List Mgmt. MSD 2025 Prospects and Discussion Thread.

[backtothedraft]

With no understanding of the talent available, I'm not convinced we need a project tall. Find me a suburban small forward that's a part time footballer, full time plumber who loves kicking goals and hurting people.

 

[Passmore]

May in means we've got no confidence in teakle or maley as future prospects.
Doesnt sit well with me.
We all know Corr is shit, just take a key back haha

There is no future with Treakle. He's pure VFL level depth.

Maley is a swing for the fences rookie pick with one attribute and nothing else.

 

[Passmore]

With no understanding of the talent available, I'm not convinced we need a project tall. Find me a suburban small forward that's a part time footballer, full time plumber who loves kicking goals and hurting people.

And tatts.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

May in means we've got no confidence in teakle or maley as future prospects.
Doesnt sit well with me.
We all know Corr is shit, just take a key back haha

May seems like guesswork to me, can't see him on our list tomorrow night.

 

[DesertRoo]

Just asking the question.
I haven’t seen much of May (or any other MSD prospect to be fair)
you’re right though, he’s probably already shown more drive than Edward’s based on heading to subi.
Can’t go wrong with derm as a mentor as well

I think he deserves a clean slate, we can’t have hold ups from other kids.

And I for one hope to see Dermie in a North jumper cheering us on in the commentary box.

 

[DesertRoo]

May in means we've got no confidence in teakle or maley as future prospects.
Doesnt sit well with me.
We all know Corr is shit, just take a key back haha

Have a look down the list and you’ll see the issue, the ready made key position players we recruited to be able to compete are now playing in the vfl, they need to be turned over for potential players.

The list is still ****ed from negligence of yesteryear.

 

[Clarke is King]

Haven't watched a second of any of these prospects but I'll be pissed off if we don't get Banch cause my man Souup said he was a bit of alright.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Hope we take Michael Sellwood personally, his contested marking for a HBF is extremely impressive.

If he’s there at our latter pick I’d happily take him

 

[My Left Foote]

Tom Morris just told Garry & Tim he expects Archer May to go pick #2 to North

What Tom Morris expects to happen and what will actually happen are two very different things.

 

[Passmore]

What Tom Morris expects to happen and what will actually happen are two very different things.

I'd give Tom a chance that he's correct. If it were Sam McClure.....

 

[shinboner magic]

Time to bring in a guy who has shown what he can do at the lower levels and can play a right away
Banch and a Selwood pairing sounds good

 

[giantroo]

 

[giantroo]

 

[giantroo]

