NAB Challenge Discussion

TheProwler · Mar 5, 2016

DuckYeah said:
Menadue is a real chance, not a slim a chance, wont play one or 2, but a real sniff to have s good crack.. How can a tiges supporter believe hes not? Ridiculous!

Then put him in your squad, sit back and enjoy the donuts whilst others score. He will play some games maybe even R1 but he is amongst a group of players vying for the same spot. Make of the what you will.......

DuckYeah · Mar 5, 2016

TheProwler said:
Then put him in your squad, sit back and enjoy the donuts whilst others score. He will play some games maybe even R1 but he is amongst a group of players vying for the same spot. Make of the what you will.......

Yup, if he plays round one, does his job then he'll be in round two.. I expect him to do as dimma wants, he'll get relief undoubtably, but i believe he may be a good little cash injection.. We'll see how the nab plays out, imo he's ready for AFL!

DraftPunk · Mar 5, 2016

SterlingArcher said:
Played 16 games last year for them. Seems pretty close to best 22 for me. Doubt Geelong play all of J.Kolodjashnij, Henderson, Lonergan and Taylor. Bews will be in for one of them (probably Henderson who may get thrown forward with the absence of Clark). Bartel, Guthrie and Gregson are all more likely to play an attacking small defender role, Bews plays that Nick Smith complete shutdown role.

From the cats board:

For hawthorn round 1 assuming thurlow scooter clark and menegola are all injured,i would go:
B: Enright Lonergan Henderson
HB: Mackie Taylor Guthrie
C: Murdoch Caddy Duncan
HF: Motlop Vardy Cockatoo
F: Menzel Hawkins Gregson
R: Smith Dangerfield J Selwood
Int: Blicavs Stanley Bartel Lang
Emg: Kolo Bews Mccarthy

----------------

Looks pretty spot on to me. No room for Bews or Ruggles.

catstragic · Mar 6, 2016

DraftPunk said:
From the cats board:

For hawthorn round 1 assuming thurlow scooter clark and menegola are all injured,i would go:
B: Enright Lonergan Henderson
HB: Mackie Taylor Guthrie
C: Murdoch Caddy Duncan
HF: Motlop Vardy Cockatoo
F: Menzel Hawkins Gregson
R: Smith Dangerfield J Selwood
Int: Blicavs Stanley Bartel Lang
Emg: Kolo Bews Mccarthy

----------------

Looks pretty spot on to me. No room for Bews or Ruggles.

Thats a pretty slow and tall defensive setup, I guess well see round 1.
If there gonna field that team they will have to stop quick ball movement against them or they will get picked to pieces.

Sir Hugh Percy · Mar 6, 2016

What was the go with Bird today? Doesn't seem to have scored very well from decent game time.

Here2tellyouwhy · Mar 6, 2016

Sir Hugh Percy said:
What was the go with Bird today? Doesn't seem to have scored very well from decent game time.

injury I think.

GRUFFY · Mar 6, 2016

Sir Hugh Percy said:
What was the go with Bird today? Doesn't seem to have scored very well from decent game time.

corked thigh

DuckYeah · Mar 6, 2016

GRUFFY said:
corked thigh

The worst, i had a nastey corked quad 6 years ago, split the muscle.. To this day if i get a knock to the same spot im down n out for a day or two.. Innocuous type that just keeps lingering on

Mitchell54 · Mar 6, 2016

I've just read a Essendon vs Geelong game supercoach Analysis and the North vs Pies one too. Swapped Simpkin to Wells and now i have 504K for a defender.

Thoughts?
I'm thinking Simpson or Bartel but who do you think

scooter30 · Mar 6, 2016

Mitchell5 said:
I've just read a Essendon vs Geelong game supercoach Analysis and the North vs Pies one too. Swapped Simpkin to Wells and now i have 504K for a defender.

Thoughts?
I'm thinking Simpson or Bartel but who do you think

Simpson, Bartel will get managed

pincrusher · Mar 6, 2016

Mitchell5 said:
I've just read a Essendon vs Geelong game supercoach Analysis and the North vs Pies one too. Swapped Simpkin to Wells and now i have 504K for a defender.

