Poll NAFL 2018-19 - Round Ten

[Freight Train]

Poll will be open for 3 days.
Do not vote for yourself or ask people to vote for you. You will be penalised.
Vote once in each game - besides your own.
Home team image is on top.


***


South Perth Swans v Port Macquarie Mariners

Brunswick FC v Busselton Hornets

Gold Coast G-Force v Woolloongabba Mammoths

Alice Springs Pirates v Derwent River

Renmark Roosters v Adelaide Monarchs

Canberra Parliament v Anglesea Canaries

Perth Boomers v Waikato Tigers

Wellington Seawolves v Melbourne Foxes

​

 

[Andonis1997]

I hope that Dylan8 finishes 1st on the ladder. Otherwise we're all screwed in the finals series.

 

[Freight Train]

I hope that Dylan8 finishes 1st on the ladder. Otherwise we're all screwed in the finals series.

que?

 

[Andonis1997]

que?

That away kit is the most beautiful thing I've seen on BigFooty.

 

[Freight Train]

That away kit is the most beautiful thing I've seen on BigFooty.

His whole set this season, IMO, is one of the best of any team in NAFL history. So simple and classic, great logo mark, great colour schemes and yeah.

 

[Barrybran]

His whole set this season, IMO, is the best of any team in NAFL history. So simple and classic, great logo mark, great colour schemes and yeah.

Plus he's rocking the dad bod harder than Jeremy McGovern

 

[Barrybran]

Alright, feedback time. I know my design is dark (my computer settings are different from my phone settings) but I'm surprised at some of the names voting for Woollongabba over Gold Coast. What am I missing here?

 

[Freight Train]

Alright, feedback time. I know my design is dark (my computer settings are different from my phone settings) but I'm surprised at some of the names voting for Woollongabba over Gold Coast. What am I missing here?

Personally, I think there's just a massive lack of contrast or pop - maybe because the design is dark, but yeah. Something about WG's orange and pink on the brown base really pops, and I quite like the wordmark.

 

[Barrybran]

Personally, I think there's just a massive lack of contrast or pop - maybe because the design is dark, but yeah. Something about WG's orange and pink on the brown base really pops, and I quite like the wordmark.

Fair enough. I've seen my design on my phone and it's night and day, pardon the pun.

 

[Sparkle]

Alright, feedback time. I know my design is dark (my computer settings are different from my phone settings) but I'm surprised at some of the names voting for Woollongabba over Gold Coast. What am I missing here?

I must admit, I'm not sure why Woollongabba is polling ahead of the G-Force. The G-Force is not the best design in the comp (it's hard to back up a winning NAFLR design with something original in the NAFL that can achieve similar success) yet I think it's much better overall than Woollongabba

In regards to feedback on your design, I'd look at presenting the jumper in a similar way to Busselton, where the design is bright, clear and easy to see. Unfortunately, the G-Force design gets lost in the whole presentation, and even switching to a brighter colour scheme (such as going from light blue to cyan) will liven the whole design up a little. Also, the back of the jumper and the way it's presented and the use of two blues means everything gets lost within each other

 

[Andonis1997]

Alright, feedback time. I know my design is dark (my computer settings are different from my phone settings) but I'm surprised at some of the names voting for Woollongabba over Gold Coast. What am I missing here?

I'm just really not a fan of the shield shape you've tried. And it's such a big part of the design that it ruins the rest of the kit and colours for mine..

 

[Freight Train]

Fair enough. I've seen my design on my phone and it's night and day, pardon the pun.

It does look better on my phone I'll admit, but there's nothing really "highlighted". I preferred the scheme in reverse last season when you won the Ressies, I think the small amounts of sky on the navy base really popped, where as it just doesn't seem to work as well inversed. This is where my reasoning for voting for the Mammoths takes shape in this - the colours really pop, and the monogram really stands out. I'd have gone with a black base though, tbh.

 

[caloschwaby]

I must admit, I'm not sure why Woollongabba is polling ahead of the G-Force. The G-Force is not the best design in the comp (it's hard to back up a winning NAFLR design with something original in the NAFL that can achieve similar success) yet I think it's much better overall than Woollongabba

In regards to feedback on your design, I'd look at presenting the jumper in a similar way to Busselton, where the design is bright, clear and easy to see. Unfortunately, the G-Force design gets lost in the whole presentation, and even switching to a brighter colour scheme (such as going from light blue to cyan) will liven the whole design up a little. Also, the back of the jumper and the way it's presented and the use of two blues means everything gets lost within each other

He could probably achieve just the same by making the background a lighter shade of blue to create a better contrast.
I quite like G-Force's two-shaded design personally.

 

[Barrybran]

It does look better on my phone I'll admit, but there's nothing really "highlighted". I preferred the scheme in reverse last season when you won the Ressies, I think the small amounts of sky on the navy base really popped, where as it just doesn't seem to work as well inversed. This is where my reasoning for voting for the Mammoths takes shape in this - the colours really pop, and the monogram really stands out. I'd have gone with a black base though, tbh.

I agree but thought I'd take the risk to avoid the sameness factor.

He could probably achieve just the same by making the background a lighter shade of blue to create a better contrast.
I quite like G-Force's two-shaded design personally.

The shades of blue are identical to the shades I used last season. I should have known better on this part as Scorch highlighted this when I was going through it last season. Good to have it pointed out though.

 

[Dylan8]

Split hairs in that match up

 

[magpienato]

Love the Monarchs' jumper
Would've gone with red shorts instead but it's SA so it makes sense to have a splash of blue.

 

[austinnn]

Alright, feedback time. I know my design is dark (my computer settings are different from my phone settings) but I'm surprised at some of the names voting for Woollongabba over Gold Coast. What am I missing here?

There's too much going on for my tastes, especially with two such similar colours. I'd have gone with either the shield or the stripes but not both. If the stripes then probably thicker more AFL style. It seems more like a NRL top to me.

 

[El_Scorcho]

I think contrast is your biggest issue BarryBran. Contrast is difficult with the double blue colour scheme unless you really make an effort to make your navy dark and sky bright. I don't know whether using a bit more white might make things pop a bit more? I'd definitely push your navy darker and your sky brighter though. Contrast is far more important on a screen than it might be in real life as well.

The Mammoths entry is really good though. Really interesting colour scheme, clever and unique designs, clean template and everything pops. No real shame in losing to it.

 

[Freight Train]

Less than 24 hours to go and we have a tied game and two games only a couple of votes apart!

Please get voting if you haven’t already.

 

[TheBug]

I really like the Tigers jumper, but reckon with some minor tweaks would be even better;

- tone down the background image (it detracts from the actual jumper)
&
- run an all yellow back

Love it otherwise. Just my 2c.