[HEADING=3]2025 AFL Mid-Season Rookie Draft nominees [/HEADING]
Tahj Abberley - Brisbane Lions (VFL)
Oscar Adams - Glenelg (SANFL)
Zach Adams - Central District
Coen Ainsworth - Murray Bushrangers (Coates Talent League)
Alex Alessio - Calder Cannons (Coates Talent League)
Christian Algeri - Collingwood (VFL)
Rod Ali - Eastern Ranges (Coates Talent League)
Matthew Allison - Coburg (VFL)
Harry Arnold - Brisbane Lions (VFL)
Jaxon Artemis - South Fremantle (WAFL)
Jake Arundell - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Riley Baldi - Casey Demons (VFL)
Jack Baldwin - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Isaac Baldwin - GWS Giants Academy (Coates Talent League)
Zac Banch - Werribee (VFL)
Max Beattie - Eagles (SANFL)
Dominic Bedendo - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Nelson Beikoff Smart - Gold Coast SUNS (Coates Talent League)
[PLAYERCARD]James Bell[/PLAYERCARD] - Glenelg (SANFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Tom Bell[/PLAYERCARD] South Fremantle (WAFL)
Joshua Bennetts - Collingwood (VFL)
Kane Bevan Western Australia (WAFL)
Trent Bianco - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Lachlan Blakiston - East Fremantle (WAFL)
Thomas Blamires - Frankston (VFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Riley Bonner[/PLAYERCARD] - Casey Demons (VFL)
Ryan Borlace - South Adelaide
Evan Bradley - North Adelaide
Dom Brew - Werribee (VFL)
Jackson Broadbent - Subiaco (WAFL)
Hugo Bromell - Coburg (VFL)
Joshua Browne - Collingwood (VFL)
Lachlan Bryce - Casey Demons (VFL)
Samuel Buck - Sandringham Dragons (Coates Talent League)
Charlie Burke - Subiaco (WAFL)
Floyd Burmeister - Greater Western Victoria Rebels (Coates Talent League)
Jack Bytel - Coburg (VFL)
Noah Cachard - Perth (WAFL)
Archie Caldow - Peel Thunder (WAFL)
Jonah Campigli - Sandringham (VFL)
William Cassidy East - Perth (WAFL)
Will Chandler - Glenelg (SANFL)
Jack Cheep - Sandringham (VFL)
Aaron Clarke - Perth (WAFL)
Jack Cleaver - East Fremantle (WAFL)
Shane Clough - Essendon (VFL)
Zane Cochrane - Collingwood (VFL)
Adrian Cole - Dandenong Stingrays (Coates Talent League)
Nathan Colenso - Williamstown (VFL)
Riley Collier-Dawkins - Williamstown (VFL)
Sam Conway - Werribee (VFL)
Lukas Cooke - Eagles (SANFL)
Billy Cootee - Norwood (SANFL)
Marlin Corbett - Subiaco (WAFL)
Cooper Craig-Peters - Footscray Bulldogs (VFL)
Jesse Craven - Casey Demons (VFL)
Paddy Cross - Casey Demons (VFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Brayden Crossley[/PLAYERCARD] - Southport (VFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Sam Darley[/PLAYERCARD] - Melton South Football Netball Club
Jayden Davey - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Kye Declase - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Clancy Dennis - Claremont (WAFL)
Oliver Depaoli-Kubank - Tasmania (Coates Talent League)
Riley Disisto - Claremont (WAFL)
Kade Dittmar - Central District
Jordan Doherty - Frankston (VFL)
Max Donohue - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Boston Dowling - Collingwood (VFL)
Connor Downie - North Melbourne (VFL)
Blake Drury - Adelaide Football Club
Elliot Dunkin - South Adelaide
Oliver Eastland - Claremont (WAFL)
Jared Eckersley - Essendon (VFL)
Ben Edwards - Sydney Swans (VFL)
Thomas Edwards-Baldwin Western Australia (WAFL)
Corey Ellison - Frankston (VFL)
Mutaz Elnour - Richmond (VFL)
Caleb Ernst - Coburg (VFL)
Tom Evans - Bendigo Pioneers (Coates Talent League)
