Land of the Giants
Premiership Player
I think we can be reasonably satisfied with our performance this afternoon against North Melbourne. They made us earn it, and we responded appropriately. Can't ask for much more than that.
With no match this week, I thought we could spend some time reflecting on the first half of the season.
The Good
The Performance of the Midfield
There was some trepidation at the end of last season when Dylan Shiel packed his bags and returned home to Victoria. How would we cope? Well, the answer to date has been, "just fine". Tim Taranto and Jacob Hopper have stepped up, provided a bit of grunt, and generally performed above expectations, allowing Josh Kelly and especially Stephen Coniglio to shine. Perhaps more importantly, everyone seems to have "clicked". Are we better off without Dylan? It's a reasonable conclusion.
Round 4 - Victory in Geelong
After being utterly humiliated at the same venue last season, we enjoyed a character-testing win against a team we've always struggled against, and on their home turf, where just about everyone struggles. The win was bitter-sweet, as we lost our inspirational captain Callan Ward for the season to an ACL. But we responded just the way Callan would have wanted.
Was this a grand final preview? Plenty seem to think so.
The Bad
Injuries roll on, but...
The glissando of injuries that seriously affected the team over the past two seasons seems to have continued - just have a look at the list before today - but for some reason, it doesn't seem to be as debilitating as in 2017 and 2018. We must be doing something in terms of managing training loads that is working, but we're still a bit banged up. The bye couldn't have come at a better time.
Round 5 - The Dockers burst our Canberra bubble
Our first loss in the nation's capital in four years. It wasn't expected either. Most disappointing.
More members than ever, but where are the crowds?
We've now got over 28,000 members (wow!), but where are they on match days, especially in Sydney? After a bright start against the Bombers, the crowds have steadily dribbled away to half of those who showed up in Round 1. There's a chance for redemption with matches to come against Brisbane, Collingwood, Big Brother and the Bulldogs, so come on, all you Westies. We've even got a Penrith boy in the team these days!
The Entirely Forgettable
Round 8 - More MCG misery
Our record at the home of football is appalling. We certainly rolled back the hands of time against the Hawks, scoring only five goals, and equaling our seventh lowest score ever. Like Geelong at the Cattery last year, when we're bad, we're horrid.
It's time to open up the discussion. Have at it.
With no match this week, I thought we could spend some time reflecting on the first half of the season.
The Good
The Performance of the Midfield
There was some trepidation at the end of last season when Dylan Shiel packed his bags and returned home to Victoria. How would we cope? Well, the answer to date has been, "just fine". Tim Taranto and Jacob Hopper have stepped up, provided a bit of grunt, and generally performed above expectations, allowing Josh Kelly and especially Stephen Coniglio to shine. Perhaps more importantly, everyone seems to have "clicked". Are we better off without Dylan? It's a reasonable conclusion.
Round 4 - Victory in Geelong
After being utterly humiliated at the same venue last season, we enjoyed a character-testing win against a team we've always struggled against, and on their home turf, where just about everyone struggles. The win was bitter-sweet, as we lost our inspirational captain Callan Ward for the season to an ACL. But we responded just the way Callan would have wanted.
Was this a grand final preview? Plenty seem to think so.
The Bad
Injuries roll on, but...
The glissando of injuries that seriously affected the team over the past two seasons seems to have continued - just have a look at the list before today - but for some reason, it doesn't seem to be as debilitating as in 2017 and 2018. We must be doing something in terms of managing training loads that is working, but we're still a bit banged up. The bye couldn't have come at a better time.
Round 5 - The Dockers burst our Canberra bubble
Our first loss in the nation's capital in four years. It wasn't expected either. Most disappointing.
More members than ever, but where are the crowds?
We've now got over 28,000 members (wow!), but where are they on match days, especially in Sydney? After a bright start against the Bombers, the crowds have steadily dribbled away to half of those who showed up in Round 1. There's a chance for redemption with matches to come against Brisbane, Collingwood, Big Brother and the Bulldogs, so come on, all you Westies. We've even got a Penrith boy in the team these days!
The Entirely Forgettable
Round 8 - More MCG misery
Our record at the home of football is appalling. We certainly rolled back the hands of time against the Hawks, scoring only five goals, and equaling our seventh lowest score ever. Like Geelong at the Cattery last year, when we're bad, we're horrid.
It's time to open up the discussion. Have at it.
Last edited: