NAB Challenge Discussion

[TheOz]

Tippa back to back 80+ what a gun.

His real name is McDonald-Tipunstudly!

 

[keny]

SWOOOOOOOP

 

[keny]

What are people's thoughts on Cutler??

He's done well in a couple of games and I have him starting in my team.

 

[Pea Nut]

SWOOOOOOOP

You win !! Close thread !!

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

What are people's thoughts on Cutler??

He's done well in a couple of games and I have him starting in my team.

i personally like him - reckon he can go 85+ this season
better option than Aish and Howe IMO
Lonergan and Sheridan could be better picks

 

[keny]

i personally like him - reckon he can go 85+ this season
better option than Aish and Howe IMO
Lonergan and Sheridan could be better picks

Agreed. Anyone who think's he's a spud has NFI.

I also have Sheridan - not sure about Longergan, think he might not get as much mid time when some of the better players return?

 

[GRUFFY]

SC scores from tonight's game (and some lesser TOG%)....

WEST COAST
Matt Priddis 130
Josh Hill 118
Josh J. Kennedy 116
Jack Darling 112
Jeremy McGovern 106
Shannon Hurn 101
Nic Naitanui 96 (61%TOG)
Andrew Gaff 95
Mark LeCras 94
Elliot Yeo 94
Luke Shuey 91
Brad Sheppard 87
Jamie Bennell 72
Scott Lycett 71 (62%TOG)
Jackson Nelson 69
Liam Duggan 65
Xavier Ellis 63
Eric MacKenzie 59
Jack Redden 57 (61%TOG)
Will Schofield 54
Malcolm Karpany 48 (65%TOG)
Jamie Cripps 29
Samuel Butler 23 (38%TOG)
Kane Lucas 7 (14%TOG)
Jonathan Giles 0 (0%TOG)

ESSENDON
Mark Baguley 113
Mathew Stokes 102
Matt Dea 94
David Zaharakis 89
Joe Daniher 87
James Gwilt 77
Zach Merrett 72
Jonathan Simpkin 67
James Kelly 62
Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti 58
Mark Jamar 56 (55%TOG)
Adam Cooney 53 (69%TOG)
Shaun McKernan 52 (53%TOG)
Martin Gleeson 52
Michael Hartley 49
Orazio Fantasia 47
Kyle Langford 46
Craig Bird 44 (59%TOG)
Patrick Ambrose 43
Brendon Goddard 39
Nick Kommer 34 (67%TOG)
Jackson Merrett 34
Sam Grimley 31 (63%TOG)
Conor McKenna 26 (61%TOG)
Mitch Brown 13 (58%TOG)

 

[Double the Fist]

lmao those movies are so terrible.

I know, but everyone of my vintage knows the 'blue oyster' reference, its a timeless classic!!

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Agreed. Anyone who think's he's a spud has NFI.

I also have Sheridan - not sure about Longergan, think he might not get as much mid time when some of the better players return?

Swallow out for half season
O'Meara indefinite
Prestia - idk

reckon if he plays well, he will hold his spot in that midfield

 

[Flandersss]

SC scores from tonight's game....

WEST COAST
Matt Priddis 130
Josh Hill 118
Josh J. Kennedy 116
Jack Darling 112
Jeremy McGovern 106
Shannon Hurn 101
Nic Naitanui 96
Andrew Gaff 95
Mark LeCras 94
Elliot Yeo 94
Luke Shuey 91
Brad Sheppard 87
Jamie Bennell 72
Scott Lycett 71
Jackson Nelson 69
Liam Duggan 65
Xavier Ellis 63
Eric MacKenzie 59
Jack Redden 57
Will Schofield 54
Malcolm Karpany 48
Jamie Cripps 29
Samuel Butler 23
Kane Lucas 7
Jonathan Giles 0

ESSENDON
Mark Baguley 113
Mathew Stokes 102
Matt Dea 94
David Zaharakis 89
Joe Daniher 87
James Gwilt 77
Zach Merrett 72
Jonathan Simpkin 67
James Kelly 62
Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti 58
Mark Jamar 56
Adam Cooney 53
Shaun McKernan 52
Martin Gleeson 52
Michael Hartley 49
Orazio Fantasia 47
Kyle Langford 46
Craig Bird 44
Patrick Ambrose 43
Brendon Goddard 39
Nick Kommer 34
Jackson Merrett 34
Sam Grimley 31
Conor McKenna 26
Mitch Brown 13

CD love Michael Hartley.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

CD love Michael Hartley.

