My team vs St.Kilda (Rate & Hate)

[YelloMit]

F: Murphy, Tarrant, Bell
HF: Collard, Pavlich, Headland
C: Webster, Hasleby, Crowley
HB: Black, Johnson, Mundy
B: Hayden, McPharlin, Grover
R: Sandilands, J Carr, Dodd

I/C: Ibbotson, M Carr, Duffield, Solomon

EMG: Campbell, Warnock, Gilmore

Ins: Collard, Murphy, Ibbotson, Hasleby
Outs: Walker, Campbell, Warnock, McManus

Rate & Hate.

 

[Kenny_01]

I don't mind it, except Campbell for Murphy. Campbell deserves another go.

Would also like Warnock to play but not really needed against Saints and no-one else to drop. He looked impressive yesterday.

 

[chook2734]

I don't mind it, except Campbell for Murphy. Campbell deserves another go.

Would also like Warnock to play but not really needed against Saints and no-one else to drop. He looked impressive yesterday.

I think a game like the Saints is the perfect oportunity to play Warnock. Give him more time on the ball against a less experienced ruck combination (assuming Clarke doesn't play?) and give Sandilands a bit more of a rest. Sandi has done an enormous amount of work so far this season - if we keep pushing him like this he will get injured and then we are completely stuffed.

I agree on Campbell for Murphy, but not sure on dropping Walker for Ibbo. I wouldn't be surprised if the MRP takes care of McManus for us too.

 

[Scham]

I think a game like the Saints is the perfect oportunity to play Warnock. Give him more time on the ball against a less experienced ruck combination (assuming Clarke doesn't play?) and give Sandilands a bit more of a rest. Sandi has done an enormous amount of work so far this season - if we keep pushing him like this he will get injured and then we are completely stuffed.
.

I agree, lets try and exploit the Sts perceived lack of ability in that area.

 

[Scham]

Here's my team;

B: Hayden Grover Jonno
HB: Duffield McPharlane Black
C: Macca Crowley Dodd
HF: Soloman Pav Webster
F: Campbell Tarrant Collard

R: Sandi Hase J Carr

INT: Bell Warnock Drum Haddrill

EMERG: Headland M Carr Mundy Walker

Tried to harden the side up, but probably in exchange for pace and skill?

Macca and J Carr may have to beat charges before getting a game?

 

[SPEEDWAGON]

doddy will get reiwoldt.

McPharlin will take him if he is stationed inside the 50.

none of this dodd in the midfield business. He is a backman.

 

[Plugga]

F: Murphy, Tarrant, Bell
HF: Collard, Pavlich, Headland
C: Webster, Hasleby, Crowley
HB: Black, Johnson, Mundy
B: Hayden, McPharlin, Grover
R: Sandilands, J Carr, Dodd

I/C: Ibbotson, M Carr, Duffield, Solomon

EMG: Campbell, Warnock, Gilmore

Ins: Collard, Murphy, Ibbotson, Hasleby
Outs: Walker, Campbell, Warnock, McManus

Rate & Hate.

Campbell is in better form than murphy at the moment without a doubt.
Would rather Drum play ahead of ibbo at the moment.
Would rather McManus ahead of Des at the moment - better tackler.

 

[Plugga]

Macca and J Carr may have to beat charges before getting a game?

What? Didn't see anything?

 

[dominguez]

I think a game like the Saints is the perfect oportunity to play Warnock. Give him more time on the ball against a less experienced ruck combination (assuming Clarke doesn't play?) and give Sandilands a bit more of a rest. Sandi has done an enormous amount of work so far this season - if we keep pushing him like this he will get injured and then we are completely stuffed.

Spot on. It would be worth resting Warnock against some combinations if we had a 196cm genuine ruckman coming in, but the fact is that Gilmore or Warnock is going to play each week. Why drop Warnock against the less talented ruck combinations, keep him in and try to really exploit them with two 7 footers. If they start hurting us around the ground run Johnson with their ruckman, this would be a much better role for him than playing on the wing and getting carved up like yesterday.

 

[dominguez]

Ins: Collard, Murphy, Ibbotson, Hasleby
Outs: Walker, Campbell, Warnock, McManus

Rate & Hate.

Were you hungover or still drunk this morning Yello Mit? Surely Campbell deserves atleast one more game since he played so well last week? Murphy has played one good game in 14 weeks, he certainly doesn't deserve to be selected over Kiwi on the back of one performance. Why would you name a side with 3 young players, 2 of which would be making their debut, and drop a guy who kicked 4 goals in just his second game 7 days ago?

Ibbo hasn't done anything so won't be selected. Copping's form>>>>Ibbo's form.

Hopefully Collard plays.

If Hasleby misses again and Josh gets rubbed out we are gone considering the form of Crowley, Headland and Macca.

 

[dominguez]

none of this dodd in the midfield business. He is a backman.

He was only moved to the backline because Matt Carr is completely hopeless at any role apart from tagging. When Thornton comes in I'd love to see Dodd return to playing run with roles through the midfield and Matt Carr return to East Freo.

 

[vicdock]

He was only moved to the backline because Matt Carr is completely hopeless at any role apart from tagging. When Thornton comes in I'd love to see Dodd return to playing run with roles through the midfield and Matt Carr return to East Freo.

spot on. we cant win a premiership with m carr ,webster in side ,nice guys good clubman but time to bite the bullet, those two arent up to it

 

[Roundhouse]

spot on. we cant win a premiership with m carr ,webster in side ,nice guys good clubman but time to bite the bullet, those two arent up to it

They are exactly the kind of players you DO need to win a premiership. Players who can be given a job in the knowledge that they will stick to it.

 

[Stronzo]

F: Murphy, Tarrant, Bell
HF: Collard, Pavlich, Headland
C: Webster, Hasleby, Crowley
HB: Black, Johnson, Mundy
B: Hayden, McPharlin, Grover
R: Sandilands, J Carr, Dodd

I/C: Ibbotson, M Carr, Duffield, Solomon

EMG: Campbell, Warnock, Gilmore

Ins: Collard, Murphy, Ibbotson, Hasleby
Outs: Walker, Campbell, Warnock, McManus

Rate & Hate.

There is no way I would give him another week doing whatever it is he does out there. I don't think you could drop walker and macmanus. I would bring cookie in for deadland.