Remove this Banner Ad

Werewolf Multi-Wolf

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

DapperJong said:
Can someone bullet point the reasoning by why morgs is suss? Or is it just because it's EJW's opinion?

Because I think EJW, apart from a good seer result, is not the best opinion.
Click to expand...
Why is that DJ?? What is wrong with my opinion.

I am happy to move if someone has got something.
 
Elton Johns Wig said:
When you put it like this, it sounds feasible.

1. I came out because I believe I was a dead man walking due to TFW terminology in a post, thought he had 'made' me
2. see 1
3. If you are not trying to work out the WC by deduction etc, you're not doing it right. Sorry for trying to be thorough
Click to expand...
Don't apologise foe thoroughness. What do you think I'm doing?
 
dogs105 said:
Happy to vote for akkaps .

At worst we get rid of someone "not following the thread ".

Thanks SM
Click to expand...

i remember when i went down that same line of voting for harload yesterday, resulted in me being super suss according to many and forcing my hand..

i agree with your reasoning, if people arent going to follow the thread and help us out, then remove them.

also saves us potentially forcing another good role player from having to reveal themselves or miss lynching them.

Elton Johns Wig can you give a run down on why your reckon morgan is the go?
 
Elton Johns Wig said:
Why is that DJ?? What is wrong with my opinion.

I am happy to move if someone has got something.
Click to expand...

Your exchange with Joe, then you seered him. So it just tells me your spidey sense may be off. And i think it's due to being wary of those who are putting heat on you and getting nervous rather than looking at evidence. I know you've got your spreadsheets, I would look back at day 1 votes if I were you.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Elton Johns Wig said:
When you put it like this, it sounds feasible.

1. I came out because I believe I was a dead man walking due to TFW terminology in a post, thought he had 'made' me
2. see 1
3. If you are not trying to work out the WC by deduction etc, you're not doing it right. Sorry for trying to be thorough
Click to expand...
I have no idea why filthy would let on that he's made you?
What's in it for them?
Surely they just kill you the following night?
 
Last edited:
Michaels said:
not by choice, but yes.

as i said to SM in my PM, everytime i get a good role someone tries to see something that isnt there against me and basically forces my hand in the early days. every single time..
Click to expand...
I think you may just have to for go weekends in the future.
 
Michaels said:
i remember when i went down that same line of voting for harload yesterday, resulted in me being super suss according to many and forcing my hand..

i agree with your reasoning, if people arent going to follow the thread and help us out, then remove them.

also saves us potentially forcing another good role player from having to reveal themselves or miss lynching them.

Elton Johns Wig can you give a run down on why your reckon morgan is the go?
Click to expand...

DapperJong said:
Your exchange with Joe, then you seered him. So it just tells me your spidey sense may be off. And i think it's due to being wary of those who are putting heat on you and getting nervous rather than looking at evidence. I know you've got your spreadsheets, I would look back at day 1 votes if I were you.
Click to expand...

Thanks for the feedback.

I am not nervous, thats one thing. I am out in the open, and have one more night at it, so nothing to be nervous about.
The Joe thing shits me. I was suss on Michaels too. What is it with docs being pegged as suss. I do that all the time, I reckon a lot do.

If I was to change, I think Mooch is ripe.

I am on my tablet during the day for work, so haven't go ability to do much, but with Morgs it was just the way she said things. 'You're not very good at this are you' after being voted for, hitting someone else with a tier rating, stuff like that. As I stated, its nothing solid. And as stated, if someone has something with a bit more meat on the bone, all for it
 
roo2macca said:
If EJW was evil, it would be a dick move to out filthy and get rid of him. Sure, it's happened before but I hope it wouldn't be the case.
Click to expand...
Could be same faction.
And anyway, his group would have something to gain - it wouldn't be a petulant killing
 
Elton Johns Wig said:
Thanks for the feedback.

I am not nervous, thats one thing. I am out in the open, and have one more night at it, so nothing to be nervous about.
The Joe thing shits me. I was suss on Michaels too. What is it with docs being pegged as suss. I do that all the time, I reckon a lot do.

If I was to change, I think Mooch is ripe.

I am on my tablet during the day for work, so haven't go ability to do much, but with Morgs it was just the way she said things. 'You're not very good at this are you' after being voted for, hitting someone else with a tier rating, stuff like that. As I stated, its nothing solid. And as stated, if someone has something with a bit more meat on the bone, all for it
Click to expand...
Isn't mooch a flog?
 
dogs105 said:
Why not lynch him?

Warning: Tin Foil Hat required for further reading -

This is crazy, but EJW may not be confirmed.
(1) he came out early to out a minor evil - not an alpha. Why expose the seer for a thug?