Connor Evans - Bendigo Pioneers (Coates Talent League)
Ryan Eyers - Werribee (VFL)
Liam Farrar Northern Knights (Coates Talent League)
Oskar Faulkhead - North Adelaide
Jake Fazldeen Brisbane Lions (Coates Talent League)
Luke Fellows - North Adelaide
Ashton Ferreira South Fremantle (WAFL)
Kristian Ferronato - Carlton (VFL)
Brodie Findlay - North Adelaide
Ty Fitzgerald - Gold Coast SUNS (Coates Talent League)
Joel Fitzgerald - Williamstown (VFL)
Zachary Fleiner - Perth (WAFL)
Matthew Foley - Essendon (VFL)
Zac Foot - Southport (VFL)
Nicholas Francis Gold Coast Suns (VFL)
Samuel Frost - West Adelaide (SANFL)
Joe Furphy - Coburg (VFL)
Aiden Fyfe Gold Coast Suns (VFL)
Julian Galbally - Sandringham Dragons (Coates Talent League)
[PLAYERCARD]Joel Garner[/PLAYERCARD] - Richmond (VFL)
Hudson Garoni - Werribee (VFL)
Jake Gasper - Central District
Flynn Gentile - Coburg (VFL)
Kobe George Geelong Falcons
Ryan Gilder - Brisbane Lions (VFL)
Jordyn Gillard - Coburg (VFL)
Glen Gillbee - Bendigo Pioneers (Coates Talent League)
Lachlan Gollant - Williamstown (VFL)
Maison Goodman - Northern Bullants (VFL)
Thomas Graham - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Baron Grant Endeavour Hills Football Club
Harry Grant - Central District
Finlay Gray - Gold Coast SUNS (Coates Talent League)
Olly Green - Casey Demons (VFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Joshua Green[/PLAYERCARD] - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Wyatt Greenaway Brisbane Lions (Coates Talent League)
George Grey - Frankston (VFL)
Corey Grocock - South Adelaide
Jhett Haeata - Richmond (VFL)
Jed Hagan - East Fremantle (WAFL)
Hugo Hall-Kahan - Williamstown (VFL)
Josh Hamilton - Northern Bullants (VFL)
Riley Hamilton GWS Giants Academy (Coates Talent League)
Cooper Hamilton - Carlton (VFL)
Mitchell Hardie - Casey Demons (VFL)
Zac Harding Murray Bushrangers (Coates Talent League)
Matthew Harms - GWS Giants (VFL)
Joe Harrison Sydney Swans (Coates Talent League)
Otis Harvey Swan Districts (WAFL)
Jett Hasting - Eagles (SANFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Jackson Hately[/PLAYERCARD] - Essendon (VFL)
Henry Hayes - Dandenong Stingrays (Coates Talent League)
Taiquin Hayes - Southport (VFL)
Jack Hayes - Eagles (SANFL)
Cooper Herbert - Calder Cannons (Coates Talent League)
Kade Herbert - Eagles (SANFL)
Marcus Herbert - Geelong Cats (VFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Jacob Heron[/PLAYERCARD] - Southport (VFL)
Dyson Hilder - North Adelaide
Coby Hilton GWS Giants Academy (Coates Talent League)
Joseph Hinder Western Australia (WAFL)
Oscar Hine-Baston - Perth (WAFL)
Darby Hipwell - Frankston (VFL)
Tom Hird - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Will Hoare - Essendon (VFL)
Damon Hollow - Williamstown (VFL)
Alex Holt Sturt
Ben Hopkins - North Melbourne (VFL)
Noah Howes - South Adelaide
Liam Hude - Collingwood (VFL)
Ethan Hunt - Footscray Bulldogs (VFL)
Lucas Impey - Williamstown (VFL)
Solomon James South Fremantle (WAFL)
Matt Johnson - Frankston (VFL)
Brock Johnston-Smith South Cairns Cutters
John Jorgensen - Northern Bullants (VFL)
Deacon Kalpakis - Coburg (VFL)
Luke Kelly Swan Districts (WAFL)
Judd Kelman - Subiaco (WAFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Ben Kennedy[/PLAYERCARD] Murray Bushrangers (Coates Talent League)
Doug Kerr - Oakleigh Chargers (Coates Talent League)
Mitchell Kirkwood-Scott - Casey Demons (VFL)
Nathan Kreuger - Geelong Cats (VFL)
Sebit Kuek East - Perth (WAFL)
