Francis, Ratugolea, Rioli, Future 2nd (NM)
Out: Pick 8, Pick 33, Pick 43,Future 1st

WCE
In: Pick 8, Pick 12, Pick 43, Future 2nd (Bris)
Out: Pick 2, Pick 40, Rioli

Brisbane
In: Pick 40
Out: Future 2nd

Geelong
In: Pick 33
Out: Ratugolea

I’m assuming Brisbane is only involved in that they need more current year picks for father/son selections and possible Dunkley trade

 

[A Bit Dusty]

You lost me when I saw Tom Browne

 

[tigs2010]

Feels like WC getting a bit shafted for pick 2

 

[random260]

Just for fun, if Tom is right, how do you think it is structured.

GWS
In: Pick 1
Out: Pick 3, Pick 12

North
In: Pick 2, Pick 3, Future 1st (PA)
Out: Pick 1, Horne-Francis, Future 2nd

Port
In: Horne-Francis, Ratugolea, Rioli, Future 2nd (NM)
Out: Pick 8, Pick 33, Pick 43, Future 1st

WCE
In: Pick 8, Pick 12, Pick 43, Future 2nd (Bris)
Out: Pick 2, Pick 40, Rioli

Brisbane
In: Pick 40
Out: Future 2nd

Geelong
In: Pick 33
Out: Ratugolea

I’m assuming Brisbane is only involved in that they need more current year picks for father/son selections and possible Dunkley trade

On what planet

Would you give up pick 2 for 8 + 12 + 20? For example

Pick 2 for 8 + 12 + 18 would get a meh okay fine

 

[Wellsy35]

On what planet

Would you give up pick 2 for 8 + 12 + 20? For example

Pick 2 for 8 + 12 + 18 would get a meh okay fine

Might want to have a crack at getting both Busslinger and Ginbey given Freo is likely out of the first round. Fast tracks the rebuild with local talent as opposed to taking a punt on a flight risk.

 

[Purple Suit]

Just for fun, if Tom is right, how do you think it is structured.

GWS
In: Pick 1
Out: Pick 3, Pick 12

North
In: Pick 2, Pick 3, Future 1st (PA)
Out: Pick 1, Horne-Francis, Future 2nd

Port
In: Horne-Francis, Ratugolea, Rioli, Future 2nd (NM)
Out: Pick 8, Pick 33, Pick 43,Future 1st

WCE
In: Pick 8, Pick 12, Pick 43, Future 2nd (Bris)
Out: Pick 2, Pick 40, Rioli

Brisbane
In: Pick 40
Out: Future 2nd

Geelong
In: Pick 33
Out: Ratugolea

I’m assuming Brisbane is only involved in that they need more current year picks for father/son selections and possible Dunkley trade

Port make out like Bandits.

 

[DanWA]

Eagles getting shafted in this deal

Port need to give up more

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Just for fun, if Tom is right, how do you think it is structured.

GWS
In: Pick 1
Out: Pick 3, Pick 12

North
In: Pick 2, Pick 3, Future 1st (PA)
Out: Pick 1, Horne-Francis, Future 2nd

Port
In: Horne-Francis, Ratugolea, Rioli, Future 2nd (NM)
Out: Pick 8, Pick 33, Pick 43,Future 1st

WCE
In: Pick 8, Pick 12, Pick 43, Future 2nd (Bris)
Out: Pick 2, Pick 40, Rioli

Brisbane
In: Pick 40
Out: Future 2nd

Geelong
In: Pick 33
Out: Ratugolea

I’m assuming Brisbane is only involved in that they need more current year picks for father/son selections and possible Dunkley trade

Looks pretty good.

Probably take out the 2nd going from North to us or send it to West Coast instead.

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Hojuman]

Port make out like Bandits.

Exactly.

 

[HeHateMe]

Alright I'll give it a crack.... Something like this?

GWS: 1 for 3, 12
North: 2, 3, F1st (Port) for 1, Horne-Francis
WC: 8, 12, 33 for 2, Rioli
Port: Horne-Francis, Ratugolea, Rioli, F2nd (Bris) for 8, 33, 43, F1st, F2nd
Geelong: F2nd (Port) for 58, Ratugolea
Bris: 43, 58 for F2nd

 

[Red mist]

It’s like the compression engine from Silicon Valley.
Just wank from all angles.

 

[Crow_68]

Just for fun, if Tom is right, how do you think it is structured.

GWS
In: Pick 1
Out: Pick 3, Pick 12

North
In: Pick 2, Pick 3, Future 1st (PA)
Out: Pick 1, Horne-Francis, Future 2nd

Port
In: Horne-Francis, Ratugolea, Rioli, Future 2nd (NM)
Out: Pick 8, Pick 33, Pick 43,Future 1st

WCE
In: Pick 8, Pick 12, Pick 43, Future 2nd (Bris)
Out: Pick 2, Pick 40, Rioli

Brisbane
In: Pick 40
Out: Future 2nd

Geelong
In: Pick 33
Out: Ratugolea

I’m assuming Brisbane is only involved in that they need more current year picks for father/son selections and possible Dunkley trade

Blimey, North are shafted there, particularly if they finish at the bottom and Port inside the top 4.

