Mock 25! its started

[SouthSwans]

Hugh Sandilands would be great for the Swans in 2nd or 3rd round.

 

[mj23]

Hugh Sandilands would be great for the Swans in 2nd or 3rd round.

if you were going to use your first pick who would you take.

 

[borgy]

Here is my take. Spaces denote where I see a drop off in class.
1. Richmond - Kreuzer

2. Carlton - Cotchin
3. Melbourne - Masten
4. Brisbane - Morton
5. Port - Palmer
6. StKilda - Henderson

7. Kangaroos - Grimes
8. Fremantle - McEvoy
9. Essendon - Ebert

10. Bulldogs - Gaertner
11. Collingwood - Bellchambers
12. Hawthorn - Collier
13. Sydney - Grant
14. Adelaide - Rioli
15. Geelong - Selwood

16. West Coast - Greenwood
17. Richmond - Veszpremi
18. Carlton - Rance
19. Brisbane - Gourdis
20. Melbourne - Myer
21. Port - Maric

You seem to know your stuff.

Out of them, who is AFL ready and who has played senoirs?

 

[mj23]

Maybe Rance seems like a good option but it looks like who ever done the last mock draft doesn't really rate him.

 

[nevil]

scott simpson
is a ready made afl player and all he needs is to work on a bit of pace
which can come with work over a pre season
i like jarrad grant being in the top 15 which is where he will go because he may not look it but is very versatile and can play from anywhere from FF to ruck and FB

potts to small?

 

[Rowie09]

Hawthorn will target Tom Collier.

Key position backman with plenty of run. Also a Tasmanian.

 

[mj23]

If he is better than Rance I think the swans might get him because the hawks might finish a little higher.

 

[HBF]

10. Bulldogs - Gaertner

Interesting call there Dan. Care to elaborate on why you think Steven will go that high?

 

[_RT_]

I see people listing picks for clubs yet they seem to be overlooking the fact that Richmond are on course from a PP at 17 this year. How would that affect the way your choices are?

 

[Salaryman]

Interesting call there Dan. Care to elaborate on why you think Steven will go that high?

Probably because Weaver had him at #6

 

[Main Man]

Hawthorn will target Tom Collier.

Key position backman with plenty of run. Also a Tasmanian.

Or Tayte Pears.. Both seem to be the type of player I believe we will be looking for..

 

[ant555]

Hawthorn will target Tom Collier.

Key position backman with plenty of run. Also a Tasmanian.

I know that Collier has been playing a lot of CHB in the under 18's but i dont think he will be a genuine KPP. In the end i think he will be a running HBF / RR.
He looked very good playing on the ball against NSW.

 

[Fireman_sam]

scott simpson
is a ready made afl player and all he needs is to work on a bit of pace
which can come with work over a pre season
i like jarrad grant being in the top 15 which is where he will go because he may not look it but is very versatile and can play from anywhere from FF to ruck and FB

potts to small?

Nevill again we meet.

Jarrad Grant is an extremely versitile player. He can play a number of positions. He is wasted talent playing at full back. I think he needs to be in the thick of the action. half back, wing, half forward or full forward. Wouldnt put him at full back the kid is too good for down there he has pure class...

Fill me in on Luke Potts please nevill and Tim Strickland... heard he is an outside chance?

 

[Fitz roos]

I'll give it a go from what i have seen: Space means drop off in class. I'll only do top 10 though

1. Rich- Kruezer
2. Carl- Cotchin (Bad carnival but pretty talented from what i have heard)
3. Melb- Masten (Ball magnet, i read that throughout his career he has avgd 31 disposals a game)

4. Bris- Morton (Very good player, would love him to slip to the roos' first pick)
5. Saints- Ebert

6. Port- Henderson (Never seen him, just going by what i have heard)
7. Fre- McEvoy
8. Kang- Palmer (Great carnival, but i still have my doubts about him, hopefully he proves me wrong)
9. Ess- Rioli ( Huge upside)
10. Sydney- Grimes (Solid player)

 

[OldSchool]

Interesting call there Dan. Care to elaborate on why you think Steven will go that high?

