NAB Challenge Discussion

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Nope.

Not sure how he scored 46.

Will not play R1 surely. Was horrible.

 

[Unknown Identity]

Mills, Gresham, Mathieson, Menadue, Petracca as it stands for me.

Similar to me.

Tiger fans reckon Menadue is no lock

 

[TheOz]

He was pretty impactful with his 18, set up numerous goals.

I was being somewhat facetious, still surprised by the score.

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Nope.

Not sure how he scored 46.

5 tackles

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

I was being somewhat facetious, still surprised by the score.

Yeah it was higher than I expected!

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Similar to me.

Tiger fans reckon Menadue is no lock

He's done really well in NAB! Hoping he is.

 

[Didstar]

Mason Cox. Sitting in F7 ATM

Edit. Didn't see the game, the fact he scored and I'm desperate.

Did he look ok?

Competed well and got his hands to the ball in the air a few times, but didn't grab them like he did in Nab 1. I'd expect him to play this year, but would be behind Cloke, Moore, Gault and Grundy/Witts for a Rd 1 position.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Competed well and got his hands to the ball in the air a few times, but didn't grab them like he did in Nab 1. I'd expect him to play this year, but would be behind Cloke, Moore, Gault and Grundy/Witts for a Rd 1 position.

I thought he was rubbish TBH.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Thurlow injuried for the cats unsure how bad I just got home.
I noticed rookied listed ruggles scored alright.

 

[TheOz]

Zero centre bounce attendances for Bartel. Danger led the way with 18 while Langford attended 16.

Tippett attended 48 ruck contests to Sinclair's 34. HTA's were Tippett 5 and Sinclair 4

Game-high 26 disposals and 15 handball-receives for Taylor Adams. Greenwood had 25 disposals, 14 cont. poss and 8 tackles.

Standard game from @SP_10 with 113 #SuperCoach points. Wells 93 and Goldy 84. Wells attended 10 centre bounces.

 

[Didstar]

I thought he was rubbish TBH.

Wasn't his best game no doubt, which is why he likely wont play till later in the year. Has shown he has some sort of capability, but would be a fair way off producing solid and consistent football.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Pics of the GWS float to follow.

Looks totally fab .

 

[catstragic]

Is anyone not going to have wells if he is healthy going into round 1?

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Pendles could do nothing but fart and CD would award him a ton. Must have.

Geez, I'd be a Supercoach Premo it that were the criteria!

 

[rocker_oz33]

Pending rookies eg wells.
If there's not 2016 cey vanders etc..

Wells could be dis years missy if he stays fit.

 

[GRUFFY]

SC scores from this evening's game (and some lesser TOG%)....

COLLINGWOOD
Taylor Adams 126 (69%TOG)
Levi Greenwood 119
Scott Pendlebury 112
Jack Crisp 101
Jarryd Blair 97
Alex Fasolo 96 (59%TOG)
Corey Gault 89
Brayden Maynard 78
Travis Varcoe 71
James Aish 69
Travis Cloke 69
Matthew Goodyear 69 (68%TOG)
Adam Oxley 66
Tom Langdon 64
Jack Frost 54
Ben Sinclair 50
Alan Toovey 49
Mason Cox 46
Jarrod Witts 45
Tom Phillips 44 (69%TOG)
Jesse White 44
Jonathon Marsh 39
Jackson Ramsay 35 (35%TOG)
Brodie Grundy 34 (32%TOG)
Darcy Moore 27
Brayden Sier 12 (26%TOG)

NORTH MELBOURNE
Nick Dal Santo 99
Sam Gibson 98
Daniel Wells 98
Drew Petrie 97
Aaron Mullett 86
Todd Goldstein 84
Lachlan Hansen 80
Luke McDonald 79 (53%TOG)
Jack Ziebell 76
Ben Brown 74
Andrew Swallow 71 (69%TOG)
Aaron Black 69
Lindsay Thomas 68
Robbie Tarrant 64
Robin Nahas 61
Farren Ray 61
Declan Mountford 52 (31%TOG)
Brad McKenzie 51
Trent Dumont 49
Mitchell Hibberd 36
Taylor Garner 35
Joel Tippett 32
Ryan Clarke 30 (27%TOG)
Ben Jacobs 28
Majak Daw 15 (33%TOG)
Mason Wood 4 (33%TOG)

 

[rocker_oz33]

Is tyres (goodyear) a chance to play dis year.
Anyone pumping him up.

 

[Kadog]

Is tyres (goodyear) a chance to play dis year.
Anyone pumping him up.

Unlikely

 

[Double the Fist]

SC scores from this evening's game (and some lesser TOG%)....
Declan Mountford 52 (31%TOG)

Who the hell is Declan Mountford! LOL

 

[Didstar]

Is anyone not going to have wells if he is healthy going into round 1?

Not planning to unless it becomes a necessity with a lack of cheaper rookies. Happy to go with Mills, but too many 200k + rookies compromises the structure to an extent. If he plays Nab 3 to a similar standard to today though, will be very tempting. As others have said, he only need 6-8 games and will be a near straight swap to a premo, but starting him over a 120k rookie can be the difference from a super premo or a speculative pick.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Who the hell is Declan Mountford! LOL

Draftee. Looked the best of our rookies easily. Fitted in to the midfield seamlessly.

See what happens NAB 3.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Who the hell is Declan Mountford! LOL

Sounds like serial killer lol.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Tipi dude from the bummers def fwd 102k.
Are all rookie listed players at Ess need upgrading ? Like normal or they can play even ever.

 

[Keg on legs]

Is anyone not going to have wells if he is healthy going into round 1?

I don't have him and don't intend to get him unless my hand is forced with round 1 selections. I just don't trust his body enough. Having said that, he dos look good today from what I saw.

 

[Keg on legs]

Tipi dude from the bummers def fwd 102k.
Are all rookie listed players at Ess need upgrading ? Like normal or they can play even ever.

IIRC Essendon can still upgrade 2 more rookies. Tip and long the most likely at this stage