NAB Challenge Discussion

[croweyrocks]

Agree on Parker and Shiel however think Viney a better selection than Wines and Cripps.

Based on NAB form absolutely but Cripps and Wines have more upside as players and supercoach scorers IMO.

 

[markm106]

It's not based on NAB alone. Anyway just my opinion. Viney I believe would probably just out score both this year.

 

[Hairy Lager]

It's not based on NAB alone. Anyway just my opinion. Viney I believe would probably just out score both this year.

Thoughts on Salem? Role and avg. for the year, thanks in advance.

 

[markm106]

Thoughts on Salem? Role and avg. for the year, thanks in advance.

I had a look at him few weeks back and won't be picking him. Will be a valuable player for us but think he could average around 75-80. I would love to see him go bigger and probably will in future. Better value in Lonergan and Sheridan.

 

[Hairy Lager]

I had a look at him few weeks back and won't be picking him. Will be a valuable player for us but think he could average around 75-80. I would love to see him go bigger and probably will in future. Better value in Lonergan and Sheridan.

Thanks I am looking a both of those at the moment, don't know if I'm game enough yet.
Very interested though both fit in my price range.

 

[TheBeardAmigos]

Thurlow just confirmed to do an ACL!!! Poor bugger.......
on the brighter side, could mean Ruggles gets elevated and might play early on

 

[Hairy Lager]

Thurlow just confirmed to do an ACL!!! Poor bugger.......
on the brighter side, could mean Ruggles gets elevated and might play early on

 

[Franky_024]

Why? Most on the Dees board have BenKen as best 22
I think he's good for a 70 average (which will see him over $300k), it's just a matter of if he's best 22

I just don't think he's a good SC option, expecting him to drift in and out of games and doesn't seem to have a big ceiling. I don't think he's capable of 70 average, Garlett is probably our best small forward and he doesn't average that. Played 3 full games last year for Pies and scored 43, 45 and 53.

From a purely Melbourne perspective I think Petracca and Hunt offer better value for less

 

[DuckYeah]

I just don't think he's a good SC option, expecting him to drift in and out of games and doesn't seem to have a big ceiling. I don't think he's capable of 70 average, Garlett is probably our best small forward and he doesn't average that. Played 3 full games last year for Pies and scored 43, 45 and 53.

From a purely Melbourne perspective I think Petracca and Hunt offer better value for less

Protractor has to get on the park first

 

[stevebbb]

I just don't think he's a good SC option, expecting him to drift in and out of games and doesn't seem to have a big ceiling. I don't think he's capable of 70 average, Garlett is probably our best small forward and he doesn't average that. Played 3 full games last year for Pies and scored 43, 45 and 53.

From a purely Melbourne perspective I think Petracca and Hunt offer better value for less

 

[Daniels]

I was directly across the road at Highlands Hotel watching the UFC. You could still see play from parts of the ground. The whole area was buzzing today.

Nice one!

 

[Daniels]

Wasnt that hot mate? Where you from? Antarctica? The ukon? Nepal? Was only 32 or some shit like that! Perfect froffie drinkin weather

Only!? F me!

Give me a nice 21 degrees, slight breeze, overcast with a touch of sun breaking through for perfect footy viewing any day!

 

[Kadog]

Only!? F me!

Give me a nice 21 degrees, slight breeze, overcast with a touch of sun breaking through for perfect footy viewing any day!

It wasn't that bad at all. Draught on tap was going down nicely.

 

[Daniels]

It wasn't that bad at all. Draught on tap was going down nicely.

Haha, yeah inside near the bar!

 

[Kadog]

Haha, yeah inside near the bar!

I'm smart!

 

[KardiniaPark]

Talk of Viney is ridiculous. If you have him in your team you have NFI what you're doing. toxic probably has him.

 

[Flandersss]

Talk of Viney is ridiculous. If you have him in your team you have NFI what you're doing. toxic probably has him.

What if I've got Todd?

 

[KardiniaPark]

What if I've got Todd?

I think you need to update your Commodore 64.

 

[DuckYeah]

Only!? F me!

Give me a nice 21 degrees, slight breeze, overcast with a touch of sun breaking through for perfect footy viewing any day!

Sooooo, you dont live in melbourne? That shit happens less than a full lunar eclipse

 

[karaoke]

What if I've got Todd?

Having Jay would trump it all.

 

[KardiniaPark]

Thoughts on Salem? Role and avg. for the year, thanks in advance.

I'm pretty sure he wasn't even a real cat, but the the things I would do to Sarina's Auntie DAYMNNNN

 

[toxic]

Talk of Viney is ridiculous. If you have him in your team you have NFI what you're doing. toxic probably has him.

Toxic has no Viney you Levi loving mudda fr

 

[KardiniaPark]

Toxic has no Viney you Levi loving mudda fr

Oh hAi

 

[Daniels]

Sooooo, you dont live in melbourne? That shit happens less than a full lunar eclipse

Happens frequently!

Nice shorts and t shirt weather.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Talk of Viney is ridiculous. If you have him in your team you have NFI what you're doing. toxic probably has him.

Given other options around his price you'd be silly to take him over Parker who is 40k more or Ollie Wines.

But keep in mind he averaged 100 last 10 games.

When he's not tagging he is quite handy.. only 21 years of age and plenty of improvement left.

It's not as absurd as you suggest but i wouldn't take him over Wines and Parker.