Drop Hartley or Brown?

Brown scores pretty well when they actually play him backline.

 

[Kadog]

McTip only 58. Bit harsh. Thought he was better than that.

 

[Flandersss]

Drop Hartley or Brown?

Brown scores pretty well when they actually play him backline.

Neither IMO.

 

[Amazing Bombers]

Drop Hartley or Brown?

Brown scores pretty well when they actually play him backline.

Hartley got 80+ 2 games prior would start him and bench Brown.

 

[Double the Fist]

Woosha being a campaigner moving campaingers around the ground?

 

[Kadog]

Does anyone have TOG% for both Shiel & Mumford? Cheers.

 

[KardiniaPark]

SC scores from tonight's game (and some lesser TOG%)....

WEST COAST
Matt Priddis 130
Josh Hill 118
Josh J. Kennedy 116
Jack Darling 112
Jeremy McGovern 106
Shannon Hurn 101
Nic Naitanui 96 (61%TOG)
Andrew Gaff 95
Mark LeCras 94
Elliot Yeo 94
Luke Shuey 91
Brad Sheppard 87
Jamie Bennell 72
Scott Lycett 71 (62%TOG)
Jackson Nelson 69
Liam Duggan 65
Xavier Ellis 63
Eric MacKenzie 59
Jack Redden 57 (61%TOG)
Will Schofield 54
Malcolm Karpany 48 (65%TOG)
Jamie Cripps 29
Samuel Butler 23 (38%TOG)
Kane Lucas 7 (14%TOG)
Jonathan Giles 0 (0%TOG)

ESSENDON
Mark Baguley 113
Mathew Stokes 102
Matt Dea 94
David Zaharakis 89
Joe Daniher 87
James Gwilt 77
Zach Merrett 72
Jonathan Simpkin 67
James Kelly 62
Anthony McDonald-Tipungwuti 58
Mark Jamar 56 (55%TOG)
Adam Cooney 53 (69%TOG)
Shaun McKernan 52 (53%TOG)
Martin Gleeson 52
Michael Hartley 49
Orazio Fantasia 47
Kyle Langford 46
Craig Bird 44 (59%TOG)
Patrick Ambrose 43
Brendon Goddard 39
Nick Kommer 34 (67%TOG)
Jackson Merrett 34
Sam Grimley 31 (63%TOG)
Conor McKenna 26 (61%TOG)
Mitch Brown 13 (58%TOG)

Geez Kommer is a huge steaming turd.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Neither IMO.

Keep both?

 

[Flandersss]

Keep both?

Yep.

There's SFA rookies, why boot the ones with JS?

 

[GRUFFY]

Does anyone have TOG% for both Shiel & Mumford? Cheers.

Shiel 82%TOG (119SC)
Mumford 68%TOG (110SC)

 

[Kadog]

Shiel 82%TOG (119SC)
Mumford 68%TOG (110SC)

Thx bud

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

Dea with 94. Nice.
Worthwhile trying to find an extra 60-70k to upgrade one of the other Def rookies?

 

[TyroneVickery29]

Wish I could pick Mummy and not have to worry about him getting injured

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Dea with 94. Nice.
Worthwhile trying to find an extra 60-70k to upgrade one of the other Def rookies?

If you can do it without compromising too much I would.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

I wonder if the Essendon banned players will all be discounted next season? I want to select Bellchambers for $40k.

I guess if he's priced at $40K I'd consider him.

If he spuds it up Super Premo, you've only lost $40k.