NAB Challenge Discussion

[pincrusher]

Another decent score from Max Gawn on the back of 12 HTA's and 111 #SuperCoach points. Also 10 disposals at 100% efficiency.

Put him in a couple of weeks ago in place of Stef. Unless he gets injured he'll be staying there.

 

[hendo8888]

Viney could be a genuine option in SC. If he ever learns to kick the ball.

 

[Test Tickle]

Solid opening game from Libba with 16 disposals, 10 tackles, 102 #SuperCoach and 79 #AFLFantasy points.

 

[pincrusher]

Viney could be a genuine option in SC. If he ever learns to kick the ball.

I'm seriously considering Viney at this point and the kick to handball ratio is not an issue for me. What does an effective handball score as opposed to an Ineffective kick?

 

[Hairy Lager]

Oh no how dare the AFL let people in other locations enjoy the sport! The nerve...

My Mum wants her saying back!

 

[hendo8888]

imagine if he broke out.
stranger things have happened.

His SC ratios were hideous for each game though. So he isn't an option here.

 

[GRUFFY]

hic think i just swallowed some of me spew

I'm seriously considering Viney at this point and the kick to handball ratio is not an issue for me. What does an effective handball score as opposed to an Ineffective kick?

Are you serious man? Viney is 497K!
What are you THINKING????
8 midfield spots, Ablett, Fyfe, Pend, Rock, Danger, Lib$, Crouch$, and waiting for Priddis, JPK, Han, Beams, where does this Viney fit in ?

 

[TheOz]

Viney could be a genuine option in SC. If he ever learns to kick the ball.

Never stopped JPK or Priddis from becoming SC midfield premiums due to their inside games and high contested possession numbers.

 

[Glenn Barclay]

Who's more likely to get a gig at the Doggies, Collins or Adams? Adams has looked alright today.

I'd say that Adams and Collins will get a go but I'll be surprised if its round one

 

[pincrusher]

hic think i just swallowed some of me spew

Are you serious man? Viney is 497K!
What are you THINKING????
8 midfield spots, Ablett, Fyfe, Pend, Rock, Danger, Lib$, Crouch$, and waiting for Priddis, JPK, Han, Beams, where does this Viney fit in ?

No guts no glory. He's primed. Nearly 22 yo. my only concern is whether or not he will tag when necessary. Would love to go through and get his average from last year in games where he tagged as opposed to games where he didn't. No point in everyone having the same players. Makes it pretty boring doesn't it??

 

[GRUFFY]

No guts no glory. He's primed. Nearly 22 yo. my only concern is whether or not he will tag when necessary. Would love to go through and get his average from last year in games where he tagged as opposed to games where he didn't. No point in everyone having the same players. Makes it pretty boring doesn't it??

Bourbon for you my friend

 

[pincrusher]

hic think i just swallowed some of me spew

Are you serious man? Viney is 497K!
What are you THINKING????
8 midfield spots, Ablett, Fyfe, Pend, Rock, Danger, Lib$, Crouch$, and waiting for Priddis, JPK, Han, Beams, where does this Viney fit in ?

Add to that, right now I have concerns about whether Crouch will be fit for round 1. I have $258k to play with at the moment if I need to ditch him.

 

[pincrusher]

Bourbon for you my friend

Screw that. Cheap red wine can do the trick if you drink enough of it. Less than half the price too.

 

[GRUFFY]

Screw that. Cheap red wine can do the trick if you drink enough of it. Less than half the price too.

you cheap bastard

 

[Hairy Lager]

hic think i just swallowed some of me spew

Are you serious man? Viney is 497K!
What are you THINKING????
8 midfield spots, Ablett, Fyfe, Pend, Rock, Danger, Lib$, Crouch$, and waiting for Priddis, JPK, Han, Beams, where does this Viney fit in ?

POTY classic.

 

[Feerits Elf]

POTY classic.

Low standards?

