Most dishonest players in the comp? Your top 10

[Tzatziki_Man]

Let's not make this about 'clubs', we all have them. In fact, it could be argued these guys are the best team-mates. They do whatever they can to win, but in no order, can you list the top 10 players that you've spotted doing a dodgy? Whether it be milk a free, karate kick someone to mark a ball, win an Oscar, duck like donald or flop like a fish.

Here are my top 10

Tom Papley
Gryan Miers
Paul Puopolo
Dylan Grimes
Ben Brown
Luke Shuey
Jack McCrae
Joel Selwood
Callan Ward
Toby Greene

 

[Power Raid]

the fact we have a thread like this suggests something is becoming very wrong culturally in the AFL

it's time for the AFL to read the riot act and then start suspending players

 

[Pykie]

Let's not make this about 'clubs', we all have them. In fact, it could be argued these guys are the best team-mates. They do whatever they can to win, but in no order, can you list the top 10 players that you've spotted doing a dodgy? Whether it be milk a free, karate kick someone to mark a ball, win an Oscar, duck like donald or flop like a fish.

Here are my top 10

Tom Papley
Gryan Miers
Paul Puopolo
Dylan Grimes
Ben Brown
Luke Shuey
Jack McCrae
Joel Selwood
Callan Ward
Toby Greene

Is Rance technically still on Richmonds list?

The absolute emperor of this group for the last 4-5 years.

 

[Marc_Remillard]

Milne, easily, stole an AFL career

 

[Milanista28]

Walters is number 1, takes little dives/throws head back every contest he's in, Superstar though

 

[Jaeger]

1.Selwood
2.Ablett
3.Dangerfield
4.Papley
5.Fantasia
6.Mcdonald-Tipungwuti
7.Brown
8.Gray
9.Walters
10.Mathieson

 

[Kwality]

Walters is number 1, takes little dives/throws head back every contest he's in, Superstar though

Like Sellwood he is first to the ball. The only problem is beating them to the ball, very few players can.

 

[Virgin Dog]

Let's not make this about 'clubs', we all have them. In fact, it could be argued these guys are the best team-mates. They do whatever they can to win, but in no order, can you list the top 10 players that you've spotted doing a dodgy? Whether it be milk a free, karate kick someone to mark a ball, win an Oscar, duck like donald or flop like a fish.

Here are my top 10

Tom Papley
Gryan Miers
Paul Puopolo
Dylan Grimes
Ben Brown
Luke Shuey
Jack McCrae
Joel Selwood
Callan Ward
Toby Greene

On reputation, Dogs could put forward Toby McLean too. Back in 2017 he was shocking for milking the high frees with his ducking, and even though he has largely removed it from his game since then, I don't think he'll shake that label.

Worst offender in the current game would be Ben Brown, never seen someone throw their arms up as often as he does at the slightest bit of contact.

Almost need to split players into 3 groups, using the most high profile examples for each:
Duckers (Shuey/Selwood)
Milkers (Papley/Brown)
Stagers (Grimes/Ward)

 

[Milanista28]

Like Sellwood he is first to the ball. The only problem is beating them to the ball, very few players can.

I think Selwood sucks players in wheras Walters is only trying to suck the umpire in

 

[Ambrosia]

Mckernan has no idea he is grabbing his opponent by the jumper so lies to the umpires about it after they’ve awarded a free kick against him.

 

[Engimal v3]

10 Richmond players.

 

[Ricky Vaughn]

Jeremy Howe
Jordan DeGoey
Wayne Carey
Gary Lyon
Stephen Milne
Andrew Lovett
Damian Cupido
Heath Scotland
Shannon Grant
Nick Stevens

 

[STPer18]

Grimes is one of the premiere flops in the comp. Has been doing it for years, well before Richmond became good.

 

[Asifhe Givashe]

Jeremy Howe
Jordan DeGoey
Wayne Carey
Gary Lyon
Stephen Milne
Andrew Lovett
Damian Cupido
Heath Scotland
Shannon Grant
Nick Stevens

What about your murderer?

Hello?

Justin Murphy?
Adam Heuskas and Michael O’loughlin?
John Nicholls?

 

[Gaben]

Josh Thomas - he's an Uber driver impersonating an AFL footballer for 7 years now, that's the height of dishonesty IMO.

 

[Ricky Vaughn]

What about your murderer?

Hello?

Justin Murphy?
Adam Heuskas and Michael O’loughlin?
John Nicholls?

Why is your list only at 4?

 

[bzparkes]

Curious list considering Rance is still on Richmond's and is clear no.1


Seriously though, nobody mentioned Jordan DeGoey and his dog?

 

[Dons4days]

Josh Daicos is one of the worst. Its shame as he's actually quite a talented footballer until he throws his head back like he's been shot after not even being touched.

Michael Walters is in the same category.

 

[Milanista28]

Merrett and Joey like a floppy every now and then

 

[Mofra]

Phill Inn gets a nod, surely

 

[Milanista28]

Also Cody Weightman has started his career strongly doing this stuff.

 

[kylegee28]

Bit surprised the magician hasn't rated a mention. I love him the man but he's a cheeky campaigner.

 

[HaroLad]

Alex Rance

 

[Greenac]

Jack Riewoldt skips dishonesty and goes straight to abuse when it comes to umpires if that is any help

 

[PetterdHoisted]

Let's not make this about 'clubs', we all have them. In fact, it could be argued these guys are the best team-mates. They do whatever they can to win, but in no order, can you list the top 10 players that you've spotted doing a dodgy? Whether it be milk a free, karate kick someone to mark a ball, win an Oscar, duck like donald or flop like a fish.

Here are my top 10

Tom Papley
Gryan Miers
Paul Puopolo
Dylan Grimes
Ben Brown
Luke Shuey
Jack McCrae
Joel Selwood
Callan Ward
Toby Greene

Gryan jumps out for me on that list.