Michael Kirby

medusala

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 14, 2004
Posts
34,959
Likes
6,230
Location
Loftus Road
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Thread starter #1
This guy is a disgrace. Speaking out against the elected govt and its policies. The media are a bunch of hypocritical muppets. Squealed like stuck pigs when pollies got stuck in to him and others over clueless decisions like Mabo and the concrete leftist McHugh who proclaimed the history of white Australia was "one of unutterable shame". Deafening silence when a high court judge criticises the govt though. He should resign immediately or else never complain again when pollies criticise his hard left dribble he passes off as informed judgement.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Contra Mundum

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 1, 2002
Posts
21,910
Likes
8,700
Location
North Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
NMFC
#2
Re: Igronance uber alles

medusala said:
This guy is a disgrace. Speaking out against the elected govt and its policies. The media are a bunch of hypocritical muppets. Squealed like stuck pigs when pollies got stuck in to him and others over clueless decisions like Mabo and the concrete leftist McHugh who proclaimed the history of white Australia was "one of unutterable shame". Deafening silence when a high court judge criticises the govt though. He should resign immediately or else never complain again when pollies criticise his hard left dribble he passes off as informed judgement.
I was at the 100th anniversary conference - Alll he said was that Australia is a Country that does not accept extreme ideology and that in such a coutnry an institution that enshrines a "fair go" was only natural.

Your comments on McHugh J are totally ignorant. In that last two years he as consistently made joint judgement with the "Capital C" conservatives on the Bench: namely Gleeson, Gummow,Heydon, Hayne and Callinan - so much for his "hard leftist" stance.

Michael Kirby is one of the most eminent jurists that Australia has ever produced: he was made a Deputy President on the Commission at age 36, became the youngest ever President of the Law Reform Commission, became the youngest ever President of the NSW Court of Appeal and his appointment to the High Court was seen by most lawyers as totally justified on merit.

Your line is similar to that of senator Heffernan who could not attack his judiical record but instead made totally baseless attacks which were thinly vailed prejudice of the most base kind.

For God sake don't waste our time making comments about things you know absolutely nothing about. If you want to talk about judicial activism have a look at the latest judgement of the Court in Electrolux.

The current ideological hegemony empowers tools like you to make attacks based on nothing more than emtpy rhetoric - move over Andrew Bolt and Janet Albrechsen there is a new kid on the block
 

MightyFighting

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jun 23, 2003
Posts
10,300
Likes
57
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Other Teams
Port Melbourne
#4
medusala said:
This guy is a disgrace. Speaking out against the elected govt and its policies. The media are a bunch of hypocritical muppets. Squealed like stuck pigs when pollies got stuck in to him and others over clueless decisions like Mabo and the concrete leftist McHugh who proclaimed the history of white Australia was "one of unutterable shame". Deafening silence when a high court judge criticises the govt though. He should resign immediately or else never complain again when pollies criticise his hard left dribble he passes off as informed judgement.
Kirby's a small-l liberal. Is that "hard left" to you?
 

medusala

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 14, 2004
Posts
34,959
Likes
6,230
Location
Loftus Road
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Thread starter #5
Kirby has made comment on it and was there for Wik.

It is very clear that politicians shouldnt comment on High Court decisions and High Court judges (and the GG for that matter) shouldnt comment on politics.

There have been numerous times when he has been in the dissenting minority, I dont have an issue with that. Its more that numerous cabinet ministers have been thoroughly criticised for speaking against court decisions whereas High Court judges are immune from criticism.

Have some bloody consistency.
 

Contra Mundum

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 1, 2002
Posts
21,910
Likes
8,700
Location
North Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
NMFC
#6
medusala said:
Kirby has made comment on it and was there for Wik.

It is very clear that politicians shouldnt comment on High Court decisions and High Court judges (and the GG for that matter) shouldnt comment on politics.

There have been numerous times when he has been in the dissenting minority, I dont have an issue with that. Its more that numerous cabinet ministers have been thoroughly criticised for speaking against court decisions whereas High Court judges are immune from criticism.

Have some bloody consistency.
May I remind you that the judicial arm is the Government.

In the last few years the pattern has been that Kirby is the only dissentiant - it is not the same as the Barwick Court where Mason and Deane were coupled. Since the retirement of Gerard Brennan I can only find two judgements where McHugh has been part of a dissenting minority - but hey lets not let the facts stand in the way of a good story - Terra Nullius was a total myth based on Western Chauvinism - it could not last further scrutiny by the Court.
 

