Poll NAFL Reserves 2018-19 - Round 7

[Bacon Warrior]

Poll will be open for 3 days.
Do not vote for yourself or ask people to vote for you. You will be penalised.
Vote once in each game - besides your own.​

Home team image is on top.​

​

***

Whittlesea Eagles vs Newcastle Black Diamonds

Broome Mavericks vs Mt Gambier Volcanoes

Ringwood Rockets vs Canberra Griffins

Dandenong Vikings vs Greensborough Golds

Camberwell Stallions vs Great Southern Sharks

Mentone Stars vs Floreat Fire

Townsville Bullsharks vs Toowoomba Tsars

Palmerston Leatherbacks vs Geelong Dragons

​

 

[Barrybran]

Your jumper just needs some tinsel Prison bar Pete

 

[magpienato]

What is going on with the Mt. Gambier jumper

 

[Prison bar Pete]

What is going on with the Mt. Gambier jumper

a bit of fun; playing with Paint 3D. Hopefully Bacon Warrior doesn't need to use it too often

 

[Freight Train]

a bit of fun; playing with Paint 3D. Hopefully Bacon Warrior doesn't need to use it too often

tbh, we're all living in 2018 while you're living in 3018.

 

[Prison bar Pete]

2017
It was an enjoyable challenge to progress from the 2D design to the 3D one conceptually and actually, and whilst I'll probably not continue with this idea in future NAFL Reserves I'll still be tinkering away at it.

 

[Fizzler]

View attachment 585483View attachment 585485
2017
It was an enjoyable challenge to progress from the 2D design to the 3D one conceptually and actually, and whilst I'll probably not continue with this idea in future NAFL Reserves I'll still be tinkering away at it.

I for one enjoyed seeing a developed version of last years one.

 

[magpienato]

View attachment 585483View attachment 585485
2017
It was an enjoyable challenge to progress from the 2D design to the 3D one conceptually and actually, and whilst I'll probably not continue with this idea in future NAFL Reserves I'll still be tinkering away at it.

Knowing it's based off that I probably would've given it a vote for the meme

 

[FootyGuy13]

My first win in this comp and I feel like it wasn't warranted. Maybe it's due to the fact that, going off everyone else's reactions, it was just less worse than my opponent. At least he was more imaginative than what I was with my clash jumper.

Gonna be interesting to see how I go in Rounds 9-11

 

[magpienato]

My first win in this comp and I feel like it wasn't warranted. Maybe it's due to the fact that, going off everyone else's reactions, it was just less worse than my opponent. At least he was more imaginative than what I was with my clash jumper.

Gonna be interesting to see how I go in Rounds 9-11

I think yours has the potential to become a great identity. Personally The design is great, just the colours are holding you back.

 

[Fizzler]

My first win in this comp and I feel like it wasn't warranted. Maybe it's due to the fact that, going off everyone else's reactions, it was just less worse than my opponent. At least he was more imaginative than what I was with my clash jumper.

Gonna be interesting to see how I go in Rounds 9-11

Are you Brooke? If so, I absolutely love the colour scheme and I think the design is a good start and can really be fleshed out. Only issue is execution. Probably just a tad pixellated right now.

 

[Prison bar Pete]

My first win in this comp and I feel like it wasn't warranted. Maybe it's due to the fact that, going off everyone else's reactions, it was just less worse than my opponent. At least he was more imaginative than what I was with my clash jumper.

Gonna be interesting to see how I go in Rounds 9-11

You won it fair & square mate. I like your design and look forward to seeing it develop over time. Cheers.

 

[Sparkle]

My first win in this comp and I feel like it wasn't warranted. Maybe it's due to the fact that, going off everyone else's reactions, it was just less worse than my opponent. At least he was more imaginative than what I was with my clash jumper.

Gonna be interesting to see how I go in Rounds 9-11

Don't get yourself too down - a win is a win, and it's always good to get on the board.

In terms of the design, and as others have said, it absolutely has the potential to become a powerhouse, but the execution is what holds it back (not that I should be talking about execution - probably my weak point)

Clearing up the pixelation is always a good start wherever possible, because while the design may look good in theory, it's hard to pick a pixelated design over the realistic templates used by teams such as Whittlesea and Camberwell. Unfortunately, these design competitions don't just run on the jumper, but the entire

Also, little things that help make a design look like a real guernsey is what is holding back the design. Just fixing up the placement, size and type of logo used is important in tying together a design (for example, using the longer Kmart logo and lifting the Bunnings logo). What you have done well is reverse the Bunnings logo - good job!

Keep at it, there's no need for a major overhaul, just fine tuning to help make the design better and to grow the identity

 

[cannavo]

Golds with a form slump

 

[FootyGuy13]

I think yours has the potential to become a great identity. Personally The design is great, just the colours are holding you back.

I wanted to use green, I just couldn't get it to work. I'd either look too dark or too fluorescent.

Are you Brooke?

Can confirm, I am not Brooke nor do I know a Brooke.

Clearing up the pixelation is always a good start wherever possible, because while the design may look good in theory, it's hard to pick a pixelated design over the realistic templates used by teams such as Whittlesea and Camberwell. Unfortunately, these design competitions don't just run on the jumper, but the entire

Yeah, I think I'm gonna have to wrap my head around pixelation. Was avoiding it due to not quite trusting myself in executing it properly