Ajang Kuol Mun - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Sean Lai - Richmond (VFL)
Campbell Lake - Southport (VFL)
Charlie Lazzaro - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Riley Leedham - Essendon (VFL)
Caleb Lewis - Casey Demons (VFL)
Mani Liddy - Central District
Matthew Ling - Norwood (SANFL)
Mitchell Lloyd - Geelong Cats (VFL)
Zaydyn Lockwood - Bendigo Pioneers (Coates Talent League)
Taj Logan - Carlton (VFL)
Jordan Lukac - Eagles (SANFL)
Seth MacDonald - Eastern Ranges (Coates Talent League)
Cooper Macdonald - Sydney Swans (VFL)
Ewan Mackinlay - North Adelaide
[PLAYERCARD]Darcy Macpherson[/PLAYERCARD] - North Melbourne (VFL)
Zavier Maher - North Adelaide
Harry Mahoney - Collingwood (VFL)
Max Mahoney - Collingwood (VFL)
Jack Manly - Brisbane Lions (VFL)
Archi Manton - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Riley Mason - Collingwood (VFL)
Jayden Matz - Central District
Archer May - Subiaco (WAFL)
Ayden McCarroll - Western Jets (Coates Talent League)
Tom McCarthy - Richmond (VFL)
Tadhg McCarthy - Collingwood (VFL)
Curtis McCarthy - Brisbane Lions (VFL)
Charles McCartin - Geelong Cats (VFL)
Fergus McFadyen - Brisbane Lions (VFL)
Billy McGee Galimberti - GWS Giants (VFL)
Zac McGown - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Solomon McKay - Essendon (VFL)
Brodie McLaughlin - Williamstown (VFL)
Jez McLennan Port Adelaide (SANFL)
Liam McMahon - Carlton (VFL)
Liam McMahon - Carlton (VFL)
Zai Millane - Gold Coast SUNS (Coates Talent League)
Alex Mirkov - Old Ivanhoe Grammarians
Diesel Moloney - Footscray Bulldogs (VFL)
Rhett Montgomerie - Central District
Harper Montgomery - GWS Giants (VFL)
Louie Montgomery - GWS Giants (VFL)
Milan Murdock - East Fremantle (WAFL)
Cooper Murley - Norwood (SANFL)
Joshua Murphy - Collingwood (VFL)
Tobyn Murray - Geelong Cats (VFL)
Amin Naim - Northern Bullants (VFL)
Caleb Nancarrow - Gold Coast SUNS (Coates Talent League)
Jacob Newton - Norwood (SANFL)
Olivier Northam - South Adelaide
Cam Nyko - Essendon (VFL)
Finbar O'Dwyer - Williamstown (VFL)
Blayne O'Loughlin - North Adelaide
Xavier O'Neill - Essendon (VFL)
Hewago Oea - Southport (VFL)
Charlton Offermans - Brisbane Lions (VFL)
Charlie Orchard - Dandenong Stingrays (Coates Talent League)
Daniel Orgill - Footscray Bulldogs (VFL)
Cameron Owen - Footscray Bulldogs (VFL)
Gus Papal - Calder Cannons (Coates Talent League)
[PLAYERCARD]Brandan Parfitt[/PLAYERCARD] - Perth (WAFL)
Luke Parks - Williamstown (VFL)
Patrick Parnell - Glenelg (SANFL)
Lochlan Paton - Perth (WAFL)
Will Patton - West Adelaide (SANFL)
Cohen Paul - Euroa Football Netball Club Inc.
Jye Peacock - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Luka Pecer - Dandenong Stingrays (Coates Talent League)
Elwood Peckett - Sandringham (VFL)
Flynn Penry - Greater Western Victoria Rebels (Coates Talent League)
Jovan Petric - Williamstown (VFL)
Nathan Philactides - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Baxter Philip - Perth (WAFL)
Ethan Phillips - Carlton (VFL)
Mitchell Podhajski - Coburg (VFL)
Oliver Poole - Carlton (VFL)
Dayne Posthuma - Central District
Liam Purcell - Sandringham (VFL)
Nicholas Quigg - Essendon (VFL)
Sebastian Quirk - Frankston (VFL)
Harrison Ramm - Glenelg (SANFL)
Heath Ramshaw - Carlton (VFL)
Wil Rantall - Greater Western Victoria Rebels (Coates Talent League)
Massimo Raso - Richmond (VFL)
Lucas Ravenhill - Claremont (WAFL)
Billy Richardson - Sandringham (VFL)