Freo Big Fella

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Sep 30, 2003
Posts
10,731
Likes
5,399
Location
The great wide north
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
WA, Australia
#7
medusala said:
Kirby has made comment on it and was there for Wik.

It is very clear that politicians shouldnt comment on High Court decisions and High Court judges (and the GG for that matter) shouldnt comment on politics.

There have been numerous times when he has been in the dissenting minority, I dont have an issue with that. Its more that numerous cabinet ministers have been thoroughly criticised for speaking against court decisions whereas High Court judges are immune from criticism.

Have some bloody consistency.
He was also there for McGinty, and countless other conservative decisions that Howard's HCA has made, it all evens out in the end. Stop whinging.
 

medusala

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 14, 2004
Posts
34,959
Likes
6,230
Location
Loftus Road
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Thread starter #8
MightyFighting said:
Kirby's a small-l liberal. Is that "hard left" to you?
No doubt in comparison to others of the Hawke Era he is more to the centre. Arguably soft left but I certainly wouldnt say small l liberal and I dare say Keating had no intention of appointing a small l liberal to the HC.

I will repeat again that its not because I disagree with some of his decisions that I am annoyed its just that he feels free to speak out against politicians whilst demanding they leave the bench alone.

A High Court judge has labelled some detractors of the industrial relations system as "industrial ayatollahs", and says there is "no room for them in this nation".

Michael Kirby, in a speech yesterday defending the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, said the body had been "an instrument for the defence of fundamental human rights and dignity".

He then blasted critics of the commission who wanted to see it closed down, or have it converted into a mediatory body.

"Persons of such views tend to live in a remote world of fantasy, inflaming themselves by their rhetoric into more and more unreal passions, usually engaging in serious dialogue only with people of like persuasion," Justice Kirby said. "For the rest of us, who live in the real world, and know our country and its institutions better, time will not be wasted over such fairytales."


I would suggest that is vefry strong language to use and certainly not that of a small l liberal. In fact the words could easily have come from the mouth of Doug Cameron.
 

Contra Mundum

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 1, 2002
Posts
21,910
Likes
8,700
Location
North Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
NMFC
#9
medusala said:
No doubt in comparison to others of the Hawke Era he is more to the centre. Arguably soft left but I certainly wouldnt say small l liberal and I dare say Keating had no intention of appointing a small l liberal to the HC.

I will repeat again that its not because I disagree with some of his decisions that I am annoyed its just that he feels free to speak out against politicians whilst demanding they leave the bench alone.

A High Court judge has labelled some detractors of the industrial relations system as "industrial ayatollahs", and says there is "no room for them in this nation".

Michael Kirby, in a speech yesterday defending the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, said the body had been "an instrument for the defence of fundamental human rights and dignity".

He then blasted critics of the commission who wanted to see it closed down, or have it converted into a mediatory body.

"Persons of such views tend to live in a remote world of fantasy, inflaming themselves by their rhetoric into more and more unreal passions, usually engaging in serious dialogue only with people of like persuasion," Justice Kirby said. "For the rest of us, who live in the real world, and know our country and its institutions better, time will not be wasted over such fairytales."

I would suggest that is vefry strong language to use and certainly not that of a small l liberal. In fact the words could easily have come from the mouth of Doug Cameron.
He was a senior deputy president on the Commission and unlike the current federal minister who never took an industrial brief in all his time at the Victorian Bar he knows what he is talking about. The Industrial Ayatollahs was aimed more at Des Moore than the Government - in the Fin Review the day after the election he proposed the very things that Kirby is talking about abolition of the Commission and its replacement by a mediatory body. The Current Federal Government appears to be stopping short of that proposal.
 

medusala

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 14, 2004
Posts
34,959
Likes
6,230
Location
Loftus Road
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Thread starter #10
The guy clearly has a strong background in the area of IR, however the language he used was very strong. Imagine the uproar if Howard (or even journalists) began talking about HC judges in the same way. Might be a few libel cases flying around in a hurry.
 

Contra Mundum

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 1, 2002
Posts
21,910
Likes
8,700
Location
North Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
NMFC
#11
medusala said:
The guy clearly has a strong background in the area of IR, however the language he used was very strong. Imagine the uproar if Howard (or even journalists) began talking about HC judges in the same way. Might be a few libel cases flying around in a hurry.
What do you say about the egregious defamation of Kirby by Heffernan. Heffernan is still there and Daryl Williams, a silk who took an oath to be an officer of the Court ,stood by and let it happen without a wimper - even when the allegations were proven to be baseless and false!

