Opinion Must play in a Final...

[witsend]

Must play:
Bartel
Mackie
Varcoe
Taylor
Kelly
Menzel
Corey
Lonergan
Selwood
Macintosh
T. Hunt
SJ
Duncan
Rivers
Hawkins
Stokes
Christensen
Podsiadly
Chapman
Enright

May play:
West
Murdoch
J. Hunt
Caddy
Vardy
Guthrie
GHS
Motlop

There's your dilemna
One of West and Vardy have to play which leaves Murdoch, J. Hunt, Caddy, Guthrie, GHS and Motlop fighting for 1 spot! I think it hass to be Motlop based on the "need for speed".

 

[FredLeDeux]

Must play:
Bartel
Mackie
Varcoe
Taylor
Kelly
Menzel
Corey
Lonergan
Selwood
Macintosh
T. Hunt
SJ
Duncan
Rivers
Hawkins
Stokes
Christensen
Podsiadly
Chapman
Enright

May play:
West
Murdoch
J. Hunt
Caddy
Vardy
Guthrie
GHS
Motlop

There's your dilemna
One of West and Vardy have to play which leaves Murdoch, J. Hunt, Caddy, Guthrie, GHS and Motlop fighting for 1 spot! I think it hass to be Motlop based on the "need for speed".

I am prepared to bet here and now that the 20 putative "musts" will not all be fit and firing come finals time.

 

[Max10]

Must play:
Bartel
Mackie
Varcoe
Taylor
Kelly
Menzel
Corey
Lonergan
Selwood
Macintosh
T. Hunt
SJ
Duncan
Rivers
Hawkins
Stokes
Christensen
Podsiadly
Chapman
Enright

May play:
West
Murdoch
J. Hunt
Caddy
Vardy
Guthrie
GHS
Motlop

There's your dilemna
One of West and Vardy have to play which leaves Murdoch, J. Hunt, Caddy, Guthrie, GHS and Motlop fighting for 1 spot! I think it hass to be Motlop based on the "need for speed".

agree with all except for menzel... Needs to come back and show the awesome form he displayed before his injury, remember he has been out for a long time. Not sure if he can recapture that form but hopefully for our sake he can

 

[Sttew]

A pretty handy dilemma for the club we'd all have to agree

 

[topic97]

A pretty handy dilemma for the club we'd all have to agree

Bloody oath!
Looking extremely good at this point in time for not only a finals berth but a decent tilt at a 4th flag!!

Now only to get these slow starts sorted.....

 

[bulletproof]

Motlop is a must play now.

 

[THE CAT WRANGLER]

I wouldn't even consider discussing this until 1st week of August so many thinks can happen between now and then

 

[Commando]

Gone a BIT too early... FFS it's round 3!

 

[winty]

Let's just make sure we're in the finals first before we contemplate who our best 22 is.

 

[Claude Balls]

Way too early. More than one of those blokes over 30 might have fallen by the way side in another 20 rounds. Others could be injured.

 

[supahoops]

So can we assume Blitzavs Stringer Brown Thurlow won't play. Long,long way to go..

 

[witsend]

Jesus guys...enough of the semantics.
"Must play in a final..."
The point of the discussion is our potential best 22 when all other considerations are put aside given our current depth!
Pretend there's a final tomorrow...or not!!