MVP Votes - Rd 8 vs. Bulldogs

[Vinnie Vegas]

8 - Tarkyn Lockyer
8 - Harry O'Brien
7 - Scott Burns
6 - Josh Fraser
5 - Scott Pendlebury

Just wanted to get this out of the way so I don't have to think about the game any more

 

[jefffff34]

8. O'Brien
7. Lockyer
6. Davis
6. Burns
4. O'Bree

 

[thatday]

O'bree? did u see the game or are u joking? perhaps you mean he was in the bests for the doggies, you fools you. how many times did he handball to people in trouble or just to the wrong team... ur duffle bags if you think he played well, and by the way if u thought R shaw might have made your list you should head back to the looney bin. duffer head.

 

[beaser]

Just like to say great game Tarcyn Lockyer. good to see a bloke fight back so well from serious injury . good stuff

 

[eddiesmith]

I wont be so nice, too pissed off at the worst half of football seen in a long time, no one deserves a pass

4- Lockyer
4-O'Brien
3- Burns
3- Pendlebury
2- Davis

 

[doppleganger]

I wont be so nice, too pissed off at the worst half of football seen in a long time, no one deserves a pass

4- Lockyer
4-O'Brien
3- Burns
3- Pendlebury
2- Davis

I think O'Brien absoluting destorying B.Johnson, to the extent that he was moved into the back half to boost his stats deserves at least a pass!

 

[eddiesmith]

I think O'Brien absoluting destorying B.Johnson, to the extent that he was moved into the back half to boost his stats deserves at least a pass!

Yes they all played a brilliant first half, who was he on in the 2nd?

 

[Hadders]

I think O'Brien absoluting destorying B.Johnson, to the extent that he was moved into the back half to boost his stats deserves at least a pass!

True. Harry's job on Johnson was outstanding. He wasn't spectacular or didn't get a lot of the pill but he kept one of the better forwards in the game quiet and for that reason was surely among Collingwood's best today.

 

[jefffff34]

Yes they all played a brilliant first half, who was he on in the 2nd?

He got moved onto Cooney after Cooney had got his fourth.

Cooney finished with four.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

No1 was.

Davis and Lockyer clearly BOG for us.

 

[Jabso]

6. O'Brien
6. Lockyer
5. Pendlebury
5. Davis
5. Swan

Ok so I changed it again. Thought Burns was good, but Swan along with Davis were part of the reason why we were up by 4 goals, the others played 4 quarters of solid ok football.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

No1 was.

Davis and Lockyer clearly BOG for us.

Did Davis get a kick after half time?

Only Lockyer Burns and Pendles put in four quarters, and Pendlebury had a lot of clangers.

 

[Coin_Toss]

Forgot about 'Presti' - we would have been in all sorts of trouble without him.

Can I change my votes? Sorry,

8. Harry O'Brien
8. Tarkyn Lockyer
6. Scott Burns
5. Leon Davis
4. Simon Prestigiacomo

 

[Parallel Andy]

Sorry guys, but this is the worst voting I have seen in a long time.
Very disappointed with those who are on the voting panel.
Appart from Jabso, absolute rubbish voting.
Fair enough opinion varies but some of those votes are bordering on riciculous. Obree in the voting???
Our highest vote from another was 4.
*shakes head*

Realistic voting:
Pendlebury - 8 (a class above the rest, looked untouchable)
Lockyer - 8 (super consistant, great contested possessions)
O'Brien - 8 (awesome defensive job on Johno)
Burns - 7 (was our driving force out of the middle)
Davis - 7 (made most of his possessions count)

 

[hellfire]

Sorry guys, but this is the worst voting I have seen in a long time.
Very disappointed with those who are on the voting panel.
Appart from Jabso, absolute rubbish voting.
Fair enough opinion varies but some of those votes are bordering on riciculous. Obree in the voting???
Our highest vote from another was 4.
*shakes head*

Realistic voting:
Pendlebury - 8 (a class above the rest, looked untouchable)
Lockyer - 8 (super consistant, great contested possessions)
O'Brien - 8 (awesome defensive job on Johno)
Burns - 7 (was our driving force out of the middle)
Davis - 7 (made most of his possessions count)

My votes are identical. Spot on.

 

[eddiesmith]

How you can give 3 players an 8 in the worst performance by COllingwood for a very long time is hard to understand

 

[Parallel Andy]

How you can give 3 players an 8 in the worst performance by COllingwood for a very long time is hard to understand

Simple. They were all fantastic. It's player voting here, not team voting. The only player unlucky to miss in my votes was Swan.
I'd have most other players at 5 points or below.
You cannot ignore individual brilliant perfomances such as those by Pendlebury, O'Brien and Lockyer.
By the way it is not Collingwood's worst performance, even for the year. We were rubbish against the Kangaroos, pretty ordinary for most of the game against Richmond and finished terribly against Port. Even our performance against Carlton last week was average for most of the game.
This week we played top-class footy for most of the game, the last quarter however was disappointing. Not our worst, that's for sure.

 

[Palmer Stoat]

8 O'Brien
7 Lockyer
6 Pendlebury
6 Burns
5 Swan

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

7 -Pendlebury
6 -O'Brien
6 -Lockyer
5 -Swan
5 -Thomas

 

[jefffff34]

Am I the only one that thought Pendlebury's game was cod ordinary?

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Am I the only one that thought Pendlebury's game was cod ordinary?

His split second decision making was not up to his normal standard and therefore he got caught out a few times. It wasnt his best game but it was still good.

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Am I the only one that thought Pendlebury's game was cod ordinary?

I thought pendles was our only real 4 quarter player closely followed by Lockyer and O'Brien.
The usual suspects like the Shaw's were unfortunately beaten on the day, Swan drifted in and out of the game, Fraser was beaten in the ruck, and are forwards were beaten after half time, whilst their forwards got on top of us in the second half.
I actually thought O'Bree derserved a vote, and l should have put him in for a 6.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

7 Tarks
7 Pendles
6 Burns
5 Presti
5 O Brien

 

[Jabso]

VV			Hoggy			ES
8 - Tarkyn Lockyer	8. O'Brien		4- Lockyer
8 - Harry O'Brien	7. Lockyer		4-O'Brien
7 - Scott Burns		6. Davis		3- Burns
6 - Josh Fraser		6. Burns		3- Pendlebury
5 - Scott Pendlebury	4. O'Bree		2- Davis
				
Jabso		Coin toss			Total
6. O'Brien	8. Harry O'Brien		H. O'Brien 34
6. Lockyer	8. Tarkyn Lockyer		T. Lockyer 33
5. Pendlebury	6. Scott Burns			S. Burns 22
5. Davis	5. Leon Davis			L. Davis 18
5. Swan		4. Simon Prestigiacomo		S. Pendlebury 13
						J. Fraser 6
						D. Swan 5
						S. O'Bree 4
						S. Prestigiacomo 4