Thoughts?
I'm thinking Simpson or Bartel but who do you think

Do you already have Laird? $506200.

prodigy · Mar 6, 2016

rocker_oz33 said:
Tipi dude from the bummers def fwd 102k.
Are all rookie listed players at Ess need upgrading ? Like normal or they can play even ever.

All Essendon's rookies have been upgraded already due to losing half their senior list.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Mitchell54 · Mar 6, 2016

pincrusher said:
Do you already have Laird? $506200.

Yep. Already got Laird, Birchall and Smith
That's the trouble. the Defence is a pretty hard position for Premos or high priced mid-picers this year.

pincrusher · Mar 6, 2016

prodigy said:
All Essendon's rookies have been upgraded already due to losing half their senior list.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

This article disagrees with you.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...t/news-story/9b721e96c3995dc08da998c33ebfb6d8

prodigy · Mar 6, 2016

pincrusher said:
This article disagrees with you.

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/a...t/news-story/9b721e96c3995dc08da998c33ebfb6d8

I couldn't get past the pay-wall. I thought I read something somewhere that they could elevate all their rookie listed players. My bad.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

buttox · Mar 6, 2016

KenTucker said:
Yeah, I do that, but if I want to scroll across to see other games I can not scroll across (there'd no arrows or anything). The last game I can click on is Richmond v Hawks

View attachment 222256

click on the fan footy icon top left. should get you back to front page. there the arrow exists

buttox · Mar 6, 2016

prodigy said:
All Essendon's rookies have been upgraded already due to losing half their senior list.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

i was certain they had 2 to upgrade.
are you sure?

buttox · Mar 6, 2016

Mitchell5 said:
Yep. Already got Laird, Birchall and Smith
That's the trouble. the Defence is a pretty hard position for Premos or high priced mid-picers this year.

macmillan or houli if you can scrap together 516k

joop · Mar 6, 2016

Mitchell5 said:
I've just read a Essendon vs Geelong game supercoach Analysis and the North vs Pies one too. Swapped Simpkin to Wells and now i have 504K for a defender.

Thoughts?
I'm thinking Simpson or Bartel but who do you think

Simpson is cooked...stay away from him.

Raveneyes · Mar 6, 2016

Mitchell5 said:
I've just read a Essendon vs Geelong game supercoach Analysis and the North vs Pies one too. Swapped Simpkin to Wells and now i have 504K for a defender.

Thoughts?
I'm thinking Simpson or Bartel but who do you think

scooter30 said:
Simpson, Bartel will get managed

I don't think they'll be managed at all. It's a common misconception. Just because a player is over 30, doesn't mean they will get rested.
Simpson is very fit and having a great pre-season, and Bartel's knee is giving him no trouble at all.

FWIW I have Bartel, and has never moved. Simpson has rotated through my team, and may start yet.

Raveneyes · Mar 6, 2016

joop said:
Simpson is cooked...stay away from him.

Cooked? Why is he cooked? Have I missed something?

prodigy · Mar 6, 2016

buttox said:
i was certain they had 2 to upgrade.
are you sure?

I think I might be wrong.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

joop · Mar 6, 2016

Raveneyes said:
Cooked? Why is he cooked? Have I missed something?

Nah not that I've heard, I have him. His ownership is at 4% so trying to keep it that way

Double the Fist · Mar 6, 2016

Raveneyes said:
Cooked? Why is he cooked? Have I missed something?

Raveneyes · Mar 6, 2016

Double the Fist said:
View attachment 222340

Log In or Create New Account

NAB Challenge Discussion

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Club Legend

BigFooty Aristocrat

SA GREAT

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Rookie

Moderator

Taj Hotton Loyalist

Norm Smith Medallist

Moderator

Taj Hotton Loyalist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Floreat Pica

Floreat Pica

Taj Hotton Loyalist

Brownlow Medallist

i wull eet yur fayce karnt

Floreat Pica