Nathan Buckley vs. Ryan O'Keefe

[Bleed Red Cheer]

It's tough to argue with success.

 

[carn_the_cattas]

It's tough to argue with success.

Ok, Buckely's success: a Brownlow, a Norm Smith, Rising Star, a captain, an All-Australian, played for Australia in the international rules, 6 B&F and few other awards. I'd say thats individual success. Obviously he hasn't won a premiership but thats not his fault.

 

[The Mighty Port Power]

It's tough to argue with success.

Team wise yes, but Buckley is exponentially better than O'Keefe, anyone that thinks differently obviously has dismissive knowledge of footy.

 

[The Mighty Port Power]

(Most) Sydney supporters and people who don't understand the game of football.

Neil Curley likes to refer to Sydney supporters as "Plastic people", cant understand why though