Although he is young, Pears doesn't look like he has the body to play on the big forwards... I would of said the same about Fletcher when he was young.
We might go for Hartlett then
We might go for Hartlett then
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Merged Draft Threads - Part 3
- Thread starter Burzum
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
We need to rescue him from mediocrity.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Bombers41
Senior List
Knights on SEN this morning reckons were down to three players for pick 5, had good things to say about yarran when KB asked about him whatever that actually means. Also went on to say that all depends what he reckons we can get with pick 23.
Any idea of the three players???
Any idea of the three players???
- Nov 28, 2006
- 28,877
- 11,949
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Thread starter
- #731
Yarran, Trengove, Hurley
So you think Yarran is our man if we opt against KP? Hopefully Hartlett or Ziebell is still on the shortlist (or Rich if he is still available).
Interesting list RIG... I would be surprised if they have ruled out Sidebottom and Hartlett at this stage...
- May 6, 2007
- 48,142
- 31,370
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
they say one thing, but could mean another. who knows who we will take with pick 5.
Sorry guys, I must say i know nothing about this year's kids (other than YouTube videos).
Yarran is a small forward. I would find it strange if Essendon went after a forward, feeling that our defense and midfield needs more attention. Injuries aside we have a plethora of forwards and surely Yarran would be passed by us, unless he show potential in other areas?
Yarran is a small forward. I would find it strange if Essendon went after a forward, feeling that our defense and midfield needs more attention. Injuries aside we have a plethora of forwards and surely Yarran would be passed by us, unless he show potential in other areas?
- May 6, 2007
- 48,142
- 31,370
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
is it fair to say that only Davey is our small forward, as Jetta (from all reports) was picked up as midfielder, Monfries plays as a (hate saying it) high half forward, leading into the midfield, so that leaves us with Davey,
alot of people say he plays as a small forward in the WAFL, yes he may, because he does not have the enginve or the body size to make a consistant impact in the seniors. over time he will puch into the midfield, has a nice size (height) and build (weight) to pursue a career in the midfield, and as I think Ant555 has stated, he played down back in a couple of the championship games, and used the ball extremly well coming out of defence. the article at the moment floating around by Ashley Prescott shows me how much of an impressive young man he is, not just his ability on the field, but how down to earth, how assured he is, how much he wants to make an impact in life. he really is going to be a good player.
People need to realise that, we are not all going to get a palmer, or a rioli, a Hasleby, these types of players that walk into the seniors and make an impact immediately, thats why everyone gets so disappointed with our recruiters, wait till Gumby gets a few games going, see how much he develops over the next 18 months, and then in 3 years time (fingers crossed) could be the most damging player out a CHF since Nick Riewoldt exploded onto the scene. The player we pick up at 5, is going to be a very good player IMO, be it, Tom Swift, Michael Hurley Chris Yarren, who knows, they all could be anything, but then all could be nothing, and this is where, the general public forget how fickle this game of football really is.
alot of people say he plays as a small forward in the WAFL, yes he may, because he does not have the enginve or the body size to make a consistant impact in the seniors. over time he will puch into the midfield, has a nice size (height) and build (weight) to pursue a career in the midfield, and as I think Ant555 has stated, he played down back in a couple of the championship games, and used the ball extremly well coming out of defence. the article at the moment floating around by Ashley Prescott shows me how much of an impressive young man he is, not just his ability on the field, but how down to earth, how assured he is, how much he wants to make an impact in life. he really is going to be a good player.
People need to realise that, we are not all going to get a palmer, or a rioli, a Hasleby, these types of players that walk into the seniors and make an impact immediately, thats why everyone gets so disappointed with our recruiters, wait till Gumby gets a few games going, see how much he develops over the next 18 months, and then in 3 years time (fingers crossed) could be the most damging player out a CHF since Nick Riewoldt exploded onto the scene. The player we pick up at 5, is going to be a very good player IMO, be it, Tom Swift, Michael Hurley Chris Yarren, who knows, they all could be anything, but then all could be nothing, and this is where, the general public forget how fickle this game of football really is.
Even though you believe we don't quite have enough forwards, i feel this area is pretty well covered. However if, as you say, Yarran can play midfield and run out of defense, that makes me more confident in him. I was worried he would just purely play as a forward.
I feel we need a few more players that can play well in a few positions. That or a [potential] star midfielder/ KP backman, rather than just a one trick, small forward.
Quicky
Brownlow Medallist
- May 27, 2008
- 26,084
- 32,184
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Socceroos, Melbourne Victory
Hey guys, we're doing a mock draft game in the collingwood forum and i'm doing Essendon. Was just wondering how many picks Essendon are likely to use in the PSD this year??
I'll come back and post what I picked when its finished.
