Mid Season Player Reviews

[Just Kreuzing]

Don't worry Jim - we will soon be able to make a good team out of the players Just Kreuzing has criticized: Carrots, AB, Simmo, Carlos, Thornton, ?

Geez you and i a piles apart on what we both class good players, My god i call them serviceable and you think they are good if not great, what do you class the elite i wonder??? lol

If we dont have any ordinary players in your book i wonder how we are still only 7 and 7 and not already in the top bracket with all our good kids coming through, honestly!!

 

[Supasta #3 Murphy]

^^ i agree here.

there are elite players and the genuine good players who do their job week in week out.

Every team has the equivalent players to say a carrazzo, or AB. it's just how a team is these days.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

^^ i agree here.

there are elite players and the genuine good players who do their job week in week out.

Every team has the equivalent players to say a carrazzo, or AB. it's just how a team is these days.

So who do we consider for trade or to replace to improve our list with other elite or young players coming through.... Players from the elite bracket or players from the good ordinary or serviceable types???

 

[The Coach]

Geez you and i a piles apart on what we both class good players, My god i call them serviceable and you think they are good if not great, what do you class the elite i wonder??? lol

If we dont have any ordinary players in your book i wonder how we are still only 7 and 7 and not already in the top bracket with all our good kids coming through, honestly!!

You have to learn to read JK (remember you missed my startling revelation the other day too) - I said 'make a good team'. Good teams have a fair sprinkling of serviceable players in them. Nevertheless some of the mentioned are good players

The reference to 'great' is by you - once again exaggerating my statement hoping to strengthen your argument. Stick to the facts JK if possible.

Your last ridiculous paragraph makes me wonder if you can - you start with something I have not said and start raving. I notice and I hope others did too - that you did not deny the growing list of players you do not believe up to it

My one line statement once again to save you scrolling:
'we will soon be able to make a good team out of the players Just Kreuzing has criticized: Carrots, AB, Simmo, Carlos, Thornton, ? '

 

[Just Kreuzing]

You have to learn to read JK (remember you missed my startling revelation the other day too) - I said 'make a good team'. Good teams have a fair sprinkling of serviceable players in them. Nevertheless some of the mentioned are good players

The reference to 'great' is by you - once again exaggerating my statement hoping to strengthen your argument. Stick to the facts JK if possible.

Your last ridiculous paragraph makes me wonder if you can - you start with something I have not said and start raving. I notice and I hope others did too - that you did not deny the growing list of players you do not believe up to it

My one line statement once again to save you scrolling:
'we will soon be able to make a good team out of the players Just Kreuzing has criticized: Carrots, AB, Simmo, Carlos, Thornton, ? '

Dont claim them to be not up to it so much as i think they are more dispensible then others to strengthen our list, that is all.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

You have to learn to read JK (remember you missed my startling revelation the other day too) - I said 'make a good team'. Good teams have a fair sprinkling of serviceable players in them. Nevertheless some of the mentioned are good players

The reference to 'great' is by you - once again exaggerating my statement hoping to strengthen your argument. Stick to the facts JK if possible.

Your last ridiculous paragraph makes me wonder if you can - you start with something I have not said and start raving. I notice and I hope others did too - that you did not deny the growing list of players you do not believe up to it

My one line statement once again to save you scrolling:
'we will soon be able to make a good team out of the players Just Kreuzing has criticized: Carrots, AB, Simmo, Carlos, Thornton, ? '

My 1 line statement to you is that we will be able to make a good ordinary shit team with the players that you keep defending which has poor decision making and suspect skills and average footy smarts but agree they are in our best 25 or so at the moment and are required until better options become available or are drafted or are developed!

Its a discussion board / public forum Five!!!... people are allowed to discuss their opinions and views even if you disagree or feel obligated to shoot them down all the time.

 

[The Coach]

My 1 line statement to you is that we will be able to make a good ordinary shit team with the players that you keep defending which has poor decision making and suspect skills and average footy smarts but agree they are in our best 25 or so at the moment and are required until better options become available or are drafted or are developed!

Its a discussion board / public forum Five!!!... people are allowed to discuss their opinions and views even if you disagree or feel obligated to shoot them down all the time.

I will fire at crap every time mate - don't write it and you won't get hit

You have posted some decent stuff but don't you think the list of players you have sniped this week is pretty long?

 

[Just Kreuzing]

I will fire at crap every time mate - don't write it and you won't get hit

You have posted some decent stuff but don't you think the list of players you have sniped this week is pretty long?

I'm getting that strange feeling again.....Lol
And no you wont affect my views and thoughts no matter how compulsive you get.

 

[setanta17]

euchaboy and just kreuzing need to lighten up and start actually supporting carlton.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

euchaboy and just kreuzing need to lighten up and start actually supporting carlton.

Mate dont even start me, you have embarrassed yourself already by refering to washed up duds like Lucas, Tredrea and Westoff as possible scalps and there is some doubt on whether he even beat a couple of them and a ordinary kid like Hawkins...FFS, he couldnt get a kick if he was a clown at a rodeo!!

He would of been delisted 2 years ago if he wasn't Irish, he is getting extra leniancy because of his late start and lack of AFL knowledge and because everyone is enthralled with this "Project Player" title, He has done a great job so far to get to where he has in his career but now he must be judged fairly and on form and performances.

 

[setanta17]

Mate dont even start me, you have embarrassed yourself already by refering to washed up duds like Lucas, Tredrea and Westoff as possible scalps and there is some doubt on whether he even beat a couple of them and a ordinary kid like Hawkins...FFS, he couldnt get a kick if he was a clown at a rodeo!!

He would of been delisted 2 years ago if he wasn't Irish, he is getting extra leniancy because of his late start and lack of AFL knowledge and because everyone is enthralled with this "Project Player" title, He has done a great job so far to get to where he has in his career but now he must be judged fairly and on form and performances.

Tredrea and Westhoff are handy players, Lucas is a bit underdone but he is still handy atm and hawkins i agree is crap.

but why didnt u mention his games on pav, jono brown and trav cloke????
just kreuzing you really gotta start realising that you might be wrong.

 

[Just Kreuzing]

Tredrea and Westhoff are handy players, Lucas is a bit underdone but he is still handy atm and hawkins i agree is crap.

but why didnt u mention his games on pav, jono brown and trav cloke????
just kreuzing you really gotta start realising that you might be wrong.

Thought he was ok on Brown after the red hot start JB had, Pav killed us but yes he certainly stuck at it and i dont rate Cloke at all so we wont go there.

I thought Tredrea was good for most part in the Port game then it never came down there during the 4th quarter.

Wrong about what??? what have i said you think is wrong??? Thats an opinion is it??? Any thought you might be wrong, I am not the one who is over rating Setanta here, think he has been ok, just ok thats all.

 

[setanta17]

Thought he was ok on Brown after the red hot start JB had, Pav killed us but yes he certainly stuck at it and i dont rate Cloke at all so we wont go there.

I thought Tredrea was good for most part in the Port game then it never came down there during the 4th quarter.

Wrong about what??? what have i said you think is wrong??? Thats an opinion is it??? Any thought you might be wrong, I am not the one who is over rating Setanta here, think he has been ok, just ok thats all.

well ive given him 6.5/10 so i really dont think thats overrating him too much. as he is one of my favourite players i do focus on him a lot during games and besides from against richmond he has been beating his opponent week in week out.