My Phantom Draft

Pie 4 Life

Brownlow Medallist
Joined
Oct 5, 2003
Posts
21,797
Likes
9,298
Location
Dragon Island
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Dragons FFC
Thread starter #1
1 Richmond - Brett Deledio (Mur)
2 Hawthorn - Richard Tambling (NT)
3 Western Bulldogs - Ryan Griffen (SA)
4 Richmond - Jarryd Roughead (Gip)
5 Hawthorn - Lance Franklin (WA)
6 Western Bulldogs - Tom Williams (Qld)
7 Hawthorn - Angus Monfries (SA)
8 Adelaide - Cameron Wood (SA)
9 Carlton - John Meesen (Gee)
10 Collingwood - Danny Meyer (SA)
11 Port Adelaide - Ben Eckerman (SA)
12 Richmond - Fabian Deluca (Eas)
13 Melbourne - Ruory Kirkby (Ben)
14 Essendon - Matthew Bate (Eas)
15 Melbourne - Ryan Willits (Nor)
16 Richmond - Jordan Russell (SA)
17 St. Kilda - Jordan Lewis (Gee)
18 Brisbane Lions - Heath Grundy (SA)
19 Port Adelaide - Chris Egan (Mur)
20 Richmond - Alan Toovey (WA)
21 Hawthorn - Ryan Jackson (Nor)
22 Western Bulldogs - Ryan Bain (Oak)
23 Collingwood - Andrew McQualter (Gip)
24 Adelaide - Benet Copping (SA)
25 Carlton - Ivan Maric (Cal)
26 Hawthorn - Thomas Murphy (San)
27 Brisbane Lions - Adam Hartlett (SA)
28 Adelaide - Thomas Redden (SA)
29 West Coast - Beau Wilkes (WA)
30 Essendon - Earl Shaw (NSW)
31 Sydney - Chad Gibson (SA)
32 Geelong - Ben Sharp (Oak)
33 St Kilda - Lynden Dunn (Cal)
34 Port Adelaide - Clinton Young (NB)
35 Port Adelaide - Matt Rosa (NB)
36 Richmond - Matt Little (Cal)
37 West Coast - Dean Polo (Gip)
38 Western Bulldogs - Adam Pattison (Nor)
39 Collingwood (F/S) - Travis Cloke (Eas)
40 Adelaide - Scott McMahon (SA)
41 Carlton (F/S) - Luke Blackwell (WA)
42 Kangaroos (F/S) - Jesse W Smith (Cal)
43 Melbourne - Michael Newton (Mur)
44 West Coast (F/S) - Mitchell Morton (WA)
45 Brisbane Lions - Mark LeCras (WA)
46 Essendon - Nick Becker (Cal)
47 Sydney - Adam Thomson (SA)
48 Geelong (F/S) - Nathan Ablett (VCFL)
49 St Kilda - Jayden Attard (Dan)
50 Brisbane Lions - Pat Garner (Qld)
51 Port Adelaide - Nathan Van Berlo (WA)
52 Richmond - Justin Sherman (Tas)
53 Hawthorn - Paul Thomas (SA)
54 Western Bulldogs - Adam Houlihan (Rich)
55 Collingwood - Jarred Moore (Dan)
56 Adelaide - Sean Rusling (SA)
57 West Coast - Andrew Swallow (WA)
58 Kangaroos - Andrew Lee (Tas)
59 Fremantle - Jesse Wells (Tas)
60 Essendon - David Spriggs (Gee)
61 Sydney - James Posiadely (VFL)
62 Geelong - Matt Egan (VFL)
63 St Kilda - Cain Ackland (PA)
64 Brisbane Lions - Dean Limbach (Cal)
Richmond - Mark Graham (Ric)
Collingwood - James Gallagher (Adel)
Fremantle - Rowan Nayna (Dan)
Kangaroos - Matthew Laidlaw (Oak)
Fremantle - Tim Hill (Ben)
Essendon - Brent Prismall (Wes)
St Kilda - James McLeay (SA)
Richmond - Patrick Wiggins (WB)
Carlton - Danyle Pearce (SA)
Kangaroos - Rubert Betheras (VFL)
Fremantle - Ryan Nye (WA)
St Kilda - Jesse D Smith (Cal)
Carlton - Mark Porter (Kan)
Carlton - Mark McGough (Coll)


I've taken a punt on a few players but it might come true!
I've made it so there's no passes from the ones selected!
What do you all think?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

