I understand that but he's been rehab-ing the same injury for 2.5yrs regardless of who's list he was on. The way some people have posted on this thread make out like Collingwood deliberately injured him & sabotaged his career. I'm pretty certain the Pies would love him to be running up & down the wings for them just as much as we want him to do so for us
I know the popular rhetoric here is that Collingwood was reckless, but we essentially didn't risk playing him for 90% of the two years he was with us. We took a conservative approach with him, even if he thinks we didn't.
I'm not sure what St Kilda are doing differently in regards to his rehab, but it's got to be very worrying for their fitness staff that the pattern of the past two years seems to be continuing despite their best efforts.