He's a terrific talent and should go high. Good fit for the Dogs as well.

 

[HBF]

He's a terrific talent and should go high. Good fit for the Dogs as well.

Terrific talent yes. Just not sure I would have him that high given the quality of the players around him.

 

[ford_dealer]

He's a terrific talent and should go high. Good fit for the Dogs as well.

Talented athletic-wise.

Interested to know how long he has actually been playing football

 

[nevil]

Nevill again we meet.

Jarrad Grant is an extremely versitile player. He can play a number of positions. He is wasted talent playing at full back. I think he needs to be in the thick of the action. half back, wing, half forward or full forward. Wouldnt put him at full back the kid is too good for down there he has pure class...

Fill me in on Luke Potts please nevill and Tim Strickland... heard he is an outside chance?

i was saying grant can play anywhere from FF to FB
as u said extremely versatile and agile player for his size

luke potts is a small on baller who is about 178 -180cms played for vic metro and was best on against SA with 18 possesions 10 tackles and four goals, he also in the last game was up in the 20 possesions and leading the 1%'s count.. would be better than cotching if speed was better and was a couple of inches taller

tim strickland is not a chance to be drafted was cut from stingrays in the last cut.. has shown magnificent form in the agsv with 4 BOG in a row for peninsula and holding his own keeping maric to 3 goals in a complete missmatch, strickland is about 183-186 and has a booming kick but doubt he will be looked at

 

[HBF]

Talented athletic-wise.

Interested to know how long he has actually been playing football

I'm pretty sure he's played a significant amount of junior footy, but I couldn;t tell you how much. What I can tell you is that he has played most of his junior footy in the ruck.

 

[nevil]

Talented athletic-wise.

Interested to know how long he has actually been playing football

been playing football ever since i can remember for his local side edithvale aspendale, caught a lucky break when he was emergency for vic metro in under 15's and the ruck broke his arm and then steve was named in the all aus team after a terrific carnival and gone on to do other things such as AIS and u-18 vic metro this year

 

[ford_dealer]

been playing football ever since i can remember for his local side edithvale aspendale, caught a lucky break when he was emergency for vic metro in under 15's and the ruck broke his arm and then steve was named in the all aus team after a terrific carnival and gone on to do other things such as AIS and u-18 vic metro this year

I have seen him play a couple of times. This year at the championships he looked a bit out of his depth. But at TAC he has looked right at home. Gets the ball and uses his athleticism. Isnt afraid to take them on. Will no doubt only improve, but the general perception from the way he is talked about on here, is that he has only recently started playing football and learning the game

 

[HBF]

I have seen him play a couple of times. This year at the championships he looked a bit out of his depth. But at TAC he has looked right at home. Gets the ball and uses his athleticism. Isnt afraid to take them on. Will no doubt only improve, but the general perception from the way he is talked about on here, is that he has only recently started playing football and learning the game

Lets just say he didn't do his chances of of being drafted any favours yesterday. Over ran the ball, fumbled, and made a few bad decisions both by hand and by foot. Still, an exciting prospect nonetheless.

 

[DanA]

Terrific talent yes. Just not sure I would have him that high given the quality of the players around him.

He seems a lot like O'Halpin and will be a project player but the sky is the limit as far as potention goes. Attacking player well and truelly big enough to play Key position. Also has the attacking game to suit the Western Bulldogs .

 

[HBF]

He seems a lot like O'Halpin and will be a project player but the sky is the limit as far as potention goes. Attacking player well and truelly big enough to play Key position. Also has the attacking game to suit the Western Bulldogs .

Just think it might be too high for him. But, it only needs one club interested to pull the trigger. He is one player I found difficult ranking.

 

[DanA]

Just think it might be too high for him. But, it only needs one club interested to pull the trigger. He is one player I found difficult ranking.

His rating changes for me on a daily basis