Competition NAFL Reserves - Hub Thread

[just_kick_it]

Where the fudge have those scores come from!! Its sure not the poll!!

 

[Greater Gattsby]

Where the fudge have those scores come from!! Its sure not the poll!!

They are getting fixed up by lmach, we had some technical difficulties in the office.

 

[Dylan8]

NM Design seeking a bit of clarification regarding the forfeit

 

[Greater Gattsby]

NM Design seeking a bit of clarification regarding the forfeit

Logan Heat had not sent their team sheet to the umpires, and hence they forfeited the game.

As a result:
- Logan Heat receive:

• A reprimand from the board at the NAFL Reserves
• 0 premiership points and 0 points for and against

- Bayside Tide receive:

• 2 premiership points and 9 points for and against
• A cheap bottle of plonk

The NAFL reserves commitee decided as a collective that this was the fairest way to deal with the situation.
Regards,
NMD
Chairman of NAFL Reserves

 

[Dylan8]

Hardly fair, i wasn't given any chance to compete for the full 4 points when the onus was on Logan Heat.

also, a goon sack is hardly reasonable compensation

 

[just_kick_it]

They are getting fixed up by lmach, we had some technical difficulties in the office.

aha! Thats cool Im looking at it and thinking WTF happened. I thought I had it in the bag.

 

[Greater Gattsby]

aha! Thats cool Im looking at it and thinking WTF happened. I thought I had it in the bag.

The ladder is correct, however.

 

[Greater Gattsby]

Hardly fair, i wasn't given any chance to compete for the full 4 points when the onus was on Logan Heat.

also, a goon sack is hardly reasonable compensation

This rule was decided before round 1, by the committee and we will review it at the end of the season. But for now, the rule stays.

Considering I could have given both of you 0 premiership points and 0 points for and against, I believe your franchise did very well out of this.
Regards,
NMD
Chairman of NAFL Reserves

 

[Dylan8]

Not happy. This isn't be the last you'll be hearing about this situation.

Regards,
Dylan
Chairman of Bayside FC

 

[just_kick_it]

I know your running this comp NM but I found this in the 2012 Laws of AFL

consequence of
forfeiture
Where a Team forfeits a Match, the following shall apply:
(a)
the points for the Match shall be awarded to the Team
who did not forfeit the Match;

then it goes on to talk about complicated maths to work out the percentage which I dont think is really neccessary. I guess if you keep it at 9 votes for and against or bump it up to 14 and 14 because thats around about the total amount of votes from each match up this week.
But it is up to you, thats just my 2 cents worth.

 

[Dylan8]

Ganty knows whats up

 

[4321]

NM Design
Dylan8 is right it should be a full 4 points and a win to the Bayside Tide as Logan Heat Forfeited

 

[lmach]

Where the fudge have those scores come from!! Its sure not the poll!!

Needs more exclamation marks!!

 

[Greater Gattsby]

NM Design
Dylan8 is right it should be a full 4 points and a win to the Bayside Tide as Logan Heat Forfeited

But what if he wasn't going to win?

It isn't fair on the other teams that fought hard for their wins.

Tide got the 2 points and that isn't going to change. It's done.

 

[Greater Gattsby]

I know your running this comp NM but I found this in the 2012 Laws of AFL

then it goes on to talk about complicated maths to work out the percentage which I dont think is really neccessary. I guess if you keep it at 9 votes for and against or bump it up to 14 and 14 because thats around about the total amount of votes from each match up this week.
But it is up to you, thats just my 2 cents worth.

Well, lucky it's NAFL then, not AFL.

 

[4321]

But what if he wasn't going to win?

It isn't fair on the other teams that fought hard for their wins.

Tide got the 2 points and that isn't going to change. It's done.

wat about then to make it even a game Logan V bayside sometime next week (Just something)

 

[Bacon Warrior]

wat about then to make it even a game Logan V bayside sometime next week (Just something)

No. Tide has 2 points and you forfeited. End of story.

 

[Dylan8]

I honestly can't comprehend not getting the maximum points for a circumstances i can't control

 

[4321]

No. Tide has 2 points and you forfeited. End of story.

So are infering that i am trying to take the points off Bayside and try to get 4 myself NO THAT IS NOT WHAT IM DOING. Read my other post

NM Design
Dylan8 is right it should be a full 4 points and a win to the Bayside Tide as Logan Heat Forfeited

I thought it was wrong for bayside not to get 4 points now ur trying to make it look like im being completely unfair JEEZ!

 

[just_kick_it]

Needs more exclamation marks!!

here youz goez!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!111!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Well, lucky it's NAFL then, not AFL.

Yeh I guess so, just trying to look out for everybody!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

 

[Bryce_Jersey17]

Oh far out!
Guys, the rules THAT WERE AGREED ON BEFORE IT STARTED said that in the case of a forfeit, two points will be awarded. This is because one team didn't turn up, so therefore the other team does not play and still receives points. No one said that 4321 is stealing points, Dylan8, at least be happy that you are getting points. Im sure that any of the other teams that lost would be happy to take your place and have 2 points. Your team did not play, but were inconvenienced, so you get compensated. You didn't play a full game and so you don't get 4 points

 

[lmach]

You also have the advantage of not having to travel to a place like Logan.

 

[4321]

You also have the advantage of not having to travel to a place like Logan.

You saying there is somthing wrong with Logan

 

[Klim]

You saying there is somthing wrong with Logan

If your a Bogan you're from Logan?

 

[lmach]

You saying there is somthing wrong with Logan

Yes