Amazing inconsistency. Hurn runs two metres past the ball and puts the guy on a stretcher with no case to answer, but Fyfey clips Greenwood with his elbow and it’s bye bye Brownlow. * I hate this sport sometimes.
MRP is a flip flopping circus
- Thread starter Jimbos1
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Amazing inconsistency. Hurn runs two metres past the ball and puts the guy on a stretcher with no case to answer, but Fyfey clips Greenwood with his elbow and it’s bye bye Brownlow. * I hate this sport sometimes.
Come on, nothing in that one - we would be filthy if a freo player got suspended for what hurn did.
Frank J Moose
Club Legend
You mean like when Sandilands coppped a week for Griffiths running inti him?
My memory’s not reliable nowadays but I remember MJ getting weeks for a rump bump on some North Melbourne (I think) dude a number of years ago. It was puny compared to what Hurn did.
Preseason game, got 4 weeks after we unsuccessfully challenged.
Not like I remember the incident all that well and I'm definitely not still bitter over it...
Nyhuis lays a robust tackle, the likes of which have been the cornerstone of this game for a hundred years, Gray gets concussed but plays next week. Three weeks.
Howe thrusts out his leg and trips a bloke, something that’s been forever banned in this game, breaks Fisher’s leg. Gerard and Robbo call for two weeks.
Howe thrusts out his leg and trips a bloke, something that’s been forever banned in this game, breaks Fisher’s leg. Gerard and Robbo call for two weeks.
Need a separate "Caviar and Keg" thread for their collective and repetitive idiocy.
Sabtaj
Debutant
I don’t post very often but can someone explain to me the difference between Charlie Curnow and Fyfe’s incidents! The MRP panel is a joke!
Nyhuis 3 weeks. Parfitt just a fine. Nice work again MRP.
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-08-04/young-cat-cops-fine-for-rough-conduct
http://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-08-04/young-cat-cops-fine-for-rough-conduct
- Jul 20, 2014
- 8,194
- 18,414
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
That is an utter farce
GAGF
Another BS result. No surprise there. MRO is driven by media outrage which is what forces the AFL to act. No media outrage here so it can slip quietly by. Decision already made so Doesn’t even get to the post weekend media cycle to give them a chance to rant. No other response than GAGF MRO is appropriate
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Keeps our nose in front as the world's worst administered and adjudicated sport?
gaskin
Hall of Famer
- Aug 19, 2009
- 33,845
- 38,039
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- LFC, Glory, Wests, Seahawks, UGA
Even though they can't, the club should put in a protest or at least a please explain.
That tackle is worse than the Nyhuis one.
That tackle is worse than the Nyhuis one.
You'd have to think that goes on in spades behind the scenes.
Interesting that it's a Freo player on the receiving end most of the time.
Similar threads
