MRP / Trib. MRP 2017

[youmewe]

At 11.40 in DrMike's video.

http://203.36.101.148/Telstra/AFL-W...-05-07_06-23-35-7679/output_2400kbps_720p.mp4

 

[Admiral Byng]

definitely there. lucky to get a fine I reckon.

 

[yoong]

$1000 to smack Hurley in the nuts. Worth it.

On MIX using BigFooty.com mobile app

It did? Thought it's the abdominal. Doesn't matter either way.

 

[ilikepotatoes]

definitely there. lucky to get a fine I reckon.

Lucky he didn't get him flush in the groin. Didn't Heath Shaw miss a match or two for Doing similar to Ballantyne but connecting fully?

 

[masai]

A back hander to the wedding gear of Hurley . Reprimand only ,nothing in it.

The Taxi Drivers Union, are fully behind that back hander.

 

[Square Peg]

Jesus I didn't see that at the game, that looks bad on video. Should there be a loading for risking father-son potential?

 

[Nothing]

Dawson's at the MRP!

Houli's reps are referencing his hit on Cameron.

EDIT: I didn't think the tribunal considered precedent?

 

[go_the_dockers]

**** the Mrp hate us. Two weeks for McCarthy.

 

[Van_Dyke]

**** the Mrp hate us. Two weeks for McCarthy.

tbh I think careless contact with high impact was the right way to grade that given how the MRP works. All the MRP could do thanks to how the work, was to give Cam 2 weeks

 

[Nothing]

tbh I think careless contact with high impact was the right way to grade that. All the MRP could do, is to give Cam 2 weeks

He tackled a guy to the ground. Wasn't even a free kick. Ends up as the same penalty as the tribunal originally decided that Bachar should get.

 

[Juggs Magnetic]

Admit I didn't see anything wrong with the tackle, that sort of thing seems to happen all the time. Is it just based on the fact that Gilbert was injured? If he had an arm free to break his fall I doubt it would have even been looked at. Am I being one eyed?

 

[Midnite65]

Wasn't a free kick or relay free yet Carlisle who did a dog act and pushed Ballantyne when he could have been injured on the ground which then basically started the melee gets fined? If you are an interstate team or low profile player you always get shafted by the MPR or AFL, time and time again.

 

[Carnthedockers]

This has to be a joke? Are we going to ban tackling now? What more could he have done? it isnt a sling tackle!

 

[Tonga Bob]

He tackled a guy to the ground. Wasn't even a free kick. Ends up as the same penalty as the tribunal originally decided that Bachar should get.

Lance Franklin meanwhile was cleared of an incident involving a tackle. Didn't see what he did though. How similar was it to McCarthy's?

 

[Nothing]

Admit I didn't see anything wrong with the tackle, that sort of thing seems to happen all the time. Is it just based on the fact that Gilbert was injured? If he had an arm free to break his fall I doubt it would have even been looked at. Am I being one eyed?

Gilbert did have his arm free. He was too busy watching his throw/handball.

 

[Allikat]

What a joke. I hope the club appeals this one. They've banned him purely on outcome and not the action. He wasn't lifted off the ground, his arms weren't pinned. It was a standard, every day tackle, it just unfortunately ended up with the player being stretchered off.

 

[wild side]

Depends on medical reports, and seeing as how one of our players was allegedly eye gouged, i can't see st kilda playing nice on this one

 

[StingBitten]

Oh how I've missed the chook lotto. Anyone have footage? Can't find on the AFL website.

McCarthy needs to build some confidence in Peel, not sitting in the magoos for the next 2 weeks.

 

[calaisking]

I knew Cam would get a week as soon as the stretcher came out. 2 is very stiff.

No word from the Jack Stevens report. Edit : $1500 fine

 

[Kram]

The BF Taberner fan club will love this. I'd laugh if he still doesn't get selected..

 

[Purple Jesus]

2 weeks for that? Not his fault the dude doesn't know how to fall.

 

[StingBitten]

He gets up and dusts himself off - free-kick at best.

This game's a strange one.

 

[youmewe]

What a joke. I hope the club appeals this one. They've banned him purely on outcome and not the action. He wasn't lifted off the ground, his arms weren't pinned. It was a standard, every day tackle, it just unfortunately ended up with the player being stretchered off.

 

[Wally Walpamur]

Did Gilbert have the ball when he was tackled or had he already disposed of it?

Would this even be looked at if Gilbert had the ball when he was tackled?

 

[Allikat]

Oh how I've missed the chook lotto. Anyone have footage? Can't find on the AFL website.

McCarthy needs to build some confidence in Peel, not sitting in the magoos for the next 2 weeks.

http://www.afl.com.au/video/2017-07-02/gilbert-knocked-out-from-heavy-tackle