NAB Challenge Discussion

[TheBeardAmigos]

want to slot Weitering in at D5, was very impressive today!

 

[Double the Fist]

u mean 19 touches and 8 marks is a poor game for a KPD?

misread Nameless post.

 

[toxic]

I'm almost tempted to take one of my 4 premo defenders out for Weitering. Get Goldstein in the ruck and take an assload of cash into R1.

You don't have goldy already

 

[GRUFFY]

SC scores from today's late game....

FREMANTLE
Nat Fyfe 138
Tommy Sheridan 128
Nick Suban 102
Michael Barlow 92
Stephen Hill 82
Tendai Mzungu 82
Danyle Pearce 75
Chris Mayne 73
Cameron Sutcliffe 71
Lachie Neale 69
Connor Blakely 65
Ed Langdon 64
Sam Collins 63
Lachie Weller 60
Matt Taberner 55
Michael Johnson 51
Alex Silvagni 46
Jack Hannath 43
Michael Walters 40
Jonathon Griffin 38
Ethan Hughes 37
Matthew Pavlich 35
Brady Grey 33
Garrick Ibbotson 32
Clancee Pearce 24
Zac Dawson 22

ADELAIDE
Rory Laird 121
Richard Douglas 117
Matt Crouch 117
Rory Atkins 103
Nathan van Berlo 98
Tom Lynch 95
Jake Lever 90
Paul Seedsman 90
Reilly O’Brien 81
David Mackay 78
Jarryd Lyons 77
Rory Sloane 72
Josh Jenkins 61
Kyle Cheney 60
Wayne Milera 54
Kyle Hartigan 54
Cam Ellis-Yolmen 41
Dean Gore 39
Sam Shaw 38
Jake Kelly 35
Luke Brown 35
Mitch McGovern 32
Troy Menzel 30
Brodie Smith 29
Mitch Grigg 25
Harry Dear 9

 

[billy fragos]

Tempted to get m.crouch in

 

[KardiniaPark]

You don't have goldy already

Going with 15 keepers ATM so I'm about $100k away from being able to get him. I'm really struggling to find someone I'm happy to get rid of. I may just hold it and give it two rounds and make a corrective - Simpson > Weitering. Jacobs> Goldy as an example. I just really like my team and it changes too much with Goldstein.

The only thing I'd really consider right now is Shaw> Gibson or someone like that which would keep the 15 keepers but still be able to squeeze Goldy in. I dunno...

 

[nameless]

Only a little game time for Gore and Milera, so 39 and 54 isn't terrible.

Gotta hope they play.

 

[KenTucker]

Laird and Sherro haven't left my team since day one. Bit disappointing knowing people will get on, but at least you know they are playing well going into the season proper.

 

[nameless]

Someone talked up Sheridan very early, and I dismissed it, might have to reconsider now.

Laird is well priced though, he's been in most of the time for me.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Sheridan = Ibbo

 

[GRUFFY]

Some lesser TOG% from some players...

M.Barlow 68%
L.Weller 65%
S.Collins 39%
A.Silvagni 51%

M.Crouch 67%
W.Milera 51%
B.Smith 29%
D.Gore 45%

 

[stevebbb]

Tempted to get m.crouch in

Safer pick than his brother imo

 

[KardiniaPark]

Safer pick than his brother imo

But not as good when the real stuff starts. I don't have him but he's a far far far better player and he's much cheaper.

 

[joop]

Laird and Sherro haven't left my team since day one. Bit disappointing knowing people will get on, but at least you know they are playing well going into the season proper.

Sheridan is $350k and averaged 65 last year. Do not see the appeal at all.

 

[Sir Skid]

Sheridan is $350k and averaged 65 last year. Do not see the appeal at all.

New sweeper role?

 

[Me Myself and I]

Some lesser TOG% from some players...

M.Barlow 68%
L.Weller 65%
S.Collins 39%
A.Silvagni 51%

M.Crouch 67%
W.Milera 51%
B.Smith 29%
D.Gore 45%

Collins' 63 points for his TOG brings him to the forefront. Might have to push Brown forward if no fwd rookies step up to the plate.
Barlow as well but I already have him.

 

[Pedro]

Someone talked up Sheridan very early, and I dismissed it, might have to reconsider now.

Laird is well priced though, he's been in most of the time for me.

Sheridan talk reminds me a bit of the same discussions had regarding Cameron Sutcliffe last year. I'm not convinced enough to stray from the GnR approach. (If you can call the DEF's Guns that is) Currently have Shaw, Rance, Laird and Jimmy B. Not sure I'm prepared to gamble much more than that. Got my fingers burnt by Harry O last year and swore I wouldn't do it again

 

[KenTucker]

Sheridan is $350k and averaged 65 last year. Do not see the appeal at all.

Looked really good in the latter part of last season. Cheap spec pick to maybe become a keeper.

 

[billy fragos]

Im going with matt>brad, might re consider after brad plays next week.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Collins' 63 points for his TOG brings him to the forefront. Might have to push Brown forward if no fwd rookies step up to the plate.
Barlow as well but I already have him.

Didn't Collins only get like 2 touches in a full game last week?

 

[Flandersss]

Didn't Collins only get like 2 touches in a full game last week?

Correct.

 

[bananatigz]

Looked really good in the latter part of last season. Cheap spec pick to maybe become a keeper.

View attachment 220391

Average of 85.4, take out the 35 and it jumps to 91.8

 

[Daniels]

Everyone will jump on laird now damn it.

Was already jumped on!

 

[jjsmitty8]

As funny as it would be to have that happen another 2 times..

Put Kreuzer, Murphy, Gibbs, Thomas, Casboult, Kerridge, Walker in and i highly doubt that they get spanked..

And Cripps!

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

You locking in Fyfe yet Here2tellyouwhy?

He's been locked in since just before NAB. Pissed Libba off to make it happen.
Don't need that midpriced maybe crap in my team. Fyfe is SC royalty.