 

[buttox]

North including pick 1 to help port pay for jhf.
Why wouldn't we just do the swap with gws direct?
Getting ripped off hard in that.

 

[DEVO]

I hope Brady says no.

 

[SnowRoo]

Cats:
In - Ports F2 (for Bowes)
Out - Rata, F3

Bris:
In - 33
Out - Cats F2

WC:
In - 8, 12, 18, Bonner
Out - 2, 20, Rioli

GWS:
In - 1, Cats F2, Freo F3
Out - 3, 12, 15, 18, Haynes

Port:
In: JHF, Rioli, Rata, Haynes, Cats F3
Out - 8, 33, F1, F2, Bonner

North:
In - 2, 3, 15, 20, Port F1
Out - JHF, 1, Freo F3

 

[Crow_68]

Alright I'll give it a crack.... Something like this?

GWS: 1 for 3, 12
North: 2, 3, F1st (Port) for 1, Horne-Francis
WC: 8, 12, 33 for 2, Rioli
Port: Horne-Francis, Ratugolea, Rioli, F2nd (Bris) for 8, 33, 43, F1st, F2nd
Geelong: F2nd (Port) for 58, Ratugolea
Bris: 43, 58 for F2nd

That’s a pretty good effort

 

[Pure_Ownage]

I think its bs but just for fun

Gws out 3 12
In 1

NM Out 1 jhf, fr3 (nm) fr3 (freo)
In 2, 3, fr1 (port)

Port out 8, fr1, fr2, 33, 43, 53
In: jhf, esava, rioli, fr3 (freo)

Wce
Out 2 rioli
In 8 12 33, fr3 (nm)

Geelong Out 58 esava, fr3 (gee)
In 7, bowes

Gc out bowes, 7
In fr2 (port) fr 3 (geel)

Bris out 38
In 43 53 58

Im assuming the afl will tick off port trading future 1st and 2nd as a future 3rd is coming back in.

Who knows really though its all guesswork.

 

[Monocle]

Cats:
In - Ports F2 (for Bowes)
Out - Rata, F3

Bris:
In - 33
Out - Cats F2

WC:
In - 8, 12, 18, Bonner
Out - 2, 20, Rioli

GWS:
In - 1, Cats F2, Freo F3
Out - 3, 12, 15, 18, Haynes

Port:
In: JHF, Rioli, Rata, Haynes, Cats F3
Out - 8, 33, F1, F2, Bonner

North:
In - 2, 3, 15, 20, Port F1
Out - JHF, 1, Freo F3

Nice deal for you ( North ), pretty shitty deal for West Coast.

 

[random260]

Nice deal for you ( North ) pretty shitty deal for West Coast.

Nah I think that's fine oh wait we are giving up pick 20? Eh rather we not take Bonner.

But closest so far

 

[harper2bastinac]

This whole trade makes port look like bandits and everyone else crumble

 

[Monocle]

Nah I think that's fine oh wait we are giving up pick 20? Eh rather we not take Bonner.

I break that down to look like this:

Give up 2 for 8 & 12
Swap 18 for 20 woopy *ing doo a two spot upgrade.
Swap Rioli for Bonner

Looks shitty to me.

 

[Red mist]

Nice deal for you ( North ) pretty shitty deal for West Coast.

Who?

 

[DEVO]

There has been some discussion today about GWS giving North picks 3 & 12 for pick 1, but in this new "mega" deal we only get pick 3 off GWS for pick 1. If we are going to trade with GWS for pick 1, I would hope we do it separately as we are getting shafted royally here.

BTW I'm yet to be convinced trading pick 1 is a good idea, but the deals I've seen in this thread to date have done little to convince me.

 

[SnowRoo]

I think its bs but just for fun

Gws out 3 12
In 1

NM Out 1 jhf, fr3 (nm) fr3 (freo)
In 2, 3, fr1 (port)

Port out 8, fr1, fr2, 33, 43, 53
In: jhf, esava, rioli, fr3 (freo)

Wce
Out 2 rioli
In 8 12 33, fr3 (nm)

Geelong Out 58 esava, fr3 (gee)
In 7, bowes

Gc out bowes, 7
In fr2 (port) fr 3 (geel)

Bris out 38
In 43 53 58

Im assuming the afl will tick off port trading future 1st and 2nd as a future 3rd is coming back in.

Who knows really though its all guesswork.

If North give up 2 No1 picks and 2 future 3rds for 2, 3 and pick 12-14 in 23 I'm moving to GC and becoming a suns fan lol

 

[Red mist]

Good read Monocle but really. Positionong is just that.