What about Ruddock in response to the Kirby comments "He is a "Colourful judge" - he might as well said he was limp wristed and liked show tunes. This Government has pushed the envelope as far as criticism of judges is concerned. I remember only too well the campaign against Tony North during Patricks emanating from that slug Reith's Office.

Ruddock himself was called to the Federal Court bench to explain why he was not in contempt of Court during one of the many immigration matters.


They drew first blood!
I
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

funkyfreo

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Jul 21, 2004
Posts
6,912
Likes
4
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
Freo
#12
Kirby is the shining light, and constantly impresses me with his insightful comments in a sea of ultra-conservatism.
 

Ray Nolan

Blue & White Army!
Joined
Apr 27, 2003
Posts
11,088
Likes
975
Location
Magill
AFL Club
Port Adelaide
Other Teams
Adelaide United FC, Rangers FC
#13
Kirby J a disgrace? No. Prone to inane waffle in his judgments for the sake of showing off his knowledge? Yes. If only he could write like McHugh J, get to the point man!
 

Mead

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Mar 2, 2002
Posts
6,795
Likes
1,080
Location
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Eagles
#17
Ray Nolan said:
Kirby J a disgrace? No. Prone to inane waffle in his judgments for the sake of showing off his knowledge? Yes. If only he could write like McHugh J, get to the point man!
Totally agree.
A lot of extreme right people are anti-Kirby for frankly no other reason than they don't like the idea of a gay judge with presumably a gay agenda on the high court.

He is pretty frustrating to read just because he loves to throw in 50 pages or obiter for no good reason, but other than that his judgments aren't all that bad. Likes international agreements and frequently dissents because of that, but other than that he is actually pretty conservative in certain areas of law.

There's not actually anything wrong with having a frequently dissenting High Court Judge, it just means that both sides of any issue are recorded for future readers- if he wasn't openly gay (and thus apparently an evil lefty judge) 90% of his critics wouldn't even know who he was.

Bagging McHugh is utterly ridiculous- imo he's the most logical and consistent person in the high court, besides being a boon to law students everywhere because he actually gets to the bloody point. He'd be the ideal next CJ.
 

Contra Mundum

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Aug 1, 2002
Posts
21,910
Likes
8,700
Location
North Melbourne
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
NMFC
#19
Mead said:
Totally agree.
A lot of extreme right people are anti-Kirby for frankly no other reason than they don't like the idea of a gay judge with presumably a gay agenda on the high court.

He is pretty frustrating to read just because he loves to throw in 50 pages or obiter for no good reason, but other than that his judgments aren't all that bad. Likes international agreements and frequently dissents because of that, but other than that he is actually pretty conservative in certain areas of law.

There's not actually anything wrong with having a frequently dissenting High Court Judge, it just means that both sides of any issue are recorded for future readers- if he wasn't openly gay (and thus apparently an evil lefty judge) 90% of his critics wouldn't even know who he was.

Bagging McHugh is utterly ridiculous- imo he's the most logical and consistent person in the high court, besides being a boon to law students everywhere because he actually gets to the bloody point. He'd be the ideal next CJ.
What about Gummow for god's sake every judgement with him you get a history lesson of the developments in the law over the last three hundred years.

Has Callinan written a judgement beyond saying "I have had the benefit of reading the decision of the Chief Justice and I concur with it"
 

Mead

Norm Smith Medallist
Joined
Mar 2, 2002
Posts
6,795
Likes
1,080
Location
Perth
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Eagles
#20
Mark Perica said:
What about Gummow for god's sake every judgement with him you get a history lesson of the developments in the law over the last three hundred years.

Has Callinan written a judgement beyond saying "I have had the benefit of reading the decision of the Chief Justice and I concur with it"
You have to admire him- he's drawing an enormous wage for typing 'what he said' a couple of dozen times every year. I have a sneaking suspicion that when Callinan's wife asks him for some nookie, he calls up whoever the current CJ is, and asks him around to do the deed for him.

'I have had the benefit of watching the esteemed Chief Justice pound your quivering love mound... '
 

Minka Beaver

All Australian
Joined
Feb 5, 2004
Posts
930
Likes
1,346
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Everton
#21
Judging by the Mills & Boon style fiction that Callinan used to write for a hobby when he was a silk in Brisbane, I doubt he needs help thinking of ideas for the bedroom.
 
Top Bottom