 

[TheOz]

Dunkley 94, Adams 76, Collins 62, Kennedy 76

 

[TheOz]

MELBOURNE

Jack Viney 113
Max Gawn 112
Nathan Jones 103
Matt Jones 96
Dom Tyson 92
Tom McDonald 92
James Harmes 90
Jack Watts 89
Bernie Vince 81
Jeff Garlett 79
Christian Salem 78
Ben Kennedy 76
Jack Grimes 74
Tomas Bugg 74
Clayton Oliver 70
Aaron Vandenberg 66
Neville Jetta 63
Cameron Pedersen 61
Jayden Hunt 40
Sam Frost 36
Dean Kent 32
Lynden Dunn 30
Josh Wagner 27
Viv Michie 27
Colin Garland 23
Billy Stretch 0

WESTERN BULLDOGS

Lin Jong 115
Tom Liberatore 107
Josh Dunkley 94
Mitch Honeychurch 89
Jordan Roughead 82
Caleb Daniel 79
Nathan Hrovat 76
Marcus Adams 76
Will Minson 69
Josh Prudden 68
Jed Adcock 63
Kieran Collins 62
Jack Redpath 61
Lukas Webb 61
Tom Boyd 59
Zaine Cordy 58
Tom Campbell 56
Bailey Dale 56
Toby McLean 52
Brad Lynch 51
Joel Hamling 46
Bailey Williams 42
Fletcher Roberts 35
Declan Hamilton 13
Luke Goetz 5

 

[Jiska]

Did Gawn end up playing out the game?

 

[TheOz]

Did Gawn end up playing out the game?

Yeh, 82% TOG.

 

[stevebbb]

Did Gawn end up playing out the game?

Yep.

Will BenKen be best 22 come round 1?

 

[hendo8888]

Did Gawn end up playing out the game?

Yes

 

[pincrusher]

Did Gawn end up playing out the game?

Surprised he didn't score more actually. 10 touches at 100% and 46 hitouts.

Jiska what are your thoughts on Viney? Is he likely to tag again this year? Scored 124 and 113 in the last two rounds of 2015 after being relieved of tagging duties. Averaged 107 for the last 7 rounds. Seriously considering him as a POD

 

[Jiska]

Surprised he didn't score more actually. 10 touches at 100% and 46 hitouts.

Jiska what are your thoughts on Viney? Is he likely to tag again this year? Scored 124 and 113 in the last two rounds of 2015 after being relieved of tagging duties. Averaged 107 for the last 7 rounds. Seriously considering him as a POD

I think tagging roles were a teaching thing rather than a long term plan. Being an in and under player is a big bonus for SC but his price is rather awkward; better options exist IMO.

I prefer Brayshaw with DPP. Guy is going to be an absolute gun.

 

[GRUFFY]

MELBOURNE

Jack Viney 113
Max Gawn 112
Nathan Jones 103
Matt Jones 96
Dom Tyson 92
Tom McDonald 92
James Harmes 90
Jack Watts 89
Bernie Vince 81
Jeff Garlett 79
Christian Salem 78
Ben Kennedy 76
Jack Grimes 74
Tomas Bugg 74
Clayton Oliver 70
Aaron Vandenberg 66
Neville Jetta 63
Cameron Pedersen 61
Jayden Hunt 40
Sam Frost 36
Dean Kent 32
Lynden Dunn 30
Josh Wagner 27
Viv Michie 27
Colin Garland 23
Billy Stretch 0

WESTERN BULLDOGS

Lin Jong 115
Tom Liberatore 107
Josh Dunkley 94
Mitch Honeychurch 89
Jordan Roughead 82
Caleb Daniel 79
Nathan Hrovat 76
Marcus Adams 76
Will Minson 69
Josh Prudden 68
Jed Adcock 63
Kieran Collins 62
Jack Redpath 61
Lukas Webb 61
Tom Boyd 59
Zaine Cordy 58
Tom Campbell 56
Bailey Dale 56
Toby McLean 52
Brad Lynch 51
Joel Hamling 46
Bailey Williams 42
Fletcher Roberts 35
Declan Hamilton 13
Luke Goetz 5

Have to make the tough call, BKennedy is not starting in my side.