Murphy 100% playing

[blue gunslinger]

One would have thought there is something more to see......an apology perhaps for getting that one so wrong.....everyone makes mistakes, its how we react next that is our measure and correct me if I am wrong (and I will surely apologize) but I have not seen an apology from the Monkey, nor any kind of post for that matter, he has gone to ground....draw your own conclusions on that.

has been seen on the bay

 

[Dennis]

One would have thought there is something more to see......an apology perhaps for getting that one so wrong.....everyone makes mistakes, its how we react next that is our measure and correct me if I am wrong (and I will surely apologize) but I have not seen an apology from the Monkey, nor any kind of post for that matter, he has gone to ground....draw your own conclusions on that.

want to bite...must resist

 

[PooMonkey]

One would have thought there is something more to see......an apology perhaps for getting that one so wrong.....everyone makes mistakes, its how we react next that is our measure and correct me if I am wrong (and I will surely apologize) but I have not seen an apology from the Monkey, nor any kind of post for that matter, he has gone to ground....draw your own conclusions on that.

HAVE NOT GONE TO GROUND, WILL NOT APPOLOGISE.

I stand by 100% what i heard and posted, and will not back away from it.

As stated in another thread, I am over the moon Murphy looks ok and played part of a game. I will be even happier if he runs out round 1.

I had nothiong to gain over posting that, all i did was pass on what i heard. If you want to keep bringing it up, by all means do so.

Do I give a toss.......not really!

 

[40yearBLUE]

want to bite...must resist

Since posting my above post I have read the Rumor thread started by ODN and see that PM has been on today and posted a defiant defense, which I guess is fair enough. So I apologize for inferring cowardice or any other inference.

He was defiant but under the circumstances I would have been a bit more contrite, you can stall attest that you thought what you heard was genuine and accurate (not going to go into the ethics of posting a doctors eavesdrop) but apologise for the subsequent accuracy and note that you may have been mistaken given that all the evidence...ALL the evidence....points that way......

.....and no-one here is in any doubt about how tenaciously I cling to an argument, but really this one was a stinker from the get go.

Like I have said many times here (and it was said to me early in my time here from another poster, cant remember who or why) you make your own rep here, and I guess we all know what to expect from PM from now on.

 

[Dennis]

So I apologize for inferring cowardice or any other inference.

This is sweet

and I guess we all know what to expect from PM from now on.

...so the above "other inferences" are outside your apology? I missed the fineprint

 

[40yearBLUE]

This is sweet



...so the above "other inferences" are outside your apology? I missed the fineprint

What are you on about? My apology is wider than just the single inference of cowardice, I cant possibly know what everyone will infer so I cover them all......

And yes, I know that the next time I see a PM post my bullshit radar might start to go into overdrive......but hey that's just me, I am quite judgmental and I judge others by the value of their previous posts, but hey, that's just me

Looks like you too are forging a rep for yourself

 

[Malifice]

HAVE NOT GONE TO GROUND, WILL NOT APPOLOGISE.



I stand by 100% what i heard and posted, and will not back away from it.



As stated in another thread, I am over the moon Murphy looks ok and played part of a game. I will be even happier if he runs out round 1.



I had nothiong to gain over posting that, all i did was pass on what i heard. If you want to keep bringing it up, by all means do so.



Do I give a toss.......not really!

I for one am happy Murph played 3 full quarters of an interstate practice match with crippling OP, and against his Physio's instructions.

A sure sign of his dedication to the club.

 

[Malifice]

I stand by 100% what i heard and posted, and will not back away from it.

You need new sources mate:

HBF...I have been posting for 2 weeks that Fev will be in Sydney and i have been rubished for it a number of times... Deal will be done tomorrow!

i agree, i have also been told this.

Sydney have offered Fev 2Mil over 4 years!

One of either Hampson or Jacobs will be traded, with Kruez and Warnock our no. 1 + 2

Joel McDonald was another name thrown about but Carlton prefered Rischatelli.

If he says no, it will be McDonald + Bradshaw.

Jacobs will also go to the swans

Goose for Fisher! done deal

Taz for Armfield and pick #27 probably

Fev for Hall and Syd first pick..doubtful but maybe

exactly what i said earlier.....

pick #27 + one of Fisher, Cloke, Bentick or Hartlett in exchange for Everitt.

The deal will be done.

It appears as if your trading sources are as reliable as your local physio mate.

 

[Dennis]

Ouch

PM...what was your source in the trade period??

..or just hunches that you thought you could post as fact?

 

[thylacine60]

...so the above "other inferences" are outside your apology? I missed the fineprint

I wouldn't........really....

 

[Salaryman]

time to get a new physiotherpaist

 

[40yearBLUE]

Ouch

PM...what was your source in the trade period??

..or just hunches that you thought you could post as fact?

From:

Knowing the Poo Monkey for many many years, I can vouch that:

a) he was where he said he was
b) It is a centre frequented by many AFL players (not just Carlton)
c) he heard what he heard


The guy has no history of lying, and has no reason to lie in this instance

Pretty simple really

to:

PM...what was your source in the trade period??

..or just hunches that you thought you could post as fact?

Didnt take much to make you jump off, a few days ago he was as reliable an old mate as one could have, now this....seen the light have you?

 

[Dennis]

From:

Knowing the Poo Monkey for many many years, I can vouch that:

a) he was where he said he was
b) It is a centre frequented by many AFL players (not just Carlton)
c) he heard what he heard


The guy has no history of lying, and has no reason to lie in this instance

Pretty simple really

to:

PM...what was your source in the trade period??

..or just hunches that you thought you could post as fact?

Didnt take much to make you jump off, a few days ago he was as reliable an old mate as one could have, now this....seen the light have you?

I still have faith in the young man

Let's see what he has to say

 

[ratten7]

Mate, seriously, **** off for a week or so.

That is hilarious, made me laugh

 

[mickelboy182]

It appears as if your trading sources are as reliable as your local physio mate.

Surely Mal has done enough here to get the **** monkey carded?
....Please? And one for Denise?

 

[blue gunslinger]

From:

Knowing the Poo Monkey for many many years, I can vouch that:

a) he was where he said he was
b) It is a centre frequented by many AFL players (not just Carlton)
c) he heard what he heard


The guy has no history of lying, and has no reason to lie in this instance

Pretty simple really

to:

PM...what was your source in the trade period??

..or just hunches that you thought you could post as fact?

Didnt take much to make you jump off, a few days ago he was as reliable an old mate as one could have, now this....seen the light have you?

Great - we have progressed from an entertaining thread to a colourfully embarassing one!
Onward and upward brothers

 

[PooMonkey]

Surely Mal has done enough here to get the **** monkey carded?
....Please? And one for Denise?

a card for what???

 

[Malifice]

a card for what???

Constantly making stuff up.

Whatever rocks your boat I guess.

I would strongly suggest you verify your 'facts' next time. Or the first part of your user name might descend from the heavens on you rather swiftly, guided by some of our omnipotent overseers.

Just a feeling I have.

But hey, what do I know?

 

[Dennis]

Constantly making stuff up.

Whatever rocks your boat I guess.

I would strongly suggest you verify your 'facts' next time. Or the first part of your user name might descend from the heavens on you rather swiftly, guided by some of our omnipotent overseers.

Just a feeling I have.

But hey, what do I know?

Are you 2 yrs old?