(2) TFW rolled over early, and his post reinforced EJW's seer status.

(3) This ploy could only work in a game with wildcards, and EJW showed he was counting the number of vig kills with an earlier post. Two vig kills would have stuffed it up completely.


Anyway, extremely unlikely but keep it at the back of your minds.

Edit: and the classic seering of a dead person, who had hinted at being doctor. (Had actually been "laying it down" for us to "pick up"). Interesting seer target?

*removes hat*
Click to expand...

Good point.

Akkaps

SM
 

Remove this Banner Ad

From first night actions:

- back and forth between TAP and red mist, TAP poking for a response, RM actually ended up being more helpful. I questioned TAP's unusual active posts and was met by a playful/jokey response. Has since been quiet.
-Sante votes BD for being defensive, BD responds strangely, disappears. I think has learned from last game that hiding works. And btw, he was defensive. SUSS
- Melter and Mooch - idiots. NOT SUSS
- BRAB has been quiet, but has spoken sense. NOT SUSS
- Spookism absolutely paper thin comments wanting to be seen but not really. SUSS
- MOrgs, fairly normal

OTHER NOTES

- EJW - let's just keep in mind that with a WC in play, he could very well be a member of the opposite evil faction TFW was in. At the moment it doesn't seem like it, but you have to question the role reveal with not much heat. If he had not claimed, he'd be number 1 on my suss list.
- roo2macca and golumless are blending in quite nicely.


BUT ALL OF THIS IS WITH A GRAIN OF SALT.

Some poor games by alleged good at this stage, and evil are in a good position to take advantage. My list could be COMPLETELY STUFFED.
 
roo2macca said:
If EJW was evil, it would be a dick move to out filthy and get rid of him. Sure, it's happened before but I hope it wouldn't be the case.
Click to expand...

It's pretty fair play this early.
 
dogs105 said:
Happy to vote for akkaps .

At worst we get rid of someone "not following the thread ".

Thanks SM
Click to expand...
Isn't that the same reasoning we had for Haro and it got shot down?
Elton Johns Wig said:
Thanks for the feedback.

I am not nervous, thats one thing. I am out in the open, and have one more night at it, so nothing to be nervous about.
The Joe thing shits me. I was suss on Michaels too. What is it with docs being pegged as suss. I do that all the time, I reckon a lot do.

If I was to change, I think Mooch is ripe.

I am on my tablet during the day for work, so haven't go ability to do much, but with Morgs it was just the way she said things. 'You're not very good at this are you' after being voted for, hitting someone else with a tier rating, stuff like that. As I stated, its nothing solid. And as stated, if someone has something with a bit more meat on the bone, all for it
Click to expand...
Wait you would take out a confirmed good role? WTF?

MA posted a few times with things like "you're making a mistake" when prodded and it smacks a little of inexperienced player with a role on the defensive.
 
Elton Johns Wig said:
I am not nervous, thats one thing. I am out in the open, and have one more night at it, so nothing to be nervous about.
Click to expand...

Probably not now, but my god you were a shambles earlier before your claim came out.
 
dogs105 said:
Akkaps came on when he was 'tagged ', but he wasn't. He was watching the thread but not posting.
Click to expand...

burningdwarf said:
That's a good get.

One of his few posts yesterday was asking if we knew what role set we were using, when that had been discussed a page or 2 earlier.

Seems like he might be acting more checked out of the game than he really is.
Click to expand...
It's pretty standard of akkaps to not know what's happening in the thread but dogs makes a good point here. The only way he would've known Melter mentioned him was that if he was following the thread. That said, who knows with him?
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Mooch said:
Isn't that the same reasoning we had for Haro and it got shot down?

Wait you would take out a confirmed good role? WTF?

MA posted a few times with things like "you're making a mistake" when prodded and it smacks a little of inexperienced player with a role on the defensive.
Click to expand...
sorry, on tablet, have no info till 6, yes, good.

On SM-G900I using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
RodneyDangerfield said:
Didn't you defend him for no being on line over the weekend? Or maybe I misread it.
Click to expand...
That post I responded to isn't what it appears. Click on that HaroLad tag.

It was Melter simply being a reptile.
 
Nakia said:
That post I responded to isn't what it appears. Click on that HaroLad tag.

It was Melter simply being a reptile.
Click to expand...
Which I notice haro hasn't replied to at all.

So either he just doesn't gaf or he is a villager.

Akkaps on the other hand.

Fwiw I think we're barking up the wrong tree with morganashlee too.

But what would I know? I'm just a flog.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Werewolf Multi-Wolf

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top