MRP Trouble For Cyril?

[Baz_hawk]

Talking to hawthorn supporters about MRP bias is like talking to yanks about gun control

Rather pointless ...they just won't ever get it

I'd argue that you were the yank in this example.

You dismissed any response before it even came up, much like what they do when a mass shooting occurs.

 

[Hawkforce]

Just gotta love how bitter Cats fans are #headfkdbyhawthorn

 

[dave123]

I'd argue that you were the yank in this example.

You dismissed any response before it even came up, much like what they do when a mass shooting occurs.

Star treatment happens in the afl

Fyfe Cyril Selwood hodge come to mind as protected species


Pav was similar too

Judd got away with stuff at west coast and Carlton because he was Chris Judd

They get star treatment by the MRP

 

[Vindicater]

Star treatment happens in the afl

Fyfe Cyril Selwood hodge come to mind as protected species


Pav was similar too

Judd got away with stuff at west coast and Carlton because he was Chris Judd

They get star treatment by the MRP

This 100%.

If it had been Taylor Duryea who did what Cyril did he wold have been booked.

Same with Boomer Harvey earlier this week on Sam Mitchell. If that had been McMillan instead who did that there would have been weeks.

 

[HairyO]

5 weeks despite not hurting anyone is some treatment.

Kept him fresh so he was strong in the finals.

Thanks MRP !!

 

[dave123]

This 100%.

If it had been Taylor Duryea who did what Cyril did he wold have been booked.

Same with Boomer Harvey earlier this week on Sam Mitchell. If that had been McMillan instead who did that there would have been weeks.

Yup ...the afl knows that star players equals bums on seats and tv viewers

Having star players out could cost $50,000 .....the AFL is a business

 

[Baz_hawk]

Star treatment happens in the afl

Fyfe Cyril Selwood hodge come to mind as protected species


Pav was similar too

Judd got away with stuff at west coast and Carlton because he was Chris Judd

They get star treatment by the MRP

No doubt stars get looked after but in this case Rioli in my opinion shouldn't have been booked at all. Was a good fair hit and the AFL changed their wording after backlash about body contact being the reason for his fine.

No doubt people will call me biased but I wouldn't expect any player to get done for a fair hit. Ziebell hit Mitchell in an almost identical spot with his forearm and was cleared earlier this year.

 

[dave123]

No doubt stars get looked after but in this case Rioli in my opinion shouldn't have been booked at all. Was a good fair hit and the AFL changed their wording after backlash about body contact being the reason for his fine.

No doubt people will call me biased but I wouldn't expect any player to get done for a fair hit. Ziebell hit Mitchell in an almost identical spot with his forearm and was cleared earlier this year.

Fair enough

I'm staggered Tunbridge gets 2 for a perfect tackle ....

I'm lost on the MRP ....err chook raffle

 

[Gralin]

Star treatment happens in the afl

Fyfe Cyril Selwood hodge come to mind as protected species


Pav was similar too

Judd got away with stuff at west coast and Carlton because he was Chris Judd

They get star treatment by the MRP

Star treatment eh, guess it's cause Hawks have so many stars then.
So really it's not a Hawks issue you are complaining about.