Max Rider - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Jack Riding - Werribee (VFL)
Jez Rigoni - Oakleigh Chargers (Coates Talent League)
Flynn Riley - Carlton (VFL)
Max Roney - Tasmania (Coates Talent League)
Fraser Rosman - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Charlie Rozenes - Sandringham Dragons (Coates Talent League)
Tom Ryan - Sydney Swans (Coates Talent League)
Mitchell Ryan - Sandringham (VFL)
Kobe Ryan - West Adelaide (SANFL)
Beau Ryan - Central District
Jack Saunders - Norwood (SANFL)
Galen Savigni - Subiaco (WAFL)
Taj Schofield - Subiaco (WAFL)
Mitchell Schofield East - Perth (WAFL)
Kaden Schreiber - Northern Bullants (VFL)
Elijah Scoble - Perth (WAFL)
Angus Scoble - Bendigo Pioneers (Coates Talent League)
Tyler Sellers - Essendon (VFL)
Michael Sellwood - Peel Thunder (WAFL)
Liam Serong - Coburg (VFL)
Travis Shearer - Subiaco (WAFL)
Marc Sheather - GWS Giants (VFL)
Josh Shepherd - Oakleigh Chargers (Coates Talent League)
Kobe Shipp - Casey Demons (VFL)
Blake Simondson - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Luca Slade - Sturt
Oskar Smartt - Essendon (VFL)
Jake Smith - Werribee (VFL)
Harshul Sodhi - Kambalda Football Club (Goldfields Football League)
Phoenix Spicer - Footscray Bulldogs (VFL)
Riley Sprigg - Western Australia (WAFL)
Ethan Stanley - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Roan Steele - Western Australia (WAFL)
Andreas Stefanakis - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Dakota Sterzl - South Adelaide
Tom Stevens - North Adelaide
Luke Strnadica - East Fremantle (WAFL)
Gabriel Stumpf - Northern Knights (Coates Talent League)
Nathaniel Sulzberger - Tasmania (Coates Talent League)
Frank Szekely - North Adelaide
Mahmoud Taha - Essendon (VFL)
Will Tasker - North Adelaide
Benjamin Thomas - Brisbane Lions (VFL)
Beau Thomas - Central District
Nick Thompson - Bendigo Pioneers (Coates Talent League)
James Tidemann - Sydney Swans (VFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Adam Tomlinson[/PLAYERCARD] - North Melbourne (VFL)
Sam Toner - Richmond (VFL)
Donovan Toohey - Coburg (VFL)
Lucas Tovey - Oakleigh Chargers (Coates Talent League)
Cooper Trembath - North Melbourne (VFL)
Joel Trudgeon - Coburg (VFL)
Clay Tucker - South Belgrave (Eastern Football Netball League)
Noah Tullio - Werribee (VFL)
Izaak Twelftree Conor - Norwood (SANFL)
Austin van der Struyf - Claremont (WAFL)
James Van Es - Port Melbourne (VFL)
Samuel van Rooyen - Claremont (WAFL)
Alex van Wyk - North Adelaide
Cooper Vickery - Carlton (VFL)
Jackson Voss - Frankston (VFL)
Lachlan Voss - Sandringham (VFL)
Tommy Vrkic - Northern Knights (Coates Talent League)
Zac Walker - Gippsland Power (Coates Talent League)
Samuel Waltham - Sturt
Oliver Warburton - Carlton (VFL)
Lane Ward - Box Hill Hawks (VFL)
Jack Watkins - Port Adelaide (SANFL)
Blake Watson - Sandringham (VFL)
Kyle Weightman - Coburg (VFL)
Tom Wheaton - South Adelaide
Hugh White - Northern Knights (Coates Talent League)
Cooper Whyte - Werribee (VFL)
Nick Williams - Southport (VFL)
Ethan Williams - Sandringham (VFL)
Zane Williams - Eagles (SANFL)
[PLAYERCARD]Tom Williamson[/PLAYERCARD] - Ararat Football Netball Club
Conor Willis - Collingwood (VFL)
Riley Wills - Perth (WAFL)
Lachlan Wilson - Richmond (VFL)
Kai Windsor - Casey Demons (VFL)
Hayden Windsor - Subiaco (WAFL)
Oliver Withers - GWS Giants Academy (Coates Talent League)
Mohammad Ali Yassine - Richmond (VFL)
Flynn Young - Werribee (VFL)
Noah Yze - Casey Demons (VFL)
Mitchell Zadow - East Fremantle (WAFL)

