Murray FL 2019

[goodgolly24]

Yes. It’s taken into account in our legal system and only makes sense for a football tribunal to do the same.
Do you advocate for it being a 2-3 week set penalty in this case?
Ya know... because striking is striking

Hmmm, I don’t think you can compare the role and responsibility of our tribunal volunteers to those carrying out the roles and responsibilities of our legal system. Well I wouldn’t anyways... whilst similar in there application, one is responsible for running our society, the other is for running a sport...... but Cool, each to their own... my follow up question was going to be if that’s the case (in that you think injuries should play a role) is that across all instances/cases, or just some?

And to answer your question re advocating penalties, from my perspective, I don’t know what the acceptable/suitable punishment is, but what ever it is, I think it should be applicable to all alike cases, and not just some.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Appears to be a lot of noise suggesting action will be taken tonight to remove Rumba tonight ??

 

[ROOTA#6]

Appears to be a lot of noise suggesting action will be taken tonight to remove Rumba tonight ??

That is absolutely ridiculous if you ask me..it’s one incident

 

[goodgolly24]

Appears to be a lot of noise suggesting action will be taken tonight to remove Rumba tonight ??

TRIB my only question would be why?? Can you shed any light....

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

That is absolutely ridiculous if you ask me..it’s one incident

Don’t necessarily disagree although my understanding is there is a fair bit of non transparency going on and it doesn’t involve the rumba or the clubs.

TRIB my only question would be why?? Can you shed any light....

As explained above , from what I am hearing it centred around the Gf incident . If what I am hearing is correct I hope all comes out.

 

[wheresyourdidak]

Hmmm, I don’t think you can compare the role and responsibility of our tribunal volunteers to those carrying out the roles and responsibilities of our legal system. Well I wouldn’t anyways... whilst similar in there application, one is responsible for running our society, the other is for running a sport...... but Cool, each to their own... my follow up question was going to be if that’s the case (in that you think injuries should play a role) is that across all instances/cases, or just some?

And to answer your question re advocating penalties, from my perspective, I don’t know what the acceptable/suitable punishment is, but what ever it is, I think it should be applicable to all alike cases, and not just some.

In ALL cases the the outcome should be taken into consideration, along with intent.
Intent being the key.

Yes injuries are part and parcel of playing football and you take that risk..
But the risk should not be akin to walking King St alone at 3am

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Is it true that all bar 3 clubs( Rumba , Katandra and Tungamah ) attended the meeting and stated/outlined they will not be playing Rumba in 2020 ?

 

[Dons01]

Is it true that all bar 3 clubs( Rumba , Katandra and Tungamah ) attended the meeting and stated/outlined they will not be playing Rumba in 2020 ?

Rumba might join the pdfnl and u wont have a say in that hahaha.

 

[goodgolly24]

Is it true that all bar 3 clubs( Rumba , Katandra and Tungamah ) attended the meeting and stated/outlined they will not be playing Rumba in 2020 ?

I dunno, but if there was a meeting, and it is over the GF incident, it comes across as a text book case of “mob mentality”. At least that’s how it comes across when you view it from a neutral position....But then, if it were in relation to Rumba pursuing an appeal, it would be even more disappointing. It would appear that “the rules apply to everyone, but if Rumba uses them, kick em out of the league”....

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Rumba might join the pdfnl and u wont have a say in that hahaha.

AFL might refuse MFL affiliation until it rectifies the situation .

 

[goodgolly24]

AFL might refuse MFL affiliation until it rectifies the situation .

I saw the league announced rumba coach as their inter league coach for next year, read into that what you will..... also if this grows legs I think it’s more likely the AFL will intervene while the MFL are affiliated, rather then push them away.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

I saw the league announced rumba coach as their inter league coach for next year, read into that what you will..... also if this grows legs I think it’s more likely the AFL will intervene while the MFL are affiliated, rather then push them away.

Been within the media that Inter league footy most likely done and buried , to be confirmed this week ???
Would the affiliation agreement have ceased end of October , prior to the Wednesday meeting ?
You’d hope neither occurs .

 

[Whats the crack]

Been within the media that Inter league footy most likely done and buried , to be confirmed this week ???
Would the affiliation agreement have ceased end of October , prior to the Wednesday meeting ?
You’d hope neither occurs .

Well you were right about interleague

 

[goodgolly24]

Well you were right about interleague

Hmmm, I hope we play a game against someone still. Be a shame not too...

 

[Whats the crack]

Hmmm, I hope we play a game against someone still. Be a shame not too...

A local gala day could be an option

 

[bystanding backman]

A local gala day could be an option

State of Origin

 

[BlowMyWhistle]

State of Origin

COUNTRY STATE OF ORIGIN!!!
what a *en great idea, Vic Metro V Aus Metro. Vic Country V Aus Country (rest of Aus)

 

[Dons01]

COUNTRY STATE OF ORIGIN!!!
what a fu**en great idea, Vic Metro V Aus Metro. Vic Country V Aus Country (rest of Aus)

Any truth in the rumour MFNL v PDFNL instead of interleague

 

[BlowMyWhistle]

Any truth in the rumour MFNL v PDFNL instead of interleague

Or we could go watch Collingwood battle it out against Bonnie Doon.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Or we could go watch Collingwood battle it out against Bonnie Doon.

Bonnie Doon hasn’t been spending $40k per game to get embarrassed .

 

[Dons01]

Bonnie Doon hasn’t been spending $40k per game to get embarrassed .

Are u up for it

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Are u up for it

For what ?

 

[Dons01]

For what ?

MFL v PDFNL during a bye weekend. Donate $2 from each person through gate to mental health or drought fund.

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

MFL v PDFNL during a bye weekend. Donate $2 from each person through gate to mental health or drought fund.

PDFNL identified that senior interleague footy was dead with little interest despite a heavy burden, and buried it years ago .

 

["The Roar Is Back"]

Whilst your here Dons01 how is the below going ? Hearing at least 4 clubs are exploring their options ? Whilst clubs continue to meet to try to remove rumba including clubs asking their coaches to outline any issues they have had whilst playing against Rumba . https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/murray-fl-2019.1207730/post-62204880