I'll come back and post what I picked when its finished.
my draft observations - pros and cons of each with respect to pick 5.
hurley - pro - the key defender essendon need
- con - perceived lack of pace, is he really worth pick 5?
yarran - pro - sublime skills and mature body for his age
- con - is he worth pick 5? with jetta, davey, lovett, monfries playing similar roles well will he benefit EFC much as i don't think he will have the engine to play mid.
trengove - pro - tall, quick, versatile
- con - injury prone?, is he a kepler bradley mk2 with no real position having been in between defence and ruck as junior? worth pick 5?
swift - pro - awesome u16 mid, DC testing excellent, good skills
- con - knee injury stopping much play for 2 years is a risk, worth pick 5?
ziebell - pro - decent skills, reads play well
- con - in between player - is he a nowhere man ie neither mid or kp. is it worth using pick 5 on a utility?
sidebottom - pro - natural footy player reads the play well, tough, endurance
- con - query pace
hartlett - pro - silky midfielder with minimal weaknesses in his game.
- con - doesn't appear to have any
From my perspective Hartlett or Sidebottom are the safest options as pick 5 guaranteeing a quality player when you look at pros and cons. Personally i think Hartlett has more upside than sidebottom and looks a potential star. Thats who i'd be taking - Hartlett.
hurley - pro - the key defender essendon need
- con - perceived lack of pace, is he really worth pick 5?
yarran - pro - sublime skills and mature body for his age
- con - is he worth pick 5? with jetta, davey, lovett, monfries playing similar roles well will he benefit EFC much as i don't think he will have the engine to play mid.
trengove - pro - tall, quick, versatile
- con - injury prone?, is he a kepler bradley mk2 with no real position having been in between defence and ruck as junior? worth pick 5?
swift - pro - awesome u16 mid, DC testing excellent, good skills
- con - knee injury stopping much play for 2 years is a risk, worth pick 5?
ziebell - pro - decent skills, reads play well
- con - in between player - is he a nowhere man ie neither mid or kp. is it worth using pick 5 on a utility?
sidebottom - pro - natural footy player reads the play well, tough, endurance
- con - query pace
hartlett - pro - silky midfielder with minimal weaknesses in his game.
- con - doesn't appear to have any
From my perspective Hartlett or Sidebottom are the safest options as pick 5 guaranteeing a quality player when you look at pros and cons. Personally i think Hartlett has more upside than sidebottom and looks a potential star. Thats who i'd be taking - Hartlett.
The_Gunny_Bomber
Senior List
I think that Hartlett's main down side is his skinny frame but oh course he he will bulk up. I also think that McCarthy had a more negative take on him than any other player he has reviewed on afl.com.au saying that he needs to be more meticulous with his preparation. I would still be very happy to take him though.
- May 6, 2007
- 48,142
- 31,370
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspurs, Melbourne Vixen
So it looks set that we are going to go for one of Hill, Yarren, or Hurley, who would you most like to see, I think Yarren could make an impact straight away, but then Hurley could be the long term answer we are looking for, but then again, Hill could be icing on the cake to our young and exciting midfield brigade.
Ben the Gooner
Stand by Hird
It doesn't look set on those three at all. It's merely media speculation. I doubt that the best journo with all of the contacts you could dream of would know what our preferences are. Hell, Dodoro's wife probably doesn't know.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Out of those 3 I'd choose Hill, but I'd rather pick Hartlett over any of them to be honest, but IF Lovett is gone unless he pulls a finger out of his arse he will..then Hill is a MUST!
If Lovett is gone? He's still signed to Essendon and barring injuries, poor form or another indiscretion he will play next year.
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Essendon will pick up one of these and their is no evidence to specify that we have narrowed it down to three.
Trengove
Hurley
Yarran
Swift
Hill
Sidebottom
Hartlett
Ziebell
Trengove
Hurley
Yarran
Swift
Hill
Sidebottom
Hartlett
Ziebell
Essendonfc_4_lyfe
Senior List
Other than Knights actually saying that we have narrowed it down to 3
Thats 3 presuming none of the big 3 slip?
Other than Knights actually saying that we have narrowed it down to 3
that is true but still anyone of these guys listed above could realistically be part of this group of 3 as none of us know. i'm doubting knights or dodoro are going to reveal their hand to anyone in the media or on bigfooty! i certainly hope they don't as it could jeopardise efc's drafting strategy.
if i had to guess i'd say hurley and trengove would be more than likely in this narrowed group of 3 - the other one is questionable. we have a journalist saying its hill, some poster saying swifts family said he was going at pick 5 and so on. there have been reports that essendon haven't even interviewed hartlett - playing games as a smokescreen?? its all a guessing game.
last year at pick 6 it was pretty clear it was either palmer or myers but this year at pick 5 its very difficult to narrow it down. certainly going to be an anxious wait i must say.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Yes, talking about 2010 with my post
cocobonobo
Senior List
hahaha,talking about 2010.
Thinking for the future.
You sound like my bank manager.
I like it.
Thinking for the future.
You sound like my bank manager.
I like it.
