Review Mike's Top 50 post season

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Alice

Team Captain
Joined
May 11, 2009
Posts
578
Likes
213
AFL Club
Carlton
#53
great question. right now i'd take pendles based simply on the fact that he is younger and can still improve. if both were at the same age however it would be judd. you dont find players like pendlebury often same goes for judd but pendles is what 6'4 and moves like he does ! yes i know judds tall to but i think his height might be 2cms above what he actually is.
Wasn't a great question - pretty much rhetorical. Judd judged by peers as games MVP. I rate Pendlebury, but FMD. It would be interesting to see who McKenna or Sheedy would have taken if they could have a free pick. Their top 10 would give a far greater indication than Mike Sheahan (heraldSuns equivalent of Carolyn Wilson)
 
Joined
Mar 21, 2008
Posts
6,676
Likes
1,031
Location
In the box
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Northern Blues
#54
Clearly you have yet to watch much football media. It is his arrogant, pompous attitude in interviews. He also comes off extremely anti-Carlton (even when the Eagles have no upcoming game against us) rubs me the wrong way as well. Is not the sharpest tool in the shed yet behaves as though he is. He was on the Footy Show a few weeks back with Andrew Embley advertising his pub/restaurant. Andrew Embley, who admittedly is one of his best mates (and business partner at said restaurant) was taking the piss out of him for being aloof.
Seeing as though I am old enough to be your father, I have seen a bit. If you are asking if I still watch the footy show - the answer is no. Know an exWCE who though Cox was a good bloke and I believe he is a mate of Juddy's. I just think you are slandering a person you do not even know. :rolleyes:
 
Joined
Jul 5, 2011
Posts
863
Likes
275
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Chelsea FC, Houston Rockets
#55
Wasn't a great question - pretty much rhetorical. Judd judged by peers as games MVP. I rate Pendlebury, but FMD. It would be interesting to see who McKenna or Sheedy would have taken if they could have a free pick. Their top 10 would give a far greater indication than Mike Sheahan (heraldSuns equivalent of Carolyn Wilson)
yes but if it was based on pure abillty at the moment i'd take pendlebury. mvp's change from year to year. pendlebury has more time left at the top than judd does simple argument. be one eyed about it i dont really care just understand that pendlebury is and will be from here on in the better footballer than judd.
 

blues4flag

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Jul 1, 2004
Posts
21,365
Likes
859
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
#57
Seeing as though I am old enough to be your father, I have seen a bit. If you are asking if I still watch the footy show - the answer is no. Know an exWCE who though Cox was a good bloke and I believe he is a mate of Juddy's. I just think you are slandering a person you do not even know. :rolleyes:
Apparently great friends with Judd. The perceived Carlton 'hate' is just banter between him and his former teammate.
 
Top Bottom