grub29

Club Legend
Joined
Oct 28, 2004
Posts
1,592
Likes
0
Location
Not in Melbourne
#2
The Lonie Range said:
1 Richmond - Brett Deledio (Mur)
2 Hawthorn - Richard Tambling (NT)
3 Western Bulldogs - Ryan Griffen (SA)
4 Richmond - Jarryd Roughead (Gip)
5 Hawthorn - Lance Franklin (WA)
6 Western Bulldogs - Tom Williams (Qld)
7 Hawthorn - Angus Monfries (SA)
8 Adelaide - Cameron Wood (SA)
9 Carlton - John Meesen (Gee)
10 Collingwood - Danny Meyer (SA)
11 Port Adelaide - Ben Eckerman (SA)
12 Richmond - Fabian Deluca (Eas)
13 Melbourne - Ruory Kirkby (Ben)
14 Essendon - Matthew Bate (Eas)
15 Melbourne - Ryan Willits (Nor)
16 Richmond - Jordan Russell (SA)
17 St. Kilda - Jordan Lewis (Gee)
18 Brisbane Lions - Heath Grundy (SA)
19 Port Adelaide - Chris Egan (Mur)
20 Richmond - Alan Toovey (WA)
21 Hawthorn - Ryan Jackson (Nor)
22 Western Bulldogs - Ryan Bain (Oak)
23 Collingwood - Andrew McQualter (Gip)
24 Adelaide - Benet Copping (SA)
25 Carlton - Ivan Maric (Cal)
26 Hawthorn - Thomas Murphy (San)
27 Brisbane Lions - Adam Hartlett (SA)
28 Adelaide - Thomas Redden (SA)
29 West Coast - Beau Wilkes (WA)
30 Essendon - Earl Shaw (NSW)
31 Sydney - Chad Gibson (SA)
32 Geelong - Ben <a href="http://www.ntsearch.com/search.php?q=Sharp&v=56">Sharp</a> (Oak)
33 St Kilda - Lynden Dunn (Cal)
34 Port Adelaide - Clinton Young (NB)
35 Port Adelaide - Matt Rosa (NB)
36 Richmond - Matt Little (Cal)
37 West Coast - Dean Polo (Gip)
38 Western Bulldogs - Adam Pattison (Nor)
39 Collingwood (F/S) - Travis Cloke (Eas)
40 Adelaide - Scott McMahon (SA)
41 Carlton (F/S) - Luke Blackwell (WA)
42 Kangaroos (F/S) - Jesse W Smith (Cal)
43 Melbourne - Michael Newton (Mur)
44 West Coast (F/S) - Mitchell Morton (WA)
45 Brisbane Lions - Mark LeCras (WA)
46 Essendon - Nick Becker (Cal)
47 Sydney - Adam Thomson (SA)
48 Geelong (F/S) - Nathan Ablett (VCFL)
49 St Kilda - Jayden Attard (Dan)
50 Brisbane Lions - Pat Garner (Qld)
51 Port Adelaide - Nathan Van Berlo (WA)
52 Richmond - Justin Sherman (Tas)
53 Hawthorn - Paul Thomas (SA)
54 Western Bulldogs - Adam Houlihan (Rich)
55 Collingwood - Jarred Moore (Dan)
56 Adelaide - Sean Rusling (SA)
57 West Coast - Andrew Swallow (WA)
58 Kangaroos - Andrew Lee (Tas)
59 Fremantle - Jesse Wells (Tas)
60 Essendon - David Spriggs (Gee)
61 Sydney - James Posiadely (VFL)
62 Geelong - Matt Egan (VFL)
63 St Kilda - Cain Ackland (PA)
64 Brisbane Lions - Dean Limbach (Cal)
Richmond - Mark Graham (Ric)
Collingwood - James Gallagher (Adel)
Fremantle - Rowan Nayna (Dan)
Kangaroos - Matthew Laidlaw (Oak)
Fremantle - Tim Hill (Ben)
Essendon - Brent Prismall (Wes)
St Kilda - James McLeay (SA)
Richmond - Patrick Wiggins (WB)
Carlton - Danyle Pearce (SA)
Kangaroos - Rubert Betheras (VFL)
Fremantle - Ryan Nye (WA)
St Kilda - Jesse D Smith (Cal)
Carlton - Mark Porter (Kan)
Carlton - Mark McGough (Coll)


I've taken a punt on a few players but it might come true!
I've made it so there's no passes from the ones selected!
What do you all think?
As a Swans fan I'll take your 3 picks. Best of a bad lot of phantom drafts.
 

thegezman

Team Captain
Joined
Feb 9, 2002
Posts
485
Likes
0
#5
pretty poor draft i've got to say. but i've never done one myself so should criticise.

I reall can see carlton picking up three ruckman and Mark McGough


have you thought that one through?
 

Ching

Club Legend
Joined
Sep 9, 2003
Posts
1,956
Likes
1
Other Teams
Bulldogs
#6
The Lonie Range said:
54 Western Bulldogs - Adam Houlihan (Rich)
Good on you for putting up a mock draft but the above is not going to happen.
Bulldogs didn't trade, don't want to be in the psd and won't go for a twice recycled soft outside midfielder.
 
Joined
Nov 29, 2000
Posts
26
Likes
0
Location
Melbourne, Victoria
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
MVFC, Liverpool FC
#7
thegezman said:
pretty poor draft i've got to say. but i've never done one myself so should criticise.

I reall can see carlton picking up three ruckman and Mark McGough


have you thought that one through?
Yeah exactly...would be happy if we picked up Meeson with 9, but if we did that I think we'd go for another player with 25...and we certainly won't pick Porter and McGough with our last two picks...

McGough is likely to go to St. Kilda, and seeing as we are most probably going to get Knobel in the Pre-Season Draft, we won't pick Porter. I expect we'll pick one young ruckman in this draft (Meeson or Wood if available at 9 and DeLuca or Maric if available at 25) and get Knobel in the PSD. As for recycled players, we won't pick McGough, as Pagan and the recruiting staff are clearly targetting three areas: rucks, key position players and pace. Spriggs is a chance to get picked up with a late pick, but from what The Age says today, Sydney is likely to pounce first.
 
Top Bottom