Remove this Banner Ad

MVP Votes v Carlton

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

eddiesmith

eddiesmith

TheBrownDog
Lego Fan Psycho Footy Nut Veteran 10k Posts 30k Posts TheBrownDog
Jul 12, 2004
64,180
19,994
Junktion Oval
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
England
Guess I'll kick it off this week

8- T.Cloke- Great game, kicked 6 goals and it would have been a perfect 10 :thumbsu:
8- D.Swan- I was always worried he might drop away, not yet :thumbsu:
8- S.Pendlebury- Rising star in the bag
7- A.Didak- Didnt get much of it but deadly when he did it, kept us in it when others couldnt kick straight
7- H.O'Brien- Thought he played brilliantly on Betts or Fevola, still making some rookie mistakes but can be forgiven whilst he is beating his opponent
 
Jabso said:
How good was Didak's kick to Cloke while he was flat on his back. Shades of McKee QF 2002 vs. Port Adelaide. Good to see Trav finally break the 3 goals milestone.
Click to expand...
Now 4 against the Dogs, 5 against the Lions :D

Was a superb kick, looked like a fluke but almost so accurate you start to think he knew he was there
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

eddiesmith said:
Guess I'll kick it off this week

8- T.Cloke- Great game, kicked 6 goals and it would have been a perfect 10 :thumbsu:
8- D.Swan- I was always worried he might drop away, not yet :thumbsu:
8- S.Pendlebury- Rising star in the bag
7- A.Didak- Didnt get much of it but deadly when he did it, kept us in it when others couldnt kick straight
7- H.O'Brien- Thought he played brilliantly on Betts or Fevola, still making some rookie mistakes but can be forgiven whilst he is beating his opponent
Click to expand...

your bias is unbelievable eddiesmith. cloke bog-very predicatable. I am actually a massive fan of Cloke number 3(and always have been) which just goes to show I do not actually have anything against the cloke name. He was sensational but imo could not be bog because of his errant kicking. As the saying goes bad kicking is bad footy. Id definately have him in by top 3 or 4. Pendles for mine just because he has the simon back/greg williams type of ability to bring others into the game.
 
ant22 said:
your bias is unbelievable eddiesmith. cloke bog-very predicatable. I am actually a massive fan of Cloke number 3(and always have been) which just goes to show I do not actually have anything against the cloke name. He was sensational but imo could not be bog because of his errant kicking. As the saying goes bad kicking is bad footy. Id definately have him in by top 3 or 4. Pendles for mine just because he has the simon back/greg williams type of ability to bring others into the game.
Click to expand...
3AW agreed with me
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Game was great got it right some of you but some players didn't do much the first half. Some only come alight when the team starts to win. Swan was great for four quarters, clearances etc. who said he wouldnt keep it up. Players have been on him he got tagged closely by Bolton anzac day, also by port adelaide, walker came to him a bit I think Mick just knows where to place him to get the best out of him - his a play maker often setting up the play - just cause he isnt flashy like Judd he gets under the radar of the media they hype up other players - which is good for collingwood as they leave him he reads the play too well and can get away. Swannie for B & F by far this year. Worth lots in dream team and living up to it.

8 Swan
7 Fraser
7 Lockyer
6 Cloke (didnt like the misses)
6 Shaw H ( for his work in last half)
 
Jabso said:
How good was Didaks kick to Cloke while he was flat on his back. Shades of McKee QF 2002 vs. Port Adelaide. Good to see Trav finally break the 3 goals milestone.
Click to expand...
I agree but his effort early in the last quarter when we desperately needed the first goal was lacking to say the least . Running towards goal , a half-arsed kick with his right foot when quick hands over the top would have given us a vital goal was very ordinary .
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

jimmy35 said:
I agree but his effort early in the last quarter when we desperately needed the first goal was lacking to say the least . Running towards goal , a half-arsed kick with his right foot when quick hands over the top would have given us a vital goal was very ordinary .
Click to expand...

Didak or Cloke?
 
jimmy35 said:
I agree but his effort early in the last quarter when we desperately needed the first goal was lacking to say the least . Running towards goal , a half-arsed kick with his right foot when quick hands over the top would have given us a vital goal was very ordinary .
Click to expand...

Agree it was pretty ordinary. Tried to be too clever and it cost us an almost certain goal. Could see what he was trying to do but sometimes he's just gotta do the easy thing rather than try the miraculous every time.
 
Code: 
Eddiesmith		Hoggy		Coin_Toss
8- T.Cloke		8. Swan		8. D.Swan
8- D.Swan		8. Fraser	8. J.Fraser
8- S.Pendlebury		8. Pendlebury	7. S.Pendlebury
7- A.Didak		7. Didak	7. H.Shaw
7- H.O'Brien		7. Lockyer	7. T.Lockyer
				
Jabso			VV		TOTAL
8. Dane Swan		9 - Fraser	D. Swan 40
8. Tarkyn Lockyer	8 - Swan	S. Pendlebury 37
7. Joshua Fraser	8 - Cloke	J. Fraser 32
7. Scott Pendlebury	7 - Pendlebury	T. Cloke 22
6. Travis Cloke		7 - Didak	T. Lockyer 22
					A. Didak 21
					H. O'Brien 7
					H. Shaw 7
 

Remove this Banner Ad

MVP Votes v Carlton

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top