 

[Event Horizon]

With no understanding of the talent available, I'm not convinced we need a project tall. Find me a suburban small forward that's a part time footballer, full time plumber who loves kicking goals and hurting people.

You think our forward line of 27 year old one dimensional Larkey, Darling who turns 33 next month and Maley/Teakle combo is a great mix do you?

I can't tell you what likelihood May is on making it, but if he is a quality prospect then this is very much a position of need for us

 

[Passmore]

It's a bit of a conundrum.

We've established we'd be stupid not to take 2 players. Yet we've also established that, given our history, they'll both be shit.

 

[Chadwiko]

You think our forward line of 27 year old one dimensional Larkey, Darling who turns 33 next month and Maley/Teakle combo is a great mix do you?

This post once again made me mad that we didn't draft Dan Curtin or Nate Caddy.

 

[My Left Foote]

I'd give Tom a chance that he's correct. If it were Sam McClure.....

Normally I'd agree with you, more often than not Tom gets good mail, however not on this occasion…

 

[Passmore]

Normally I'd agree with you, more often than not Tom gets good mail, however not on this occasion…

Bloody Tom.

What is the good oil?

 

[Event Horizon]

This post once again made me mad that we didn't draft Dan Curtin or Nate Caddy.

You're not wrong. But to be fair neither of them is a proven 50 goal forward at this stage. But I wouldn't mind one of them on our list that's for sure.

But we are where we are, and we certainly did try to fill that spot with Jack Whitlock last year but nobody wanted to trade with is for the second rounder we were after.

And if Archer May is considered a strong chance to develop into a quality forward we absolutely need to take the punt on him. Given he's now 2 years out of the U18 system is a positive as well, as it should be easier to tell if he is going to make it, as well as being closer to being AFL ready

 

[The Nostradamus]

Normally I'd agree with you, more often than not Tom gets good mail, however not on this occasion…

what are you hearing?

 

[7577969923]

Time to bring in a guy who has shown what he can do at the lower levels and can play a right away
Banch and a Selwood pairing sounds good

I don't get the urgency to bring in a guy who can play straight away in the MSD. We aren't making the finals this year.

Bring in the best available talent that fills a need for us, even if that is with another 12 to 18 months of development. Archer May, if he's good enough, ticks that box.

I still don't understand the Payne selection from last year at all. Doesn't fill any obvious need for us, nor was he ready to go, or a particularly outstanding talent.

 

[Event Horizon]

It's a bit of a conundrum.

We've established we'd be stupid not to take 2 players. Yet we've also established that, given our history, they'll both be shit.

There is a Russian saying that translates to "once in a hundred years even a stick can shoot like a shotgun"

 

[Event Horizon]

I don't get the urgency to bring in a guy who can play straight away in the MSD. We aren't making the finals this year.

Bring in the best available talent that fills a need for us, even if that is with another 12 to 18 months of development. Archer May, if he's good enough, ticks that box.

I still don't understand the Payne selection from last year at all. Doesn't fill any obvious need for us, nor was he ready to go, or a particularly outstanding talent.

Agree with your first point. But in regards to Payne, we do have a need for a pressure small forward, which Payne was becoming from all reports. But for whatever reason, he hasn't looked like it

 

[7577969923]

Agree with your first point. But in regards to Payne, we do have a need for a pressure small forward, which Payne was becoming from all reports. But for whatever reason, he hasn't looked like it

Maley seems okay in the pressure small forward role!