NAB Challenge Discussion

[TheOz]

Does it annoy anyone else when people can't spell players full names? Liberatore, Dahlhaus just to name a few?

Rockliff annoys me when people add an e to his name. Hate it.

 

[DuckYeah]

He's gone!

I second that notion, ive opted for 5 premo mid keepers instead of ****in about with risky libba!

 

[DuckYeah]

Rockliff annoys me when people add an e to his name. Hate it.

People annoy me! The way they talk, walk, interact with one another, whinge, cry.. Their grammar and english use is not a concern!

 

[Black knight]

I hate how you come on here and the main guys just give you the same advice and want everyone to be the same !!!!
Be bold be different

 

[joop]

I hate how you come on here and the main guys just give you the same advice and want everyone to be the same !!!!
Be bold be different

Then don't come on here....?

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

I hate how you come on here and the main guys just give you the same advice and want everyone to be the same !!!!
Be bold be different

Get O'Meara in, lock for Round 1.
Jamar #1 ruck easy.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Brad sheppard anyone think he could have a break out year

Had a break out year last year. Looks like he hasn't missed a beat in the off season and will only get better.
Will get a AA gig on half back this year but don't think his scoring will improve too much.
Hurn is the one who benefits most by having McKenzie and Brown back.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

I hate how you come on here and the main guys just give you the same advice and want everyone to be the same !!!!
Be bold be different

I think you'll find most of us will give a few examples of moves that will put you in the right direction then tell you to back your gut.

If your gut (footy knowledge) is a bit iffy, nothing short of copying our teams will help you.

 

[Black knight]

Had a break out year last year. Looks like he hasn't missed a beat in the off season and will only get better.
Will get a AA gig on half back this year but don't think his scoring will improve too much.
Hurn is the one who benefits most by having McKenzie and Brown back.

Take there first game out doesn't count so much 2nd game 112
3rd 87
I think he will come into
His own this year

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Take there first game out doesn't count so much 2nd game 112
3rd 87
I think he will come into
His own this year

He very well could mate. He's a safe pick and has gotten over his injured years.
Solid consistent scorer who will play 22 games and has a set role that he can grow into. Not a mr fix it like Yeo.

 

[Ambrosia]

Drop Hartley or Brown?

Brown scores pretty well when they actually play him backline.

Brown only had 50% game time he's undroppable considering his job security imo.

 

[Jiska]

Didn't you ask this already ? I posted it, but would be quite a few pages ago now. He played two's on Saturday, definitely didn't stand out, and in the last quarter got flattened by the Redlands ruckman, who by the way, is a monster. He was helped off by trainers and didn't come back on.

Don't think so, but missed the answer all the same. Thanks for the info, looks like he may be a downgrade option later rather than a starter. Cheers.

 

[Jiska]

I understand that Mr Jiska, but does it make it a better decision if the expensive rookie can be a keeper at D6, M8, F6? I suppose the potential is definitely there for a few of these <250g players but whether they play entire seasons is the other thing..

But i do agree, and is the reason i have steered clear of weitering..

Just A little devils advocate

Good point. If you think he'll be in your side come SC finals then worth the risk. Personally I don't think that will be the case hence my spending elsewhere but it is all a guessing game, isn't it?

 

[Jiska]

I hate how you come on here and the main guys just give you the same advice and want everyone to be the same !!!!
Be bold be different

Don't start with Dusty - the guy is a hack.

 

[pincrusher]

Don't start with GAJ - the guy is a hack.

EFA

 

[Jiska]

EFA

First picked. Has never left my side.

 

[DraftPunk]

Schoenmakers time as a defender is over.
Short of their being no alternative due to injury, he is now a forward. Played all his junior footy as a forward so not surprising really.
Even more the case with Roughead out.

They would love Spangher to get his body right. He would be plan A. But he hasn't been fit for more than 12 months now so I won't be holding my breath. Alternatives are very raw and untried. Brand and Heatherley the likely 2. Looks as though Brand is in the lead.
I think ideally they would like to play another tall so will probably give it chance. If it doesn't work however, they know they can survive playing smaller. Both Howe and Litherland are cllose to 190cm and offer much more with ball in hand. Don't really play like genuine KPP though.

If Brand plays Rd1, it's possible Howe doesn't

Gibson too risky to start with then? Sounds like he'll be needed as a lock down a bit.

 

[pincrusher]

I haven't been around for a few days. Is there a link to any sort of formguide that shows all the SC scores and averages for the NAB challenge?

 

[stevebbb]

I haven't been around for a few days. Is there a link to any sort of formguide that shows all the SC scores and averages for the NAB challenge?

Herald Sun did one last year, hopefully they do it again this year. If so, I'd imagine it'll be out some time this week

 

[Jiska]

I haven't been around for a few days. Is there a link to any sort of formguide that shows all the SC scores and averages for the NAB challenge?

Jock Reynolds and SC Paige did them last year.

Scroll through this thread, don't trust those fools.

 

[pincrusher]

Jock Reynolds and SC Paige did them last year.

Scroll through this thread, don't trust those fools.

Cheers. Looks like I have a lot of reading to do.

 

[Jiska]

Cheers. Looks like I have a lot of reading to do.

Maybe you could be generous to the community and compile a list for us?

Use the search function http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/search/88682844/?q=Brisbane&t=post&o=date&c[thread]=1123921

 

[cdcanman]

Gibson too risky to start with then? Sounds like he'll be needed as a lock down a bit.

That would be my thinking. Just too much uncertainty.
If he consistently plays loose (or at least with little responsibility) then he can be a prime upgrade target for us all later in the year.

 

[pincrusher]

Maybe you could be generous to the community and compile a list for us?

Use the search function http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/search/88682844/?q=Brisbane&t=post&o=date&c[thread]=1123921

If I had the time I would. Generally only get the chance to catch up on here when I have days off.

Here's a start. No individual scores but totals and averages over the 3 games.

http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pre_season_supercoach

 

[Didstar]

Are the teams for the Saturday/Sunday matches released prior to the start of the Carlton Richmond game?